EE enigma

I have both and never really noticed a difference.  I will say EE quilts, Enigma have been great quilts for me. Where do you plan to use it? What weather conditions? Under a small tarp? In a tent? Cowboy camping?

I trust natural down more than something that has been chemically treated.  There are many decades of experience with untreated down showing it performing well and having very long life…can’t say that about treated down.  If you are worried about water ingress, I think the water repelancy of the outer fabric would be more important…prevent the moisture from entering in the first place.

I have both a 30* Revelation and an 10* Enigma and agree with dirtbag, they are great quilts.

Western Mountaineering and Feathered Friends make some of the best down products available and they don’t use treated down for anything. Nunatak wrote up a article on their website noting that the treated down will degrade quicker and lose performance so while the performance may be better initially over the long term untreated down (that is properly cared for) will likely perform better or at least more consistently.

Thanks for the feedback. I do most of my trips in the Sierra and Trinity Alps between mid June and early September. Mostly July and August. In the late winter/spring we will sometimes go to the Northern California coast. I have both a  GG twin tarp and a Durston x-mid which I switch depending on conditions. Don’t cowboy camp often, but planning to get a Borah gear bivy that I can use under the tarp or for cowboy camping. I sleep a little to the cold side of normal, but not particularly cold. I have been trying to decide between 10 or 20 degrees. Also, thoughts on a draft collar. For an extra $10 it is a no brainer, but I see ee started their holiday sale  and stock gear is now 10% less. So the price difference is 10%+$10.

PS.. Borah Gear makes great gear! From bivies to tarps..

Here’s a quote from Nunatak’s website.

“Fall 2020 update: The quality and lofting ability of our treated HyperDry goose down is now on par with regular down, and we therefore apply the same amount to all products. We are in the process of updating all specs on the site.”

I strongly agree with the majority of respondents above.  Personally, I would not purchase treated down. Many business more knowledgeable than I are. not supportive of it.  I am also skeptical of the practical benefit even if it does provide that rather small amount of resistance that is claimed. I also have high confidence in Nunatak and have some of their stuff, but I still wouldn’t go treated.

I think the Nunatak statement is initial loft between treated vs untreated is essentially the same….but doesn’t address how durable the treated down will be in comparison to untreated over time. I opted for untreated in my Nunatak and other premier companies (Feathered Friends, Western Mountaineering, Valandre, El Coyote) only offer untreated.