Monte Masterson: regarding people’s interesting in the Big Agnes tents.
Don’t underestimate people’s reluctance to use trekking pole supported (aka non-freestanding) shelters.
This spring I ran a “intro to lightweight backpacking” class for my local backpacking club in SE Michigan. I
We had set up my Tarptent Stratospire 2, ZPacks Hexamid Twin Tent, Tarptent Notch, a Borah Gear “Borahgami” tarp (no longer in production. It was a rectangular tarp with a simple triangular door on each end), a Nemo Dagger 2p, and several Big Agnes Copper Spur UL2s and UL1s.
The Nemo Dagger and BA tents were BY FAR the most popular. A lot of people can’t get their head around the idea of trekking pole supported shelters. I don’t know what is it that scares them off so much.
I will admit that setting up the Hexamid Twin is “finicky” and I don’t like the number of guylines it requires. It seems like someone is always tripping over one of the corner guylines, even me!
And even though I’ve now had my Tarptent SS2 for at least two seasons, there are still times when I can’t seem to get the pitch completely square. I’ll look at the floor of the inner and there will be a “fold” of fabric running diagonally, indicating it’s not correct.
So, I guess I get it. Especially on less than ideal ground, a self-standing tent is a lot easier to pitch, so I can see why people would be highly interested in a tent that’s self standing and UL.