At around 15-20F, I switch from trail runners and GoreTex socks to using waterproof mukluks along with vapor barriers. Here’s a post in my blog where I go into more detail:
http://bushcraftscience.blogspot.com/2010/12/footwear-for-really-cold-weather.html
These are definitely for those who like to experiment and don’t mind making their own gear and doing the extra work required to find just the right fit or performance. They work ok with my snowshoe bindings, but that may not be true of stiffer and harder bindings.
I think I actually like the knee-length boots better because the shorter ones fit almost too tight around my leg. But, Tingley also makes the shorter boot with built-in traction spikes, making that an interesting option in icy conditions. All of the natural rubber boots have better than average traction on ice.
I think I’d like a soft duffle sock made from fleece or wool better than the stiffer mukluk liners. I’m going to make some and experiment with those this winter.