Topic

Help Choosing Down jacket and Synthethic jacket

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
Marcus BPL Member
PostedOct 26, 2020 at 2:56 pm

Hey Guys,
I am going to pick up a nice synthetic/active jacket and a down/stationary jacket for my winter hikes, and would like them to double as an around town jacket reasonably well.

I live near Ojai, CA just outside the Los Padres National Forest. I often hike between 3000 and 6000 feet around Sespe Creek, Pine Mountain, and Mckinnley mountain (north of santa barbara, not the famous McKinnley) all in the LPNF. In the winter 20-35* is pretty typical with varying wind, from calm to 20+ mph. I hike far less distance than many of you on here, but can expect do commonly do 5-10 miles in an outing with occasional 10-20 mile days. Being super ultralight is not a big concern, but lighter is always better.

Around Ojai the winter is often 35-50*ish and it would be nice if these jackets could double as an around town jacket when its colder. Above 50ish and I’ll wear a fleece.

For the Down jackets I am most considering the Arcteryx Cerium LT, Montbell Alpine Light Parka, or a Feathered Friends Eos. Any others I should consider? Or of those 3 how do you see the pros/cons/weight to warmth? It seems like the Alpine Light has the best value, while the Eos tempts me the most but is pricey. The Cerium LT seems very nice but I’m worried about how fragile a 7d shell would be.

The Synthetic jackets I’m mostly considering a Arcteryx Proton LT or Montbell Thermawrap Classic. I have no reference for either of these and will likely buy blind. Which would you prefer, why, and what else should I consider?

For other supporting gear at my disposal, I have smart wool base layers, various wind shells, an Arcteryx Alpha FL rain jacket, konseal mid layer, LEAF Naga hoody mid layer, and a couple other wool and fleece layers, nothing major though. I’ve been spoiled by SoCal weather and low elevation hikes, but have been here a couple years and its time to start branching out and up.

Last thought, does Montbell or Feathered Friends do a good black friday sale? we’re close enough I could wait a month if it means 25%+ off

Thanks for any thoughts!

 

 

Marcus BPL Member
PostedOct 26, 2020 at 3:00 pm

Lets try a bigger comparison pic, or a smaller crop in case it forces resizing

PostedOct 27, 2020 at 7:05 am

For the Down jackets I am most considering the Arcteryx Cerium LT, Montbell Alpine Light Parka, or a Feathered Friends Eos

I’ve had a Montbell Alpine Light for the last 6+ years. It’s a nicely warm jacket. I ordered an Arcteryx Cerium LT this past spring, but sent it back. Not nearly the warmth/loft of the Montbell. Really, pretty disappointing given its cost. The FF Eos would be my first choice if cost is no object.

No, I’ve never seen FF or Montbell have sales, other than Montbell will closeout past season’s colors and styles.

My favorite synthetic is the Patagonia Micro Puff… I find it warmer than the Nano Puff. I don’t have any experience with the other two you mention.

PostedOct 27, 2020 at 10:07 am

Synthetic- I’ve had the ArcTeryx Atom LT hoody for many years.  Love it, can’t kill it, pretty much live in it around town.

Down- Last year added a FF Eos hoody to the mix & am very impressed & pleased with that jacket.  Considered the same ones you did.  It is pricey, but the warm, weight & compression are excellent, as you’d expect from FF.  Buy once cry once worked in this case.

Hope to add either a FF Tanager 20 or Flicker soon to go add to my Eos/sleep system.

Hope that helps.

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
Loading...