Also… comparing sleeping bag measurement specs is a dicey operation.
I have ordered sleeping bags and then measured them on the living room floor. Many are not even close to the published specs!!!! Perhaps they changed the cut but not the specs? Not sure.
Also, just where do they measure the shoulder, hip, and foot measurements???? For instance, do they measure the foot at the exact bottom or 6" up.. or 12" up???? Do they measure the shoulder at the very top of the bag where it tapers back in toward your neck or do they take that measurement 6" down… or 12" down? or 18" down??? Same questions with the hip measurement…. Some may measure one place, another company may measure at another place. And some bags taper on a straight line from the shoulder section to the foot… others curve giving more or less room at the hips…
If you are picky about the fit, the best thing to do is to order both, try them on your living room floor, and return the one you don't want.
I would NOT trust the published specs.
billy