My old Marmot Essence jacket (purchased new in 2009) needs to be replaced. The WPB membrane on the interior is peeling off in various high-abrasion areas, such as around the hood/neck join area.
I was considering the Outdoor Research Helium II (which uses Pertex as the WPB membrane). However, I’ve read several reviews that say that it wets out trivially, and that it’s basically expensive and useless. Then in other places, I’ve seen this jacket come recommended (including at the bottom of Ryan Jordan’s review of the Hyperlite Mountain Gear Shell Jacket, from about 2 years ago).
I live in Arizona, and most often would be using this jacket to carry as a “just in case I get caught in weather” jacket, a wind break, or to throw on if I have to go out to the car in the rain. In other words, really probably not needing it for extended heavy rain exposure, like on the PCT or anything like that.
I was happy with the performance of the Marmot Essence – it suited my needs very well. Can I expect similar performance with the OR Helium II jacket?


