Topic

Backpack Fit Problems – Can’t believe I’m asking for help to find a backpack

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
PostedSep 27, 2020 at 5:38 pm

I’ve hiked with my 4th backpack and may finally understand part of the fit problem: I’m short coupled and seem to have narrow shoulders. I do hope someone here has the same kinda issue and has found a off-the-shelf pack or suggestions that I should look into.

The most comfortable pack is 5.6 lbs and I’m trying to get down to 3 lbs. Attached photo shows the difference in the way the shoulder straps are secured. Left is the heavy, comfortable, Lowe Alpine, narrow straps, right is the Gregory Paragon 68, wider spread in the straps, pulls on my shoulder/arm joint.

Measured 16 in. torso. The Gregory Paragon was just fit at REI, all packed up for a this last weekend overnighter, the shoulder fit was questionable by the person that fit me.

I measured 3 latest packs, shoulder attachment to middle of the belt: Lowe Alpine, 14-15 inches(may need to lengthen). Gregory Paragon 16 inches, Flex Capacator 17.7 inches (too long).

Here’s my grocery list:

60 L. About 3 lb or less. Straight frame, not curved out much like Osprey’s.

Less than $200. I’ll stretch the cost and suck it up if I have to. Prefer REI because of dividends and gift cards and 2 packs are going to be returned.

I pack for temps 20 deg to 60 deg F and in the snow, with a tarp, and campfire.

Loops or straps to hang things: I sometimes carry 4 L of water, 1 lb saw, and extra bag on the outside with a light fireshield and DIY chair. Also a foam pad.

Carry weight varies: 3 mile hikes I might carry 35 lbs because no water source. Longer hikes I’m trying to keep the weight to 25 lbs.

Left Lowe Alpine Right Gregory

PostedSep 27, 2020 at 5:44 pm

If I have to go via the cottage industry I will, but I’m shy about the whole order/build/ship scenario. Getting something online and having it fit right isn’t  working out for me.

Dan BPL Member
PostedSep 27, 2020 at 8:50 pm

You may want to try some women-specific packs, e.g. Granite Gear Crown 2 si.

PostedSep 28, 2020 at 10:05 pm

No idea where you live, but in many areas there are shops that off a variety of packs that can be tried on, just like footwear.  You can bring a couple of pack-sized stuff sacks filled with the weight you expect to carry.  Without the weight, trying on an empty packs doesn’t say much.

Before I started making my own packs, that was the only approach that worked for me, and also saved a heck of a lot of money and costs of shipping back and forth.

PostedSep 29, 2020 at 3:45 pm

I’m in the MPLS/St. Paul area, so we have REI and Midwest Mountaineering, plus a couple others.

Last night I took what I’ve learned and went back to REI to try more packs. Test weight was 20 – 25 lbs.  The best fit that met my weight req of < 3 lbs was the REI Flash 55. Felt really good at 20 lbs.  We didn’t get to the women’s specific packs yet.

Side comment: I’m not at all confident I can learn to carry less and still be comfortable during northern MN shoulder seasons, but as I get older it’s either that or quit the multi day hikes.

PostedOct 2, 2020 at 4:34 am

I just picked up a Granite Gear Blaze 60 at Midwest Mountaineering here in the TC.  After a really detailed fitting I spent a good 40 minutes shopping with a total weight of about 25 lbs and started to forget I was wearing a pack.

 

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
Loading...