Topic

Minaret Lake out and back

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
Doug Smith BPL Member
PostedSep 13, 2014 at 8:20 pm

Well, I thought I’d share my thoughts on what was supposed to be a 6 day loop in Ansel Adams Wilderness, and ended up being a two day out and back. Having backpacked from Agnew Meadows to Thousand Island Lake before, I decided I wanted to check out some of the other lakes in the area, such as Minaret, Cecile, Ediza, and even Catherine. I had grandiose plans of a 6-day trek, which is double the longest trip I’ve previously done.

I brought my trusty backpacking partner, Vixen, who is an 8-year-old Belgian Malinois. Vixen and I (and the rest of our family haha) live at sea-level (about 2 miles from it to be exact). We do visit Mammoth and Tahoe quite often, and altitude has never been a real issue…Sure I get winded faster, and don’t sleep so good the first few nights, but never any serious high altitude problems or illnesses.

My goal for the trip was to try and take great landscape photos. I love photography as a hobby and a gear sink, but honestly I completely and truly suck at landscape photography. So I brought along a full-frame body, two lenses, tripod, filters, batteries, etc. Add to that 6 full days of meals for me and 6 days of dry kibble for Vixen, in a large size Bear Vault, and weight started to add up.

My lightest tent at the moment is a Hilleberg Jannu, which is a glorious, bomber tent, that tips the scales at a measly 6lb 13oz. My sleeping pad is not horribly heavy, it’s a Thermarest X-Therm, but my 30* down quilt is really my only true “light” piece of gear. Add to the list water purifier, three 1 liter bottles, toiletries/ first aid/ survival, clothes, etc., and my full pack with water tipped the scales at almost exactly 50lbs. UltraLight…I know. ;-)

So here’s a list of what did and didn’t work. 50 lbs didn’t work. My right knee didn’t work. Vixen didn’t work. Hahaha. Let me break it down a little better; I’ve had a series of injuries at work to my right knee (along with a lot of other parts of me, but the right knee is the biggest effect on mobility). Vixen is not overweight, but she has admittedly become more sedentary over the past few years.

The 9.5 mile hike from Devil’s Postpile gains 2,500′ elevation by the time you get to Minaret Lake, which is just shy of 10,000′. We started at 0745 and got to the lake at 1600 hrs (4PM)! It was a beautiful hike, with phenomenal weather, but the last mile or so and 600′ elevation gain are an a$$ kicker with exposed sunlight and a 50lb pack. We made good time for the first 3 or 4 miles. The second half of the hike we were stopping for about a minute every 100 feet or so. Sometimes even more often and longer breaks. In short, it was brutal, and by the time we set up camp my knee was killing me. The next morning it felt like it wouldn’t hardly move. Vixen was pooped.

Not wanting to be a victim of my own overconfidence, I decided that the plans for an epic 6-day/ 6 lake loop were out the window. I took some golden hour photos and we headed for Devil’s Postpile. By the time we reached the trailhead my knee was pounding and my legs felt like jello. For the return trip we left, coincidentally, at 0745 and reached the car at 1130! Less than 1/2 the time for the same distance covered.

OK, on to gear:
Trekking poles;
I’d never used trekking poles before. I honestly thought it was goofy and that I looked like a cross-country skier in the summer time by using trekking poles when I tried it once before for a day hike. This trip threw my ignorant misconceptions out the window. They were divine. I will never backpack again without trekking poles. I’d probably still be on the mountain, with a bum knee and my 50lb pack (but with plenty of food ;-) ) if it wasn’t for the trekking poles. I thought Vixen’s leash would be a hassle with poles and it wasn’t in the least. I attached her leash to the waistbelt of my pack with a carabiner and all was dandy.

Backpack;
The next item of gear that worked…my Kifaru “Late Season” pack. 50 pounds was brutal, but the pack actually carried it remarkably well. Nearly all the weight was on my hips, and the waist belt and shoulder pads were comfortable and padded for my physique. I’ve carried similar loads in an outstanding custom McHale pack, and I’ve got to admit, the Kifaru Late season, at less than half the cost, carried the weight better for me personally.

I specifically chose the Late Season over some of the larger Kifaru packs because I’m an overpacker, and didn’t want to be tempted. Of course, The large Bear Vault had to be added in a “pod” to the bottom of the pack, and a lot of my camera gear had to be strapped to the back in an E&E pack. So my new mantra is going to be, if it doesn’t fit IN the pack, it doesn’t go. Bear Vault included. In other words, I don’t plan on backpacking again unless my gross weight is less than half of what I carried (25 or less)…BUT…the Late Season is a keeper. I will put up with the pack weight even if I switch completely over to all UL gear. I was that impressed with it’s load managing ability. If it carried 50lbs like it did, I can’t wait to see how it carries 18.

Water filter;
I’ve now used my Sawyer Squeeze on three backpacking trips and honestly I’m not overly impressed. The first trip worked great, as advertised. The second trip was so hard to get a drop of water through that I had to sit on the bag to get it to squeeze…obviously ruining two of the three bags. I flushed it out at home after that. And this trip, with a flushed out filter, it took me about 45 minutes to filter 3 liters of water. I think I’d rather have been pumping. Or who knows…just simply drinking the lake water. Giardia can’t be half as frustrating as a slow water filter. Hahaha

Quilt;
My Enlightened Equipment 30* quilt is the bomb. I haven’t been too cold or too hot since I got it. It vents easily, keeps me toasty warm, packs tiny, and is very light.

General observations:
So I’ve come to the realization that because of my previous injuries, I really have no choice but to lighten my load if I’m going to continue backpacking. I’m not going to plan any more trips longer than 3 days until I get comfortable at the 3 day mark. I’m not going to bring heavy camera gear anymore. I really don’t have the skill to justify it, and I find I spend so much time trying to capture the perfect moment on film (so to speak) that I don’t take the time to enjoy it while I’m living it.

I have a nice hammock (WBBB) that I’ve only used one night. I’ve never slept comfortably on the ground… some times I’m so exhausted I get a decent amount of sleep, but I’m always sore the next day. I’m going to give hanging a shot on my next backpacking trip. This will also lighten my shelter/ sleep system load exponentially.

Anyways, here are some photos. Don’t get the wrong idea, I’m glad I went. Any day in the mountains beats a day at work. :) I just know for sure some changes are going to be made before my next outing.

Look closely and see Vixen resting in the shade on the left:

Alpenglow on Minaret Lake:

Hilleberg Jannu…the last time I’ll carry one of my beloved Hillebergs to Minaret Lake. hahaha:

Minaret Lake:

And the next time I carry 50 lbs to the High Sierra, I plan on riding in one of these instead… (I passed by these V22 Ospreys driving home on Hwy 108, at the Mountain Warfare Training Center:

HkNewman BPL Member
PostedSep 13, 2014 at 8:29 pm

Nice photos and a number take a good camera by rigging it up to balance the back load from the shoulder straps. 50 lbs? Need to stop doing that

Ralph Burgess BPL Member
PostedSep 13, 2014 at 11:00 pm

Thanks Doug, great pictures. That's one of my favorite parts of the world.

Were you planning to go follow the "Minaret Loop", i.e. the part of the Sierra High Route that runs Minaret-Cecile-Iceberg- then across the watersheds at the western end of Ediza – Garnet – Thousand Island? If so… probably better that you saved this for another day. I would not want to be negotiating that route with a 50lb pack and dodgy knee. I can't remember any Class 3, but plenty of Class 2, and some awkward sections – a long traverse of a steep & loose scree slope & then talus by Iceberg Lake; and then if you want to continue up to Catherine, I think there was a solid 3/4 mile of hopping across large deep talus. It's one of my favorite hikes in the world, jawdroppingly beautiful, but you definitely want to be light and agile.

Kiel Senninger BPL Member
PostedSep 14, 2014 at 11:10 am

Those are some great shots of the lake! How long of a leash do you keep your dog on? I've been trying to think of a better way to take my two along.

Try squeezing some vinegar through your sawyer and let it sit in there for a while, then flush it out with water and see if that helps. You could have some mineral deposits built up in there like a drip coffee maker. I've had the same sawyer squeeze for about 4 years and have done that a couple times at the beginning of the season or if the flow rate seems slow at home when I'm testing everything out before I hit the trail.

Doug Smith BPL Member
PostedSep 14, 2014 at 11:40 am

Thanks for the compliments on the photos! :)

HK Newman, yeah, 50lbs is off the list for the next trip. I've already got some ideas that will be put into action that will significantly reduce that weight.

Ralph, that is nearly the route I was going to take. My plan was Minaret> Cecile> Iceberg> Ediza, but then take the trail down from Ediza to the JMT, and north to Garnet> Thousand Island> Catherine. In other words not going cross country between Ediza, Garnet and Thousand Island. I still want to see all the areas I missed, but I'm not going to bite off more than I can chew next time. I'll probably do Shadow trail to Ediza, to Iceberg, to Cecile on my next outing in that neck of the woods. Although my next backpacking trip is more likely going to be Cottonwood Lakes area or Lassen NP.

Kiel, thanks for the tips on the Sawyer, I'll give that a shot. I'd really love to be happy with it, since it's a compact filter. I just won't be happy with it unless I can get the flow rate significantly improved. My leash is the standard 6', give or take a few inches, and then a carabiner to attach it to the backpack waistbelt. Although in the end I started simply putting the belt through the loop on the end of the leash and not using the 'biner. One observation I had was that her leash sometimes becomes too slack at rest, and would wrap under her belly when we began walking again. I have a tracking harness for her (my other dog is a working dog who tracks bad guys and missing people, so he has lots of harnesses)…this harness has an attachment point on the back, near her hips. The leash attached that far to her stern would definitely help from getting it tangled under her legs, and I might give it a shot the next time.

Ralph Burgess BPL Member
PostedSep 14, 2014 at 1:37 pm

The off-trail part from west of Ediza to the north over the watersheds via the Nydivers to the western end of Garnet and Thousand Island is pretty easy terrain, I'd choose that over heading east back to the trail. And the Nydivers are lovely and always deserted (no trails into there). I'd also recommend the western end of Thousand Island, where you ascend gently up a meadowed ramp toward North Glacer Pass. Just gorgeous, and it's easy terrain, just walking through meadows and over slabs, it only gets tricky when you hit talus much higher up. Even if you don't want to deal with the talus and reach Catherine, it's worth just hiking up through the meadows. There are a some easy spots camp up there with good views, near a tomb where a couple of Banner climbers were buried in the 1930s.

Alex Wallace BPL Member
PostedSep 15, 2014 at 5:10 pm

Great pictures, Doug. Thanks for sharing.

"Even if you don't want to deal with the talus and reach Catherine, it's worth just hiking up through the meadows. There are a some easy spots camp up there with good views, near a tomb where a couple of Banner climbers were buried in the 1930s."

Indeed, but the talus scramble up to Lake Catherine is absolutely worth it. It's really beautiful up there!

With respect to your pack weight, obviously reducing it is key, but until then maybe just try a different style of trip. For example, on this particular trip it would be cool to setup a basecamp (Hille mofo' style!) and do some day hikes to explore the various lakes, peaks, and passes. Sure day 1 will probably still suck, but after that it would be a great way to enjoy the scenery and explore with minimal weight on your back. After a day of exploring you get to come back to your Taj-mah-hooch already setup and ready to enjoy a nice evening. Anyways, thanks again for the report.

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
Loading...