Topic

how low should my base weight be before i consider a lighter backpack

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
PostedMay 4, 2014 at 3:50 pm

As it stands right now hiking with my wife we have our base weights around 12-13 pounds. depending on weather (rain gear, insulation.)

How low should it be before we can consider backpack offerings from gossamer gear and such. I was looking at the GG Mariposa, but do not want to consider moving to one if my base weight isn't low enough.

the GG website says it can handle load to about 30 pounds.

for consumables we use mainly dehydrated food supplemented with jerky (of course) and my wife is dead set on smores :p lol but yea so our total weight should be more that 25 pounds.

We do mainly 4-5 day trips/3 season.

a gear list can be found in "gear lists"

i currently use a gregory z65 and my wife a gregory jade 50

PostedMay 4, 2014 at 4:38 pm

On paper it looks like you are there already. Swapping out your Gregory and substituting the GG Mariposa will save you about 2.5lbs, putting your base weight down to ~10 lbs. Now, only your shoulders and back will know for sure.

bjc BPL Member
PostedMay 4, 2014 at 4:58 pm

I think it depends how light you want to go with the new packs. The ULA packs and the new Fusion packs from Six Moon Designs should have no issues handling the weight you are indicating. Packs from MLD and GG would probably work as long as you don't let the weight creep up. That may be tough to do if extra chocolate is a priority and you let that replace the weight loss from the packs!

David Thomas BPL Member
PostedMay 4, 2014 at 5:10 pm

Realize, of course, that your total weight isn't constant. Each day, the two of you will go through 4-5 pounds of food and fuel. It's reasonable to plan a trip with fewer miles at the beginning (where your bag is definitely the heaviest and you are likely going up hill) with more miles at the end of the trip. Even more so if you hike at elevations well above your hometown – you do acclimatize to altitude somewhat in the first few days. Also, if you plan fewer miles early in a trip (with that heavier pack), you can focus the fewer hiking hours early and late in the day when it is cooler.

To give an extreme example: I can handle two 50-pound duffle bags, one over each shoulder, for a few hundred yards in an airport. But for 40 miles in day with only 4 pounds on my back, a 2.4 ounce Sea-to-Summit daypack can suffice and is preferred for its light weight.

PostedMay 4, 2014 at 5:27 pm

I know we have to tweak a few things on our gear list and additional items due to weather will change our base weight from each trip. (sometimes as much a 2 pounds for rain gear/insulation or what not)

but i'm expecting the MAX load out would be 30 pounds for me.

I guess i'm looking for input for a versatile light weight pack that can handle up to 30 pounds at sometimes. I picked the GG bc of the specifications on the website.

EDIT i also liked it b/c it had a removable stay (which will come out on lighter loads and help out with heavier loads i'm assuming)

PostedMay 4, 2014 at 6:59 pm

just glancing at ULA and six moon and my impressions are that the fusion is pretty cool and the ULA circuit is pretty neat too.

so my list for packs goes as listed

GG mariposa
ULA Circuit
6moon Fusion 65

I like the camp options for the ULA which is pretty neat.

The unique spine design of the 6 moons is cool

anyone have experience with these can chime in please.

Shane S. BPL Member
PostedMay 4, 2014 at 7:47 pm

Take a gander at Elemental Horizons packs, the Kalais is top notch.30-34oz range depending on options.

Ian BPL Member
PostedMay 4, 2014 at 8:12 pm

Hi Nathan,

My two BPL friendly packs are the ULA Ohm 2.0 and the MLD Prophet. I have the large torso size and have found that the ULA Ohm 2.0 is overkill for me when I'm solo but ideal when I'm backpacking with the kids and have to carry extra stuff. Weight transfer to the hips is outstanding. I've never had the pack over 25 lbs, even when carrying 1.5 gallons of water so I can't say what the extra 5lbs would do but the pack has performed like a champ so far. The Ohm is much bigger than I was expecting and the only reason I'm considering the Circuit is it's my understanding that the Circuit is bear canister friendly and I hope to take on the JMT next summer.

As far as frameless packs go, this really becomes personal and it's difficult to say. The Prophet is fairly new to me but I'm comfortable with heavier loads carried completely on my shoulders. As a vet, carrying >75lb loads completely on the shoulders ala an Alice pack is at the low end of common (although those days are far behind me.) I'm still putting the Prophet through its paces but right now I think 25 lbs is a fine upper limit for me with this pack. There are ways to use sleeping pads and other air beams to serve as an internal frame but that hasn't been something I've concerned myself with.

All that babbling aside, my recommendation would be to buy a ULA Ohm or Circuit for the time being. If you take care of them, they have great re sale value if you want to make the jump to a frameless pack later on.

Derek M. BPL Member
PostedMay 4, 2014 at 11:57 pm

Nathan,
The SMD Fusion 65 is too new for there to be much of a consensus about it yet. I tried one on in the store loaded up with 40lbs of weight and it was fantastic at transferring that load to my hips. It was a very comfortable pack, albeit under ideal conditions with soft weight bags loaded up in the pack.

I think it is a very good design, and I'm considering buying one myself. If this pack pans out to be anything like it was in the store for me, then I think it would be the easiest transition for you from a z65. You'd lose significant weight without a lot of load carrying capabilities being lost.

I've tried on the the ULA Circuit in the past and didn't like it. I am the minority here though. Everyone else seems to love these packs. They are certainly well made.

From what I understand, the GG Mariposa will be the worst of the three options in terms of weight transfer to the hips. I really like the layout of the pack, and would like to try one on (which is difficult to do without purchasing). I get the impression from others that this pack is most comfortable with about 20lbs or less in it, with the 30lb designation serving as really an upper limit that you don't want to hang out in for very long. Again though, I've never tried this pack, so take this with a grain of salt.

IMO, the most important factor to determine how well a given pack will handle weight is how the the frame interfaces with the hipbelt. If it is a strong, direct connection then effective weight transfer to the hips is as least theoretically possible. I am most dubious of suspension systems like that of the GG Mariposa where a soft hipbelt just slides in outside of the frame with no other type of connection to the frame. This would seem to allow for the main pack body to sag even while the hipbelt hugs you tightly. All that weight is going to go on your shoulders at that point.

In closing, I'd suggest that you look for a rigid enough frame and an effective frame/hipbelt interface if you want a pack to carry 30lbs or more well.

Oh and yes, your base weight is definitely low enough to start considering a lighter pack!

Just my two cents.

Justin Baker BPL Member
PostedMay 5, 2014 at 12:52 am

I've pushed my ohm up to 30 lbs with a torso length z-lite folded in there and it was just fine. Not sure what it would be like without the pad in there.

James Marco BPL Member
PostedMay 5, 2014 at 3:17 am

I used to do 30 pounds all the time. I still do at the start of a 3 week trip. And, I use a much smaller pack. I often carry a GG Miniposa, though it is only rated at 25 pounds. The load ratings of a pack don't really matter all that much.

If you are carrying a gold brick, the volume is very small. All the weight is concentrated in the bottom. If you carry lots of light clothing, it will fill a 4#11 Gregory. Balance, loading on the straps and hip belt, and your personal condition will effect the maximum load more than the exact style of a pack.

Keep your base load as small as possible. Small lights, light down bags that can compress well, high density foods, will keep you pack volume as low as possible without drastically increasing your weight much beyond a few ounces. A UL compression sack will allow you to form your bag and sleeping cloths into a stiff tube. Roll your tent into a 14-18" roll. keep flat stuff next to your back. Use a pad as a frame. All allow you to add structure to a pack…any pack. You can get a lighter pack, sure. But I would recommend you wait untill you reduce the volume/weight of your gear. I think you will find the Mariposa to be a bit too large, unless you have to carry a bear can.

I would develop a system for packing based on balance. Midweight stuff close to your back, and heavier items on top of your bag. midweight stuff on the bottom. Clothing (sweater, and raingear) in the front pocket. Heavy gear, water bottles, stove and fuel, want to be as close as possible, I usually stick these in my pack pockets.

There are a lot of variations so develop your own system based on how you load the pack. I usually ignore how it will be used as I remove it. I look for balance, about 20-30% on my shoulders, 70% on my hips. Keep the weight as low as possible for better balance. Then put a days worth of snacks in your outside pockets where you can get at them. I often load my pack in the morning, drinks and snacks are in my pockets and accessible. Rain Gear is accessible. I don't open my pack till I get to the next campsite. You can add more weight above (good for down hill) by hiking your shoulder straps up. You can drop it back on open hikes with little climbing. If you do any climbing, cinch everything down fairly tight, you do not want it to shift.

Anyway, I think you have to work on loading and balance in a system, then smaller gear and minimal volume, then you can look at a new pack. Do you have kids? Planning on it? This will turn you into a pack mule, you want a LARGER pack. Think ahead. And you will likely need three packs finaly. One huge one for family camping, one midsize one for you and the wife (and for longer distance hiking) and when you get to be my age, a small solo pack that will let you out for a couple weeks at a time. Most packs will last 10 years plus. So, consider them a durable purchase.

You really cannot go wrong with the Mariposa. You can bend the stay to fit most body types. But, it is a large pack. Better that way than one too small and not be able to carry your gear.

PostedMay 5, 2014 at 6:39 am

I wish I could try on a fusion before I buy it. They do have a refund and satisfaction policy about their products though.

I live in Michigan Anyone around the area have a ULA circuit? or a GG mariposa I could try on?

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
Loading...