Topic

bulk down

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedNov 30, 2014 at 10:23 am

I've purchased that down from Wilderness Logics before. It was pretty good.

–B.G.–

todd BPL Member
PostedNov 30, 2014 at 10:27 am

Why no more water resistant down? Problems?

Bill Townsend BPL Member
PostedNov 30, 2014 at 10:55 am

In reading/researching some more, both here and various other places I think that I am also a bit of victim of the marketing hype. I note that Western Mountaineering (who I consider one of the best vendors) still hasn't jumped on board. I also noticed this little blurb recently added to Zpacks site:

"Water resistant down is just normal down that is washed with a water resistant treatment by the factory. In theory this treatment makes the down take longer to wet out, and may retain a little bit less water after being soaked, however real world results are hard to observe. The down still wets out after a while and you still need to be careful to keep your bag dry. I personally think that the benefits are very minor. We have also noticed that the treated down can be more clingy and can take more work to break apart clumps and fluff the bag up, which could result in cold spots if the bag isn't fluffed well.

It is for this reason that we have decided to streamline our production and discontinue WR down as a standard option as of November 2014."

In messing with my recent quilt more (850 WR from Ripstop by the roll) I do notice more hard clusters/clumps and a bit less "uhmph" from my project compared to some of the commercial (non-WR) bags I have. Granted its limited by my experience of one, but this recent bit from an experienced vendor (Zpacks) has made me rethink it a bit.

I'm hard on my stuff, but in thinking about it I can only think of a handful of times I have actually gotten stuff wet- although moisture build up is still an issue in the humid Midwest and East. The long term moisture is still a problem, but an unlofted (or overstuffed bag) is a bigger one. I also wonder about eventual accumulation of dust/dirt/etc. with the stickier product. I experienced very little trouble in stuffing my quilt as far as drifting down- despite working in an open room and being under an air vent while doing so. So the "clingy" argument is making sense to me.

I suppose if nothing else- the point has been made before- Ducks and geese spend their life in the water and seem to have gotten by just fine for quite some time without the help of two legged chemists.

I'm not swearing it off- more looking to try the regular stuff in the real world and see if it works fine for me. I may have been solving a problem I didn't have- especially if it reduces the effectiveness of the expensive down I purchase.

Be open to hearing more for sure.

BTW- tried a few of the old vendors and deals mentioned here but many of them are a bust or non-responsive- so that's why I was looking for an update.

PostedDec 1, 2014 at 8:47 am

Just received a 30% of code from Downlinens, thinking about ordering a pound of their 950Fp down with DWR, but they don't ship to europe, anybody know how big their packages are/how much the down is compressed? Trying to see if it would be worth using any of the US->europe forwarding services.

Bt.w If anybody else wants to use the code it's "CYBER30", only works today

Bill Townsend BPL Member
PostedDec 1, 2014 at 10:44 am

Ordered some up- heard good things about this source- sale price can't be beat.

FWIW- I ordered 12 ounces from RBTR and it shipped in a 3.5" x 12" x 14" USPS box. It was 850 fill WR down. I don't think a pound would be much bigger than a large pair of shoes.

PostedDec 1, 2014 at 11:10 am

Edvin,

Thanks for the heads up on their sale!

I recently ordered a pound of 800 WR from Downlinens. The box I received measures:
– Inches: 16 x 9.5 x 23
– CM: 41 x 24 x 59

The down is packaged in a large bag inside the box. It was lofted to take up almost all of the interior space, so I would say it is shipped only somewhat compressed but not at all significantly.

PostedDec 1, 2014 at 12:27 pm

Awesome, thanks alot! Shipping to sweden looks like it's going to be about $60 so evens out with the discount :)

PostedDec 12, 2014 at 11:15 am

When DWR treated down from a reliable DWR source like DownTek is available then we'll know DWR down has "arrived".

Kevin Beeden BPL Member
PostedDec 15, 2014 at 12:21 pm

> Ducks and geese spend their life in the water and seem to have gotten by just fine for quite some time without the help of two legged chemists.

But ducks and geese spend great deal of time attending to their down, which involves carefully distributing secreted oil into the down…

That's why seabirds treated for oil spillage (with very harsh detergents) cannot be released into the wild until they've had time to restore the waterproofing.

As part of the production process, down is cleaned of these waterproofing oils.

So the chemists are only trying to recreate what evolution perfected a long time ago…

ps. Ducks and geese only have two legs….

Bill Townsend BPL Member
PostedDec 18, 2014 at 10:12 am

Got my down in- good product- good packaging- easy to use. Package came with order number, lot number, and control number from what I assume was the original supplier.

So… I've always bought my down goods, so this is my first experience with the untreated down from the MYOG side. I made the Jerry Adams UQ and a few odd things with the treated stuff which got me interested in down again for MYOG needs.

850 fill treated vs 850 fill non-treated. Technically one from RBTR and one from Down Linens.

The difference is pretty substantial so far.
Stuffing- I was prepared by the horror stories, so the plain down wasn't much worse. I kept a dust buster handy and went slow. No huge mess despite reaching into a two pound bag in a workbench in a big open room. I lost a few grams to the room, fought it a bit in transfer and had an occasional mishap when I breathed too hard. Had a tough time getting it off of sweaty palms at times.

I had almost zero mess with the treated stuff, and no issues with transfer from the bag to measuring tray to project. Very little if any stuck to me or drifted away. I doubt I lost a gram on my last projects- had no issue "recycling" it either.

Stuffing- the Treated stuff was easy to ball up with a fist and move around. the non-treated instantly lofted and constantly tried to escape.

Clump busting-
It took me almost 4 hours of no heat/four tennis ball beating dryer time to get the treated bag to loft up, and even then, a small few clumps can be felt, even now a few weeks later with the bag sitting around more or less uncompressed.

By massive contrast- the plain down took about two minutes of hand massaging and spreading in each baffle, literally four good shakes in each direction- and was fully lofted almost instantly. I can feel no hard spots, lumps, clumps, etc.

The point-
Though it's one man's opinion, and not even on an apples to apples project-
There is definitely something to the clumping and poor recovery argument in regards to treated down. Even when really balling up and smashing my new quilt- it's up and at em in 15 minutes, and 80% there almost as soon as I un stuff it. The treated stuff isn't even close in that regard. I would need to increase overfill by a good bit to come close to the same loft.

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
Loading...