My experience with hand-cranked lights and radios is that it is really only viable / preferable if it is a VERY low-power device AND it will sit for years letting normal batteries go flat.
For handheld lights, it only ever made sense after LED lights were produced. Â We had some hand-crank lights for the kids to read in the backseat on their (dark, Alaskan winter) ride to school. Â Because the battery-powered lights all got left on and discharged while the hand-cranked ones gave a few minutes of reading between cranking and the next chapter of Harry Potter was sufficient motivation.
The other reasonable usage I’ve seen is hand-crank for 1) the earthquake / flood / power failure / Y2K scenario because if you really want to use a light or hear the news, you’ll bother to crank the light / radio and because leaving the radio play non-stop during a disaster is NOT helping anyone’s mental health or 2) an off-the-grid cabin dweller listening to Art Bell on Coast to Coast America discussing alien abductions and government coverups in part because when they’re too tired to stay up, the radio will go off in a few minutes.
But what if you REALLY needed to send a text / voice call in an emergency and your phone battery was dead? Â Then a minimal external battery will do more with less weight than any hand-crank device, as long as you NEVER use it until you really need it. Â Compared to this unit’s 15 ounces, you could carry a serious USB battery pack with a built in light.
Going to be in bush Africa for 6 months? Â Just bring a small solar panel. Â And you want a “belt&suspenders” approach – yeah, maybe one of these. Â Or, better yet, an additional solar panel/battery set-up.