Topic

What’s the best GPS hiking app for my Galaxy S5? BackCountry Navigator TOPO GPS?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 47 total)
Michael K BPL Member
PostedJun 25, 2014 at 12:27 pm

What do you think would be the best app to use for my Samsung Galaxy S5 as a backup to my etrex 30 or stand alone on shorter hikes (battery won't allow its consistent use on bigger trips)? I just made the jump from a flip phone to this thingimibopper and I want to try using it as a GPS . Also, I like the idea of saving certain more detailed maps than the one that I may have on me. I'll be hiking the Wind River Range this summer (not sure if that effects things).

Is BackCountry Navigator TOPO GPS the best and easiest one now?
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.crittermap.backcountrynavigator.license&referrer=utm_source%3DWebsite%26utm_medium%3DLink%26utm_campaign%3DSeeAppButton

I don't really see the "Pro" one that everyone seemed to be talking about on earlier threads.

PostedJun 25, 2014 at 1:55 pm

If you want to use high quality USGS and USFS maps, then in my opinion Gaia is the best app. It's available for iOS and Android. I have more map apps that I know what to with, but Gaia is really the only one I use now.

Michael K BPL Member
PostedJun 25, 2014 at 3:22 pm

Mike……thanks for the Gai recommendation, but it doesn't appear to be compatible with the galaxy. Which app do you recommend that is galaxy compatible? Have you used "backcountry navigator" and what is its disadvantage when comapred to gaia?

PostedJun 25, 2014 at 3:36 pm

Well, I'm an iOS user, so I just assumed that their Android App would work with any Android phone. Sorry. This is actually bad news for me as I was going to buy an S5 in a few weeks. Now I'll have to rethink that.

PostedJun 25, 2014 at 3:47 pm

Hmmmm not sure why it would not be compatible with the S5 as I know gaia works on the S3. I have the S4 and use Atlogis topo maps gps. I believe its 5$ for the pro so less than backcountry and gaia. Works for me.

Michael K BPL Member
PostedJun 25, 2014 at 3:54 pm

I should have been clear. I was not sure if it would be compatible. If it worked for the S3, then it should work with the S5. I just could not find any specific information of its campatibility with the Galaxy phones. The reason why I did not get an iphone is that it has less than half of the Galaxies battery life.

Again, what's the advantage of Gaia over Backcountry Navigator?

PostedJun 25, 2014 at 5:11 pm

The appeal of Samsung devices for mapping is the sd card slot.. to store maps for off line use…. .. however, I heard that the newer android os will not allow BCN app to use the sd card…. BCN is very pissed off about this… contact them fot more info.
billy

PostedJun 25, 2014 at 5:18 pm

I have a Samsung S4 and use Backcountry Navigator Pro as my only GPS device. A full day of hiking will drain about 60% of battery (also using the phone as a camera). Also, if you are running short on battery you can always turn off GPS and this will save you a lot of battery life. However, you then of course loose the track statistics but you can still access the map and your track is still displayed on the map. I usually also carry a small solar charger (wakawaka power) and 1-3 extra S4 batteries depending on the length of the trip.

Ian BPL Member
PostedJun 25, 2014 at 5:21 pm

I've used Gaia with ios and was very happy with it but I can't speak for android devices. My iPhone was only 16g with 3/4+ of the memory dedicated to music. For no particular reason, I downloaded most of Rainier NP before I hiked a couple sections of the Wonderland last year and didn't see any noticeable impact on my memory bar. Fairly easy to delete them when you're done too. System is also pretty intuitive.

There may be better aps out there but I was happy enough with Gaia that I never felt compelled to explore it any further.

Andrew Johnson BPL Member
PostedJun 25, 2014 at 5:31 pm

I am one of the Gaia GPS developers. Gaia should work well with all of the Samsung devices, and basically any Android.

We'll give you Gaia GPS for free, and you can compare to Backcountry if you like.

Please send an email to support@gaiagps.com, and we'll send you a link to download the latest version for Android.

PostedJun 25, 2014 at 7:39 pm

Andrew,,,
can Gaia access the Micro sdCard on Samsungs?
Even the latest OS?
BackCountry Navigator is having an issue with this since the latest OS verion 4.4 I think is the number.

billy

Adroit BPL Member
PostedJun 25, 2014 at 9:23 pm

I am using Gaia on my Galaxy Note 3 and it works just fine. Thanks Andrew. Im running 4.4.2. I just checked and it looks like it will not access the SD card.

Peter James BPL Member
PostedJun 25, 2014 at 9:43 pm

I just got back from a JMT section hike, using the AlpineQuest app to track my route. With full tracking, hiking about 14 hours per day, I only used two batteries in my Note 2 over the course of six days. I'd consider it.

PostedJun 26, 2014 at 9:20 am

I've had pretty good results with back country navigator. Had one instance where a map was wrong, two sources. But the Nat geo map was wrong too. Can't fault BCN for that.
Also a lot of times I don't use it all the time, I just might turn it on to check something if I have some doubt, it can take a really long time for the GPS to hone in on me. I don't know why exactly, I would imagine that it is hardware issues though.

PostedJun 26, 2014 at 9:31 am

I have both bcn and gaia on my S4. They are both good apps (though Gaia lagged on Android for along time, it's finally getting pretty good, though still a little quirky in some areas). Both are quite inexpensive so I just paid for both of them.

As of Android version 4.4 (Kit Kat), apps don't have permission to write to an external SD card outside of their 'sandbox' folder. BCN works fine when configured to work within these parameters.

PostedJun 26, 2014 at 11:22 am

I had good results with BCN on an old android. I liked the interface and it performed well. No experience with Gaia, but as you can tell it gets good reviews here. These seem to be the best two out there.

Matt Jones BPL Member
PostedJun 26, 2014 at 11:29 am

I like Backcountry Navigator but have had some issues with archived maps not loading while on the trail. I don't see a lot of other people with this issue so maybe it's something with my device. Does the latest Android update mean that I have to save everything to internal memory? I am going to give Gaia a try regardless.

DGoggins BPL Member
PostedJun 26, 2014 at 12:03 pm

Correct…with Gaia and BCN (well, at least on my s4 I couldn't get the BCN workaround to function to be able to save to SD card…at least while not rooted), you have to currently save maps to internal memory. Gaia support told me ->


Hi there,

I'm sorry you are having issues downloading maps to your SD card.

There have been other users who have encountered the same issue. We are working on a workaround at the moment, but we think it is related to a change in security settings for SD cards that happened in the last update.

I'm sorry for the inconvenience. If you would like, I could send you an email when we resolve the issue. Please let me know if you would like for me to do that.

Regards,
Zach



So hopefully they are working on it…..

PostedJun 26, 2014 at 1:05 pm

Another vote for backcountry navigator. So long as it sticks to its own folders there are no problems writing to the sd card on my note 3 on android 4.4.

Dena Kelley BPL Member
PostedJun 26, 2014 at 3:24 pm

I have Gaia on my iPhone. I was out on a hike a couple weeks ago and while the Topo map was accurate as far as showing terrain and features like lakes, the elevations on the map were WAY off. As one example, a nearby peak is listed on Gaia as being 1239 ft, when in actuality it's 4100 ft. Note that I took a waypoint on the ridge and the waypoint elevation did appear to be accurate. Just a heads up.

Ian BPL Member
PostedJun 26, 2014 at 3:37 pm

Dena,

Was the elevation marked wrong on the digital topo itself or was it the reading at the bottom of the screen?

Doug L BPL Member
PostedJun 26, 2014 at 3:41 pm

1239 meters is pretty close to 4100 feet. Are you sure weren't referencing a topo map with intervals in meters?.

Bill Law BPL Member
PostedJun 26, 2014 at 8:47 pm

I suggest trying both (I think there are free/trial versions) and see which you prefer.

I used to use BCN Pro on an Android phone. Never had an issue with it.

I use Gaia GPS on my iPhone and have had 2 issues.

1. I find it incredibly difficult to select an area for downloading the maps for offline use. I can't figure out how to select an area and then extend it (e.g., by grabbing its corners and dragging it). So I have to zoom out until the entire area I want is visible on the screen, but then it is so tiny I can't figure out what portion I want. I find this incredibly frustrating. Maybe there's some trick to it, but I haven't been able to figure it out.

2. It refused to start up on two trips last summer. It would show the "Loading…" Screen, then shut down. When I returned to an area with cell signal, it would show an apple App Store signin screen, after which it worked fine. I did post this and the developers tried to help (the problem remained a mystery, and it has worked twice with no problem this year), but I still am paranoid about whether it will work for me each time I start it up. I don't think I found anybody else that ran into that. Maybe it is just me.

Andrew Johnson BPL Member
PostedJun 27, 2014 at 1:42 am

@Bill: We just shipped off Gaia 9 for review by Apple. In the new version, we improved the map download screen so you can adjust the corners, and zoom/pan the map while setting up the download. I think it will work just as you want, and that's actually just a minor change in this version! With regards to your bug, I remember you writing about that, but haven't otherwise had it reported – sorry to spook you.

@Dena: It sounds like the elevation on the map source in Gaia GPS was correct, but it was shown in meters rather than feet. The USGS has been inconsistent with whether they use meters or feet in topos, and all the worldwide sources are in meters.

Bill Law BPL Member
PostedJun 27, 2014 at 9:15 am

Thanks, Andrew. I appreciate your great customer service. I will get the new version.

And I dont mean to dissuade folks from using Gaia. I did some off-trail wandering on my last outing and it worked a charm. But BCN was good, too.

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 47 total)
Loading...