So while I do like my Montbell Alpine jacket (20oz, no hood) I thought I might want to get something for when it gets really cold around here, around town or while I am waiting for the bus. I found a new Marmot Greenland in XXL on a really good sale which seems to fit pretty okay. The only drawback I have to it is that while a medium supposedly weighs 27, my XXL weighs 34.3. It does have about 2.65 extra oz of down in it though (13.25oz) but it seems the extra 4.65 is a bit extra but it probably makes sense since I went up three sizes and only had a 1.55oz jump at each stage. The Permafrost in M is 23.6 and that has 1.6oz less down and would weigh about 1.8oz less than the Marmot minus the down differential. I can’t put a wind jacket over it or anything like that to protect it though because it is so big. Should I just shut up and be okay that I bought this Jacket for $150 new and it is probably as good as I am going to get for such a thing? Sorry I do have an issue with anxiety.
Topic
Should I just stop worrying about the Greenland I bought?
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
If you got it for 150$ you should be happy.
Just to note my XL Permafrost is 26.4oz
So possibly a Permafrost XXL would possibly weigh about 28.8, 5.5oz less but would probably have about 2oz less down also. I can live with 3.5oz that probably come in the way of extras like the inner pockets and what not. Doesn't have the Gore Windstopper on it though but oh well. Probably good that it doesn't
Brett,
What temperatures are you planning on needing this jacket for? I've been trying to keep up with your jacket search saga since I am a pretty big fellow myself although not quite up to your standards.
Ryan
I picked up a marmot Greenland jacket last winter on sale. Wow, that thing is seriously warm and great for seriously cold winter days. I can't imagine ever taking it hiking (too hot to wear while active, too big to stuff into a backpack), but it's the warmest winter jacket I've ever worn.
You bought Greenland?
What do the residents think of this?
More seriously, what will worrying achieve? You have it now: use it and enjoy it.
Is you really want some protection over it, try a silnylon poncho of some sort.
Cheers
Roger,
The voice of reason. Simple solution. Good advice.
He bought all the marmots in greenland
Fortunately all the bears are mine !!!
If it fits, then it doesnt matter very much
A marginally lighter piece of gear wont matter one whit unless you are pushing the edge, and perhaps not even then
;)
I think the question about a waterproof shell over a Greenland jacket is pretty much moot. If it's warm enough for rain or any kind of wet precipitation, you'd sweat to death within minutes after putting on the Greenland. We are talking a full-baffle hooded jacket with a lot of 800 fill down. I wouldn't even think about wearing mine unless it's below 20F. The last time I wore mine, I think it was about 5F.
The shell is already reasonably wind resistant, plus you've got a DWR finish. I can't really imagine ever wearing it and having a need for an additional layer.
http://marmot.com/products/details/greenland-baffled-jacket

Become a member to post in the forums.

