Got my down in- good product- good packaging- easy to use. Package came with order number, lot number, and control number from what I assume was the original supplier.
So… I've always bought my down goods, so this is my first experience with the untreated down from the MYOG side. I made the Jerry Adams UQ and a few odd things with the treated stuff which got me interested in down again for MYOG needs.
850 fill treated vs 850 fill non-treated. Technically one from RBTR and one from Down Linens.
The difference is pretty substantial so far.
Stuffing- I was prepared by the horror stories, so the plain down wasn't much worse. I kept a dust buster handy and went slow. No huge mess despite reaching into a two pound bag in a workbench in a big open room. I lost a few grams to the room, fought it a bit in transfer and had an occasional mishap when I breathed too hard. Had a tough time getting it off of sweaty palms at times.
I had almost zero mess with the treated stuff, and no issues with transfer from the bag to measuring tray to project. Very little if any stuck to me or drifted away. I doubt I lost a gram on my last projects- had no issue "recycling" it either.
Stuffing- the Treated stuff was easy to ball up with a fist and move around. the non-treated instantly lofted and constantly tried to escape.
Clump busting-
It took me almost 4 hours of no heat/four tennis ball beating dryer time to get the treated bag to loft up, and even then, a small few clumps can be felt, even now a few weeks later with the bag sitting around more or less uncompressed.
By massive contrast- the plain down took about two minutes of hand massaging and spreading in each baffle, literally four good shakes in each direction- and was fully lofted almost instantly. I can feel no hard spots, lumps, clumps, etc.
The point-
Though it's one man's opinion, and not even on an apples to apples project-
There is definitely something to the clumping and poor recovery argument in regards to treated down. Even when really balling up and smashing my new quilt- it's up and at em in 15 minutes, and 80% there almost as soon as I un stuff it. The treated stuff isn't even close in that regard. I would need to increase overfill by a good bit to come close to the same loft.