Andrew F,
It sounds from your posts that you are quite knowledgeable about Epic treatments. The Epic Malibu formerly used by Black Diamond was one of the very few WPB materials that would function at low enough humidity to be used to effectively deter condensation for a shelter wall. Black Diamond has had a newer material for some time, but reports suggest that it is not anywhere near as durable as the Malibu.
The issues with Malibu were its weight, close to 2 oz/yd2, and judging from tests done by Roger Caffin and others, it tended to fail badly over 1500mm HH, in that water comes through in large amounts. Some silnylons that test only to about the same point, at higher pressure allow only a few drops to pass through, up to various levels above 3000mm, where they fail badly also.
Also, I have found that some fabrics that test well for HH, if left in a stormy environment for several weeks will eventually lose water resistance and allow water to penetrate, creating a wet inner wall. So extended testing is required to fully ascertain the usefulness of a fabric for a shelter wall in areas where rain can be extended.
However, functional WPB fabric for a SUL shelter remains the golden fleece for tents. At least for those like me whose desire was whetted by the Malibu. So I'm interested in your views about the feasibility of WPB shelter fabric in the 1 oz/yd2 range. For example, GoLite had a material around 1.1oz/yd2 that it used for its Poncho Tarp that was supposed to be WPB at 1200mm HH, and a number of people reported luck with using it as a low tarp and experiencing minimal condensation. Others have used the 'Impetus' material for tarps, including one manufacturer; but after exposing it to extended rain, I'm doubtful whether it is water resistant enough for tents. Also, there was a link posted recently to a snippet about GTX' attempts to develop a WPB tent fabric, but it sounds as if in the early stages, and much remains to be worked out.
Are we chasing rainbows here, or is there some potential for an almost condensation free SUL single wall tent. I'd be very interested in yours and others' thoughts on this subject. Thanks.

