So… I got to thinking (always dangerous :)…
I pulled the bottom section of my Locus CP3 carbon fiber poles and thought I'd see if the bottom section from my aluminum Leki Cressida poles would fit into the CP3s…
Wala… they do!!! And there is zero weight penalty!!!
And… it seems to diminish the infamous, intractable 'rattle' of the CP3s!!!
To add to the discussion above… when I broke my previous CF poles that had an alum bottom section, I did that by falling directly on the top section… it had nothing to do with the bottom section being aluminum.
Also, the appeal of having an aluminum bottom section is not just what the Original Poster was concerned with: stepping on the bottom section and breaking it…
My main concern is that the bottom section is what takes the most beating from rocks. Just look at any poles that have been used for some time and you will notice most of the scratches are on the bottom section. Carbon fiber will not hold up to this cutting/scratching as well as aluminum. So there are two reasons to have aluminum bottom: cuts/scratch vulnerability of CF and aluminum will not break as easily.
billy