Topic

Down Tech – the “best” down DWR?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
PostedNov 6, 2014 at 1:48 pm

I've noticed lately that several apparel companies ae going with Down Tech as their down DWR treatment.
Namely Eddie Bauer, LL Bean and Big Agnes are the ones I've seen so far.

EB says they tested down DWRs and found Down Tech to be the best. Since their testing is done by professional guides I place a lot more faith in them than, say Backpacker Magazine.

So has anyone had any trail experience with down any brand of down DWR? (commercially applied down DWR only)

PostedNov 6, 2014 at 3:30 pm

And TNF and other companies go with Hyperdry from Allied Feather and Down … and almost all large companies have professional (and biased) testers. Still no independant testing.

PostedNov 6, 2014 at 11:15 pm

>EB says they tested down DWRs and found Down Tech to be the best. Since their testing is ?done by professional guides I place a lot more faith in them than, say Backpacker Magazine.

As do most other major manufacturers. Professional guides or climbers or both. Their 'testing' is not in any way scientific nor unbiased. They do give good feedback on designs, but they would not be able to honestly tell you of any performance difference between DWR treatments for down in most cases.

I am sure their are differences, and I am also fairly confident that the differences are not all that important overall. I would but far more emphasis on the fit and design of the bag or garment, fit and finish than in what brand of treated down is used.

As for real world experience, mine is still pretty small. I have a Mountain Hardware Speed 32 that I have used a couple of times and a Marmot Guides Hoodie jacket with a bit more use (and some in town use) so far both perform fine, but then I never had a lot of issue with down and moisture in the first place.

On my last trip the Speed 32 did not appear to gain any weight or absorb any moisture even though it poured rain all night and there was a fair amount of condensation inside my tent. unfortunately I did not think to weigh the bag upon arriving home so no solid data their, just anecdotal.

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedNov 7, 2014 at 11:55 am

> Since their testing is done by professional guides I place a lot more faith in them
> than, say Backpacker Magazine.
Well, I don't think I would place very much faith in EITHER method.

Until you measure something in numbers, you know very little about it.

Cheers

PostedNov 7, 2014 at 12:06 pm

With that comment I would expect BPL to get small samples of each type of water resistant down and start testing. When can we expect this?

PostedNov 7, 2014 at 1:52 pm

And an example perhaps to show this:
recently I was searching for the draining capability of a shoe-model. I found a few reviews that said the draining capabities were very good. Very nice I thought. Then I saw that all those reviews were of members of the pro-testteam of the brand that offered that model. So I searched further for an independant review and I found one. It said that the draining capability of that model is very poor.

PostedNov 7, 2014 at 3:01 pm

My understanding was that the Patagonia down treatment technology (plasma silicon something or other…I forget) was totally different than these DWR treatments. And that it was likely to be superior. But except for their gold plated limited production run jacket, I've seen nothing else using that down technology.

PostedNov 9, 2014 at 11:45 pm

… for such a test. Maybe we can ask the military test site at Nautick to tells if they have tested DWR treated down. After all, It's our tax dollars that fund them. Shouldn't we get some direct benefit from their tests?

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
Loading...