Good luck with your recording Jerry. The lower limit of human hearing is about 20Hz, so few common recording devices are likely to be reliable down there.
We have a subduction zone a bit off the west coast. I doubt moving that much rock is silent, however taffy-like the subducting rock might be at those temperatures and pressures. I also doubt that the sound would present itself at the surface uniformly due to intervening geology. Points of resonance and focus would be likely for the low frequency, crustally modified sounds. So, one of the Earth’s low frequency “screams” may be an explanation.
An excuse to get a really good mic (and a recording oscilloscope app for your phone) and to go hiking in a lot of places world-wide to gather data.