Topic

Campsite Jacket for 30F Recommendation?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
PostedOct 19, 2014 at 1:39 pm

Hello,

I frequently car camp with the Boy Scouts but knowing that someday that will turn into backpacking or even Philmont, I am replacing all my heavy Walmart quality gear from decades past with lightweight when I see deals.

Through REI garage sales, coupons, and a lot of patience, for clothing I've picked up Icebreaker Tech T's, an Icebreaker Tracer 260 bottom, Arc'Teryx Squamish, merino balaclava, light merino gloves, and a Smartwool NTS quarter zip.

We are primarily camping in SoCal and in the winter we can get into the high 20F's/low 30F's while sitting around camp. What lightweight down jacket would you recommend in combination with the above to layer and be comfortable?

Thanks for all the help and all the things I've learned from so many people as I've lurked over the last year!

–6th0

PostedOct 19, 2014 at 5:09 pm

WM Flight is a great option but very rarely on sale. Though it's not a UL option I also -really- like the Woolpower full-zip jacket/cardigan in 400g/m^2 terry loop wool. Under a shell, it keeps me comfy to 25d when sitting still. The shirt is also part of the Swedish military M90 uniform system so you can find them surplus as M90 "värmetröja" (insulating shirt) on ebay sometimes.

M B BPL Member
PostedOct 19, 2014 at 6:10 pm

Depends on activity level, and if you like wearing all you gear. If you sit motionless for 3 hrs you will be uncomfortable in practically anything.

For normal activity, 2.5 to 4 oz of 850 down should work.

Jeff Jeff BPL Member
PostedOct 19, 2014 at 6:17 pm

If I was sitting around camp at sub freezing temps with campfire, I would want something with 5oz down, box baffles, and a hood. The Montbell Mirage might work, but the shell fabric might not hold up to scouting antics.

I can use my Alpine Light in the 30s with a decent fleece underneath if that puts things into perspective.

James holden BPL Member
PostedOct 19, 2014 at 6:48 pm

sitting around and being "comfortable" at that temp

a minimum of 4+ oz of 800+ fill down IMO … probably more if you run cold or get down into the low 20s

as to the brand and model, get what fits best, is a good price, and meets your needs

one note is that some of these UL 7-10d fabrics might not last too long if you wear it alot around camp and town … unless you put it under a windshell

even my 15D+ fabric on my EB downlight is seeing holes after a few years of decent use

;)

PostedOct 19, 2014 at 8:03 pm

Don't forget you can add a wind shirt and rain shell to add warmth as well. For 30F, 2.5oz of 800 + down will work for me with these considerations (as well as a merino wool beanie and wool gloves). I just need to be comfortable, as I know that my sleeping quilt is available….

However, I generally run warm.

PostedDec 11, 2014 at 3:15 pm

Thanks for all your replies.

I was agonizing over a Mirage or an Alpine Light, but what is the opinion of layering an ultralight jacket and a vest to get the same amount of warmth but with the flexibility of leaving one layer at home if temperatures aren't expected to be "SoCal arctic" of low 30's. What would the Mirage equivalent in terms of warmth and weight be–or is there no way of doing this without being heavier than a around 12oz?

Thanks!

–6ht0

Trill Daddy BPL Member
PostedDec 11, 2014 at 3:30 pm

IMO it depends on how often you will USE the jacket.

The Mirage is probably the warmest jacket for its weight offered by a non-cottage manufacturer. It is hard to beat.

PostedDec 11, 2014 at 3:35 pm

"what is the opinion of layering an ultralight jacket and a vest to get the same amount of warmth but with the flexibility of leaving one layer at home if temperatures aren't expected to be "SoCal arctic" of low 30's. What would the Mirage equivalent in terms of warmth and weight be–or is there no way of doing this without being heavier than a around 12oz?"

I use a Montbell Ex Light jacket(4.5 oz. size small) and my old BMW Cocoon vest(5.5 oz.) layered over a base layer and under my Montane Minimus WPB jacket/windshirt(5 oz.) for temperatures down to the low 30s-high 20s. They will not provide the warmth of a Mirage, but enough for your stated range, with more flexibility. The Cocoon vest is no longer made, but an Ex Light Down Jacket under either a Montbell U.L. Down Vest or T would provide at least equivalent insulation and satisfy your weight requirement for considerably less money than a Mirage. I am assuming you will have a shell of some kind to block wind/rain/snow as the outer layer.

http://www.montbell.us/products/list.php?p=all&cat_id=20&gen_cd=1

PostedDec 11, 2014 at 3:38 pm

What I can realistically see in the future is the occasional (4 times/year) 2-night backpacking trip in SoCal with the Scouts, a couple snowball fights on Mt. San Jacinto but not staying the night, and a lot of car camping in the occasional mid-30's sitting around camp in either the Idyllwild area or in the desert.

In 2016 I'm planning on going to Philmont during the summer but I understand the temperature swings from hot/dry to cold/wet rather quickly.

–6ht0

PostedDec 11, 2014 at 9:30 pm

I did a Yukon trip last September with temps that were around a high of 30 during the days and lows of around 17 at night. I did a lot of photography at night and was pretty comfortable with a thin baselayer, an R1 Hoody over that, then an Arcteryx Cerium for insulation. When on the move I would de-layer down to the baselayer. The Cerium is quite light and stuffs down to a small size.

Edward Jursek BPL Member
PostedDec 11, 2014 at 9:41 pm

I would look on Gear Swap and Ebay for a Feathered Friends Hyperion, Helios or Volant or a Nunatak Skaha if you have the time. In the last few months I picked up a Skaha Jacket and Vest for under $300 combined on the Gear Swap Forum. Just in the last couple of weeks I have seen some nice Nunatak and FF jackets up for sale. At full retail, FF and Nunatak are brutally priced, but you get what you pay for with them; high quality materials, workmanship, and a great down fill to jacket weight ratio.

James holden BPL Member
PostedDec 12, 2014 at 5:34 am

To the question of using 2 poofays rather than 1 larger poofay

Its works fine if you an deal with the extra faff

– get a synthetic and a down sweater

– fit em so that either one can go under or over the other, and the entire thing can go under you shell … If you find well fitting stuff you shouldnt need to oversize anything

– the majority of the time youll use the synth for quick stops … Only for long stops or camp will you take the down out of its dry bag

– when moving slowly on technical terrain you can wear the synth

– put the down under the synth to prevent external and internal moisture … With enough heat you can even dry off a light down sweater this way (this requires a SURPLUS of heat somewhere)

– its more redundant

The downsides

– more costly

– a bit heavier

– and mainly more faff

Its only really practical with down sweaters, beyond that the poofays get too big to manage without oversizing one or the other … So its not the best below say 15-20F

;)

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
Loading...