Help me pick a rock climbing /hiking jacket

I’ve used the Arcteryx Proton FL exactly for this purpose. This is the most comfortable climbing shell layer I’ve ever worn – I wear it over a short sleeve Capilene Cool shirt on mild days and a lightweight merino wool hoody when it’s cold.

My got-o for ice climbing in most conditions are: lightweight merino base layer, Patagonia R1 hoodie, and an Arc’teryx Squamish wind shirt. This is usually the most I wear when I’m climbing. Then I have a belay parka (the MEC Tango) to throw over everything while I’m belaying or eating lunch or whatever. Something I’ve been experimenting with is using Polartec Alpha Direct (a Macpac Nitro hoodie) in lieu of my R1. So far it seems like it’s working well. Wind does go through it much more easily, so a wind shirt becomes even more important, but it’s just about as warm at less weight. HTH.

@Ryan – Thanks.  Has the Merino+proton FL kept you warm all the way down to 45 in the shade/wind?

@S Long Thanks. I am going to try a similar setup tomorrow NF future fleece LT+Kinesis+houdini

Does Marmot still make their Alpha 60 hoody? I have one and like it a lot for stop and go activities.

Not sure if this is what you had in mind but it is on sale :)

https://www.marmot.com/men/jackets-and-vests/insulated-and-down/mens-alt-hb-hoody/AFS_195115061258.html

This one (not sure if they have any in stock, you might need to try other online vendors who sell Marmot):

https://www.marmot.com/sale/men/jackets-and-vests/mens-alpha-60-jacket/AFS_889169544187.html

Looks like Marmot discontinued that jacket. A shame! And when I called Marmot to ask whether they have a similar product the phone # connects to a call center, in some far off country, with no actual knowledge of the products, just reading off the web page. Bummer.