Topic

Cargo pocket water flask?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
PostedApr 14, 2014 at 7:23 am

There's a question at the end of my ramble, so skip there, or bear with me for a moment…

Staying hydrated while I cycle has never been an issue with mounted bottle bracket bosses, but the last couple years of my new venture into hiking, have left me less than optimal. I tried my first hoser 15 years ago, and despite some filtration advances, they haven't really gained any appeal with me yet, so I doubt I'll ever be a true convert.

I've tried in vein to use water bottle pockets on my backpacks, but short of dislocating my shoulder every time I get thirsty, that is becoming a losing battle with me as well.

So this spring, after sitting on my duff for almost six months, I strolled down the road to visit my parents on what's becoming my "warm up" outdoor excursion of the season. It's a six mile flatland walk in the dead thatch and mud along the roadside (the blacktop is unpleasant to walk on for me). So it's a nice 12 mile walk, with a coffee break half way. Good for killing an afternoon and making sure my elderly parents are still getting along alright. So anyway…

This year I found myself stuffing my 500ml SmartWater bottle (new item?) in my cargo pocket on my pants and I really liked the convenience. It was a little bulky, but I liked the location. I thought perhaps a flask might work well, so I looked into flask options, and was unhappy with what was out there. Leaky lids, small sizes, expensive prices, breakable plastics. It was looking grim. So I went to the liquor store. Who would know flasks better than a booze company? I was not dissapointed. For the price of a Nalgene brand bottle that's prone to breakage, I got a 375ml kidney shaped flask of sturdy food grade plastic with standard pop bottle threads for under $10, which was about what they wanted for the less-than-adequate flasks I'd seen online. Oh, and it came with 375ml of free booze to boot. Win win. I chose the Capt Morgan model, as it has a cool ship molded onto the bottle.

So here's my question. How will carrying this weight along my upper thigh affect hiking? As in, joint stress or leg fatigue for example. It was fine for a short 12 miler, but what about longer distances? I know swinging weight around on my thigh with every step isn't ideal, but this is less than 13 ounces when fully topped up, and only gets lighter from there. With the depth of experience on these forums, I'm hopeful that there's some tales from people that have already tried this and what kind of limitations I might expect, or alternatives to this theme, like in a back pocket instead…

Todd T BPL Member
PostedApr 14, 2014 at 7:58 am

I'd think it would be a pain on the steeper trails where you have to lift your legs high for each step. I sometimes remove my map and eyeglasses from their usual cargo pockets when going up like that because they tug tight on my thighs, becoming quite irritating after 10,000 or so steps.

Here's my preferred solution:

Bottle holster on shoulder strap

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedApr 14, 2014 at 12:14 pm

Some cargo pants have the pockets on the front, and gear in those pockets will feel bad to my thigh muscles. Other cargo pants have the pockets on the outside, and gear there doesn't seem to get in the way. It also helps if the cargo pants are a little loose.

–B.G.–

PostedApr 14, 2014 at 3:01 pm

Good points on the pocket placements and climbs. Some pants will obviously work better than others for this method. I've tried the shoulder strap carrier things and they seemed to really be in the way for me. Maybe a flat flask, combined with a shoulder harness, hmmm….

This flask is thinner than the actual plastic bottles being sold as flasks. About an inch thick at the edges and an inch and a half at the base, with a classic kidney shape curve holding about an inch and a quarter, so it fits well for my current configuration. I was really more concerned about carrying water weight, albeit minimal, on my leg for longer periods of time.

Kelly G BPL Member
PostedApr 14, 2014 at 7:59 pm

Think centrifugal force. A full flask positioned just above the knee will be more difficult to carry than one positioned on the hip, or just below the hip, for example.

I like the concept though. Might try to make a waste-belt attachment to hold a 12oz bottle. My shoulder attachment attempt didn't work too well. Although, I hadn't pursued it. I need a solution for my G4 backpack. Just can't get a water bottle out of those tall side pockets without taking it off.

Kelly

Steven Hanlon BPL Member
PostedApr 16, 2014 at 4:52 pm

my son's backpack is made for a hydration bladder and doesn't have a place that can accommodate a water bottle easily reached without assistance. my solution was to make a pocket out of a 1 liter soda bottle that a 16.9 oz bottle easily drops into. a small section of elastic cord over the top keeps the bottle from popping out when scrambling about.

wish i had a picture, but the pack with him in Maryland. basically cut a 1 liter soda bottle so part of it has a lip, punch holes in it to attach to the hip belt, punch 4 more holes for an elastic cord and ta-da. don't forget to punch holes in the bottom or water will build up.

it takes a beating and is easily replaced, and cost nothing! no more "dad, can you get my water bottle out, thanks"

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
Loading...