"The low O2 levels just shocked me…not sure if that's normal."
Yes, that is very normal for Mount Whitney.
I carry a small fingertip pulse oximeter, and I record the numbers at six or more places on the way up the Whitney Trail. Then I can compare the numbers to the previous year's numbers, and I can better assess the need to speed up or slow down.
If I push really hard to the summit, I will depress the oxygen saturation to maybe 80%. More typically, it will be 85%.
Also, using the same device I monitor my pulse rate. I know what my maximum limit is, and I make sure that I stay several points below that limit.
In the old, old days, say thirty years ago, we used to push ourselves much faster going up Whitney. We would push beyond the point of getting tunnel vision, so the oxygen saturation was probably down around 70-75% back then. Not recommended.
So, here is what you do. Plot how your resting pulse rate increases with altitude. Let's say at sea level it is 60. Then at 5000 feet it is 64. Then at 10000 feet it is 68, etc. Now plot your maximum pulse rate (which takes some heavy exercise). Let's say at sea level it is 180. Then at 5000 feet it is 170. Then at 10000 feet it is 160. You get the idea. If you keep extending those curves, they will eventually intersect. That means that you can't do any more work beyond resting. That, effectively, is your altitude ceiling. For some people, that is probably 10000 feet. For others like Ed Viesturs, it is probably 30000 feet.
–B.G.–