I have a stupid question. I'm planning on doing the JMT sobo in next Sept in a pair of brooks cascadia 9's which I LOVE for comfort/breathability, etc.
Seemed like a no brainer…but I'm reading tidbits here and there about them blowing out on the JMT.
I'm guessing those are anomalies? Other reports say 600+ miles before a blowout..
Any thoughts?
Topic
Life expectancy of Cascadia 9’s?
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
Christopher, I have a pair of 8's and 9's. I have about 60 miles on the 9's and little over 200 on the 8's (very conservative estimate, because I have hiked and do trail runs in them as well).
On a hike this past weekend with the 8's the front tip of the sole (where it wraps around the toes) came unglued on the right shoe while hiking some very rocky trails in Pennsylvania (where it seems there is no other kind of trail!) Temporarily glued back on with the only glue I had, some Crazy Glue (cyanoacrylate) and it held fairly well, but it was peeling off again by the time we reached the cars.
At home, I peeled the section back, sanded away as much of the old glue as I could reach with some 80-grit sandpaper and reglued with Welder Contact Adhesive. Did a short run with the dog today and purposely kicked a few rocks and dragged the toe a little bit to check the bond and it seems good as new.
Needless to say, Welder adhesive will be in my repair kit from now on.
I have gone thru 6 pairs of Cascadia 7 in the past 2 years, mostly mountain running, but at least 300 miles in the Sierra fastpacking.
I never had a blow out on any of them.
I tended to retire each pair between 500-550 miles, mostly because the tread was worn down, and the spring in the cushion was gone.
the Cascadia 9 has some minor changes from the 7, but they are basically the same shoe.
In my view Cascadias are great shoes for slow long distance.
HAHA, for some reason I think the JMT just eats shoes.
Last year I hiked in Salomon's – trashed. My friend hiked in a different pair of Salomon's – trashed. This year I hiked in New Balance Leadvilles – trashed. My friend hiked in Montrail Masochists – trashed. A couple we hiked with – all had Cascadias (new as of August…so not sure which model) – all trashed.
I have come to the conclusion that Sierra granite and trail runners just don't get along after about 200 miles. But others can (and should!) correct me if I'm wrong…….
Wow! Very interesting.
The most I've done in the sierras was 90 miles and my shoes were ok…so I'm pretty naive in this area,
However, I put ~80 Sierra miles on my cascadias in the last 2 months and I am noticing some pretty obvious signs of wear on the sides near the front. Can't believe I didn't even notice that until an hour ago when I checked.
I'm highly considering replacing my shoes at MTR.
Is that pretty normal for people on the JMT or am I being paranoid?
I haven't used the 9's, but I've done a lot in the Sierras int he 8's. I've probably gone through 6 pairs. I retire them at about 400 miles on average. I have never had a failure in the uppers, and I've never had any catastrophic failure or anything that required field repair. They always start to fail in the sole, where at first a stud or two will break off, presaging more substantial disintegration of parts of the sole when I've carried on putting more miles an old pair for trail running at home. Given how aggressive the tread studs are for a lightish shoe, I think that's a reasonable life.
I've done two JMT thru hikes in 8's. They will easily get the 200 miles, but I'd certainly start with a brand new pair to be safe.
I did the JMT in a pair of reasonably fresh 9's and didn't have any durability issues. I haven't really worn them since (I have a second pair for hiking/day-to-day walking), but they were more or less fine and will look like new whenever I get around to hosing them off in the bathtub and getting rid of all of the sand/grit in there.
I don't remember exactly how many miles I had on them before the JMT, but I'm pretty sure it was in the 80-100 range (IIRC, something like 40-50 trail miles and a week or two of wearing them on sidewalks for my 5-mile walking commute to work). They probably have something in the range of 350 miles on them (mostly from the 230ish miles I did with the JMT and a few side trips) and look pretty good. I'm not sure I'd take them out for a second round on the JMT, but I wouldn't have any reservations about taking them out for another 100ish miles.
My other pair is starting to wear thin and is developing some smaller mesh holes (no structural issues yet), and is definitely losing some of the cushion. I'm not sure how many miles I have on them, but it's probably at least 500 (lots of trail time, but majority sidewalks, so it's not a great reference point). For walking on streets, I'll probably stick with them for another 1-200 miles (it adds up quickly when you walk everywhere you go) before I switch out to the fresh pair I ordered a while back.
That said, my experience on the JMT seems to be atypical. There was a thread on the JMT yahoo newsgroup about Cascadias and there were some pretty scathing comments on the durability. Obviously YMMV, but the shoes may have been my single best-loved piece of gear on that hike.
Become a member to post in the forums.

