Topic

Change my mind….errrr…I think…?

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
Brett R BPL Member
PostedOct 2, 2023 at 4:51 pm

Hey, y’all.  Tent conundrum (or…first world problem).  I own a Z-Packs AltaPlex.  Nice tent!  I use one hiking staff anyway so it’s a real nice fit.  I’m 5’9″ tall so…plenty of room in the tent except the occasional brush of my noggin sitting up or laying down.  Super light, packs easy, and I think it’s fairly simple to set up.  I just set it up in my yard to take sales pics of it and it was up in 3-4 minutes. Now…I’m not perfect every time setting it up, but I do OK…  There’s the occasional failure in set up, but it’s pretty rare.  The one thing that I really don’t like about the tent is it does, of course, have a tendency to collect condensation.  Nasty stuff!  I really don’t like condensation.  At all.  Really.

So….I’m thinking on going back the other direction to what I had in the past:  The Big Agnes Copper Spur 2 HV.  I like the freestanding aspect.  I love the two walls… less potential to have to deal with condensation.  I mean…not ZERO chance as I just saw out on a Sawtooth trip in Idaho last month, but far less potential.

Things I’m concerned about in making the switch.  1.)  Copper Spur is heavier.  2.) Sil nylon rainfly will stretch if sustained moisture is encountered with no real way to tighten it in it’s latest configuration from what I understand.  3.) Takes up a bit more space in my pack.

Things I’m excited about in making the switch:  1.) “Perfect” Pitch every time.  2.) Set it up and move it to a better spot if necessary (freestanding).  3.)  LESS CONDENSATION  4.) Rain fly star gazing option.  5.)  Slightly smaller footprint on the Copper Spur vs Altaplex.  Not much on paper, but when you consider all the stakes on the Altaplex it does take up a bit of real estate. 6.)  Fewer stakes to deal with.

So…  Y’all change my mind, please, before I put this thing on the market.  Or…maybe I don’t need my mind changed.  Really and truly it’s personal preference…I get that.  But I guess I’m just looking for opinions and personal experiences to consider.

Thanks!

Brett

PostedOct 2, 2023 at 4:54 pm

Why don’t you keep the Altaplex and use it on trips where condensation is not an issue so you can save weight. Maybe those trips will require you to carry more water and the weight savings of your Altaplex will be appreciated.

jscott Blocked
PostedOct 2, 2023 at 5:06 pm

I owned a Zpacks Hexamid solo plus and Fly Creek UL solo at the same time. (I’m dating myself…). I liked both tents. After using both, today I would opt for a double wall tent…in DCF. Say, the TT Notch Li, with a half solid wall. That wall blocks winds great and adds warmth. The double wall deals great with condensation. But it’s lighter than a sil nylon tent.

Yes, the ease of set up of a BA tent is nice. And every BA tent I’ve had has been bombproof. And yes, you can pick them up and move them once they’re set up. But how often does that happen?

The TT Notch li is reputed to be very good in storms. I use hiking poles though, and the OP only uses one staff. Still, you can get a very light dedicated pole for the TT, I believe. I did this for the Hexamid because I like to take day trips when out backpacking and use my hiking poles.

I totally understand your reasoning.

p.s, I hate the number three zippers on BA tents. This has been the biggest fail point for me.

Dan BPL Member
PostedOct 2, 2023 at 5:21 pm

I have been alternating between a Plexamid and a mass market double wall tent (Nemo Hornet 2P) for the last couple of years. I greatly prefer the single-wall trekking pole tent because of the weight difference, and I really don’t mind condensation too much, it generally just runs down the walls and if things are slightly damp, I don’t really care.

However, when I got another big dog, it was too crowded in the Plexamid, so I went back to using the Hornet, which I happened to have in the basement. It’s a nice tent, and much lighter and more compact than the Copper Spur, if you make the apples to apples comparison between the Hornet Elite and the Copper Spur UL versions (I think those are the right names).  It would be too small for two real people, but it’s very roomy for one person, and works well for me with one or two big dogs. The Copper Spur 2P is much more than I would need for one person, even with two big dogs. Granted, it might be hard to swallow buying another tent given that you already have the Big Agnes.

All of that said, I plan to buy a 2-person trekking pole single-wall tent and go back to that next year. Sad, because I like the Plexamid and it worked well for me with one small mellow dog.

 

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
Loading...