Garcia’s are heavier, but they open so much easier than bear vaults. I’ve own one since the late 90’s, long before Bear Vaults existed and who later had to redesign their lids several times due to bear compromising them. I agree with the statement, Who carries a quater in the backcountry!? This is an UL site after all. I personally use to carry a penny for the job as you aren’t going to notice the weight of it and it worked perfectly well. Then I discovered that my ladybug knife when closed, the blade part that sticks out of the handle was a perfect fit for opening it. That said, perhaps some of the issues people had with the Garcia come from the fact that they rented it (e.g. high use and abuse by people who despise having to use a bear can in the first place and don’t care what happens to it). I do know they retire rental units after awhile due to the wear and tear. My 20+ year old one is in great shape as I rarely use it, only carrying it when required, and I don’t have a habit of abusing my stuff.
For shorter trips, I use the bareboxer 101, which looks like a mini Garcia, but much lighter than any other non carbon fiber bear can due to its small size. Works great for holding about 3 days of food (for me) and will fit inside most of the smaller UL backpacks (unlike most of the fullsize ones).