Topic

Epicurean / Cone / Esbit stove data

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
PostedFeb 7, 2016 at 10:18 pm

I finished a home made cone for a grease pot today.  I wanted to get some data on how fast it would boil 2 cups of water.  My previous experience was with a primus eta power pot with a heat exchanger.  I did not write things down, but my memory tells me that with this cone and a different stove setup (not the Epicurean made by Flatcat Gear) it was around 8 minutes for 2 cups.

Today I ran two tests.  Did this outside at 60F, no wind and basically sea level.  The first was 2 cups of water to rolling boil in 6:30, at least that was when I heard it and lifted the top. That used 10 of 12g of 2 round Couglans fuel,  epicurean stove by Flatcat gear and home made cone with a grease pot.  The lid is the grease pot strainer with foil covering the holes.  Decided to try again and this time measured the starting water temperature at 59.4 F.  I started 2 fresh Couglans tabs and did a few things.  When I returned, I could see the flames licking around the bottom of the pot through the holes in my cone.  I decided to peak at 5;18 to discover that I had already achieved a rolling boil, but was not seeing the steam due to either darkness or who knows.  This time I had 4g of fuel left over.  Earlier I did try boiling 2 cups on 1 Couglans tab to no avail.

But, the first tab was laid flat side down.  When I burned 2 tabs, I had them round side down and side by side to fit better in the Epicurean.  I am starting to wonder if I do 1 tab on the round side if I might just get the two cups to boil.  Not trying this tonight, but maybe tomorrow.

I have read tons of threads about stoves and efficiencies, but not lately.  If you would like to share your experiences with esbit boil times have at it.

thanks, Matt

PostedFeb 14, 2016 at 1:07 am

 

Try using a Brian Green Blog modified Gram Cracker fuel tablet holder. It holds all the liquid given off and allows it to burn. This almost doubles your tablet burn time!

PostedFeb 14, 2016 at 7:36 am

Thanks for the tip Eric.  I think the Epicrean stove does a good job of holding all the liquid as well.  I have gotten burn times for dry baking over 40 minutes with Coughlans fuel.  If the stoves is turned upside down it burns very slow.  Or if positioned as shown it burns rather fast as shown above.  Not sure how it compares to the BGET stove, that is on my wish list as well.

 

I am curious to see what other folks boil times are for 2 cups water and an esbit setup.  Not that I am in a super hurry for water to boil, but I was pleasently surprised how quickly and efficiently this setup works.

Bob Moulder BPL Member
PostedFeb 14, 2016 at 9:32 am

The Esbit Thread de tutti Esbit threads!

With my MYOG set-up using an Open Country 3-cup aluminum pot I am able to boil 3 cups of water with one 14g Esbit tab (‘average’ conditions/parameters, yada-yada-yada).

IMO you’re in the right frame of mind when you mention that you’re ‘not in a super hurry’ because efficiency is not so much a function of time (well, okay, within reason) as it is the quantity of fuel burned to achieve a boil. So what if it takes 2 minutes more but consumes 4 grams less fuel?

Anyway, check out the thread linked above. All that testing and investigating turned me into a huge Esbit fan… for gentler 3-season trips, at least.

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
Loading...