Topic

wind shirt vs waterproof shell

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
PostedNov 25, 2014 at 12:52 pm

Hi all,

I'm gearing up for a trip to Patagonia next March – a place known for its wind. I also want to be prepared for rain, which I think we're bound to see during our 3 weeks in the backcountry.

I've gotten a lot of advice (because of the infamous wind in southern Argentina/Chile) to invest in a good windshirt (such as the Patagonia Houdini). However, is there any sense in carrying that around PLUS a rain shell? (I'm also looking at the Patagonia Torrentshell or Outdoor Research Aspire).

In other words, would the Houdini give me something that the Torrentshell or Aspire would not? Are there any arguments for carrying both a windshirt and rain shell? In the interest of weight (and expense), I don't want to have to buy or carry non essential layers.

Justin Baker BPL Member
PostedNov 25, 2014 at 1:34 pm

The wind shirt is air permeable which allows your perspiration to evaporate. If you use the rain jacket all the time for wind you will trap perspiration and get damp which could make you cold at some point.

The houdini is also fairly water resistant so you can wear it in light rain. In light rain with the houdini you will stay much drier because your sweat can evaporate. Heavy rain, leave the rain jacket on. When it's starts drizzling take it off and put on the houdini so you can at least dry out a little bit.

Steve K BPL Member
PostedNov 25, 2014 at 1:57 pm

On paper this sounds like a pretty simple thing: cut one or the other and eliminate unnecessary bulk and weight.

However, in practice it turns out that carrying both lends itself to some pretty incredible advantages, in both comfort and utility.

The reason is because as much as manufacturers make a big deal about the "breathability" of a waterproof shell, no waterproof shell comes close to the breathability of something specifically designed not to be waterproof.

In cooler weather for backpacking I wear my wind shirt close to 100% of the time. It protects me from bug bites, from the wind, from light drizzle, spindrift and scratchy thorns. With a hood, it keeps my ears and head and neck warm, it prevents snow from going down my back when I duck under a low-hanging branch and helps me regulate temperature as I am moving without having to stop and redress. More importantly, it prevents sweat from evaporating too quickly off of me and my base (or fleece mid) layers while at the same time, not inhibiting humidity and moisture transfer.

The hard shell sits in my pack most of the time. If it starts pouring or I bust out of treeline and it is super windy, the hard shell comes out. In cold weather, it goes over my wind shell, which keeps the wind from whisking away all of my body warmth when the hard shell comes off, and also protects the hard shell from my body oils, particularly around the neck where my hard shells always seem to fail first. The hard shell is my final and ultimate protection against the elements, but it has to be extremely wet or windy before I'll prefer it over the wind shell. And of course, I'd never cut the hard shell from my packing list because it's no fun to be cold and wet and hypothermic either.

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
Loading...