Topic

Yet another shoe question

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
Matthew Reese BPL Member
PostedOct 29, 2014 at 12:21 pm

For years I have worn Salomon XA Pro Ultra's, in wide, for 90% of my hiking and backpacking. Alas, the most recent version for 2014 does not fit my feet like the old ones did, so I'm searching for a new hiking shoe. My requirements are: low-cut trail runner or light hiker with a narrow heel, wife forefoot, and support for a high arch. I want breathable mesh, no waterproof liner, and enough volume to accept Superfeet green insoles. It would be nice to get a model that isn't going to change every year, as it's frustrating to go through all the trouble of finding shoes that fit only see them go away the next year. I've only tried on a couple so far, but Merrell Moabs felt ok, though a little too flexy. Suggestions?

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedOct 29, 2014 at 2:11 pm

You could try reading some of our reviews of New Balance shoes. The NB web site lets you search for size, width and last, so you can focus on what will fit your feet.

> support for a high arch.
NO! Medically very bad, and definitely on the out. Nike's concept of 'arch support' is now thoroughly discredited and seen as harmful. Utterly and totally bad for your feet.

> It would be nice to get a model that isn't going to change every year,
Not going to happen. Not with joggers – and today's marketing depts.

But once you find a size/width/last combo which works for you, I think you will find that there will be a replacement next year for this year's model. Different colours and exterior trim maybe, but the big names do (generally) keep a popular core style going. I know NB and Salomon do, anyhow.

Cheers

M B BPL Member
PostedOct 29, 2014 at 6:39 pm

Order several from zappos or running warehouse and start trying them. With free shipping and return shipping, you can try shoes to your hearts content.

You can even return to running warehouse after using if you don't like them, for store credit only then.

I'm currently running in saucony peregrine 4s. They are OK. I tried about half dozen shoes before actually using these. My biggest gripe is most "trail" shoes have a laughable tread depth. 1/8 " deep won't last 200 miles on rocky terrain.

They obviously aren't intended to.

Adam G BPL Member
PostedOct 29, 2014 at 6:55 pm

I've had good luck with the Altra Lone Peak 2.0. They are vastly superior to the 1.5. They don't have much of an arch, but I put Superfeet in them and they are incredibly comfortable for me.

Monty Montana BPL Member
PostedOct 29, 2014 at 7:48 pm

Hi Roger! I recall you saying something similar in the past about "arch support", especially as promoted by Nike. I, and I,m sure others would, too, would sure enjoy some elaboration on this topic. Maybe you could do an article in the usual thoroughgoing Roger fashion…that would be great! For one, does this approbation apply to Superfeet insoles? I have left-of-center flatish feet, and they seem to help; I know the heel cup sure helps with fatigue and blister reduction. Admittedly, much of that has to do with giving up heavy, leather clodhoppers, changing to trail runners instead. Anyways, what do you say?

Justin Baker BPL Member
PostedOct 29, 2014 at 8:15 pm

I'm not very knowledgable about this sort of thing, but I do know that superfeet don't "support" your arches in the way you are probably thinking. It's more about preventing the arches from extending and stretching. It's a bit different from having an actual physical arch in there.

PostedOct 30, 2014 at 6:55 am

OK. Here's your PT perspective:

Your arch is NOT a weight bearing surface, so the idea of "arch support" in and of itself is flawed. Think of your foot as a tripod: the heel, and the ball of your big toe and the ball of your little toe. THIS is where the weight goes – your arch is supposed to be a flexible, rotating, flattening device that absorbs force as you step. If you cram something in there, ala arch support, then you are eliminating the foot's natural force-absorption properties.

Now, many folks have arches that are too stiff and don't absorb force like they are supposed to, or are already flat to start with, or just collapse too quickly during weight acceptance. The first two generally need some kind of help in terms of footwear to contribute to force distribution – the stiff arches need a cushion shoe since the arch won't drop to absorb force; the already flat foot needs a bit of support to lift the arch – but usually that's actually at the heel to put the foot in a better position to allow it to rotate. If you have an arch when you aren't weight bearing, but then it collapses when you stand up on it, then that means you just need muscles in your foot.

The problem is that podiatrists and superfeet and shoe stores and yes, even PTs, have convinced people that they need orthotics and arch supports, etc. I cannot tell you how many times people come into my clinic for something and casually mention they have orthotics. Why? I ask. I don't know…I've had them for 20 years….

So no, arch supports per se are not good. Very few people actually need some kind of control to their foot – and yes, Roger is right that for many people (NOT everyone, Roger…) simply building foot muscles will be adequate for correcting biomechanical faults.

PostedOct 30, 2014 at 8:03 pm

Another view is that the orthotics, like Superfeet, are used to fill space and keep low volume feet from slipping around and rolling in the heel area. Truly torture on rocky terrain.

I tried Superfeet and other off-the-shelf orthotics and none worked, so for those who benefit, you are saving a lot of money. My pronation was so bad the force on the left side of the right foot was so powerful that after a while, the foam in the mid sole collapsed on the left side, leaving the sole of boot at quite an angle. Great boots that had to go in the trash.

Finally, someone at a bar waiting for a concert to start suggested the podiatrist who makes my orthotics. No more pronation. Feet fit firmly in the heel pocket of a number of boots to pick from. The latest pair he's made appear to have completely eliminated the heel slip, both vertical and lateral (up and down, and side to side).

This is not to differ with JM's excellent description of how the feet work and why arch "support" is not a useful concept. Roger will undoubtedly disagree (again); but I love being able to use well made low cut and low weight mid hiking boots. I just ordered a pair of Danner mids that are constructed much like the Keens, but should last longer if they fit well and are not returned. One does have to find relatively flat bottom boots without much arch built in so the orthotic can sit firmly on the sole and not rock back and forth over the arch support or get caught between curvature on each side of the foot, as in Patagonia boots. It doesn't hurt that the flat bottoms tend to be lower end and less money, though they need to be replaced more often.

The biggest problem is that many boots that seem to fit great in the store and around the house, become uncomfortable after a while on the rocky trails in NH that don't offer many level places to put the feet down. By then, the boots are worn and seldom returnable. So JM might say to toughen up the muscles. I know, I know. But there is no question that the boots that keep the heels solidly in place, are wide enough in the forefoot, and have less torsional flex, are much more comfortable for me on the rocky trails.

Monty Montana BPL Member
PostedOct 30, 2014 at 8:41 pm

Jennifer & Samuel, thanks for your thoughtful and insightful input. I've found that for hiking on moderate, maintained trails, the "out of the box" trail runner is light and moccasin comfortable; however, should I venture on a hike that's cross-country, superfeet sure improve stability, especially with some of the minimalist shoes like Lone Peak, which lack a heel counter. Actually, I won't use that kind of shoe anymore as they put too much of a strain on my already battered feet; something sturdier like the Saucony Exodus is much kinder and carries me farther.

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedOct 31, 2014 at 2:09 am

> Maybe you could do an article in the usual thoroughgoing Roger fashion…
I am trying to get Jennifer to write that article!
(Hint, hint…)

> does this approbation apply to Superfeet insoles?
I don't THINK so, although I have never worn them myself. Any FLAT insoles should be just fine imho.

Cheers
PS: can I say it before Jennifer does: do NOT try to alter your gait to conform to some idiot theory put out by certain popular shoe vendors, one of whose name might start with 'N'. All you will do is cause injury. Walk how you normally walk.

If you get arrested for walking like that … tough.

Bill Segraves BPL Member
PostedNov 4, 2014 at 5:37 pm

"simply building foot muscles will be adequate for correcting biomechanical faults."

What would you consider the best references to publications with controlled studies demonstrating efficacy of exercises to build foot muscles? Best exercises that are practical for doing oneself? (What looked to me like a good recent paper used a setup that was pretty complicated!)

Thanks.

Bill S.

Nick Gatel BPL Member
PostedNov 4, 2014 at 5:52 pm

"What would you consider the best references to publications with controlled studies demonstrating efficacy of exercises to build foot muscles? Best exercises that are practical for doing oneself? (What looked to me like a good recent paper used a setup that was pretty complicated!)"

Just walk a lot?

PostedNov 4, 2014 at 6:22 pm

I have worn the Oboz low sawtooth for past couple of years ie 2 pair for 1100 At trail miles. Have had no issues but for the front toe cap (on 1 shoe) breaking free at the very top, bout 1/4 inch. I just trimmed it off and had no further issues.

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
Loading...