Topic

Ultralight Meditation Shelter

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
PostedMar 20, 2014 at 9:40 am

This past winter I made my first ultralight shelter purchases. Apart from lightest possible weight,  the only must-have feature that I looked for was the ability to sit upright in the shelter comfortably (i.e. without hitting my head on the ceiling) in order to meditate in the mornings and evenings. This proved to be an unexpectedly complicated task.

I’m 5’10″ and when I sit cross legged on the floor without a cushion under my butt (I don’t use a cushion when meditating) the crown of my head is at 43″. So all I needed to do was find a shelter with a peak height greater than that, right?

If I were in the market for a free standing tent as I always had been in the past then this would be the case. But with UL shelters there are other considerations the prospective meditator needs to look out for. Especially important is the fact that:

Innernet specs are deceiving. A popular ultralight shelter setup is a tarp or shaped tarp combined with separate inner bug net. Peak height specs for three popular inner nets: MLD Solo InnerNet (44″), SMD Serenity NetTent (45″), Zpacks Hexanet (48″). At a glance it would seem that any of these should pair perfectly with a  tarp or shaped tarp to provide more than enough space for meditating. Especially someone needing only 43″ of height. Unfortunately all of these turn out to be too small for the intended use.

Where is the disconnect?

The thing about inner nets (and many UL shelters in general) is that they setup with a single pole. And where does that single pole tuck in? At the peak of the tent. And what direction does it go? Straight down. In other words, your shelter’s setup pole is going to stand right in the center of what you anticipated would be usable sitting space.

Single pole shelters like the Zpacks Hexamid tent or the Hexamid tarp (with no separate inner net attached) can be made to accommodate meditating by offsetting the base of the setup pole toward the front of the shelter during setup and then scooching forward in the cross legged position so that your knees are actually in front of the setup pole and your head is under the peak of the shelter.

But this little trick does not work if pairing the shelter with a solo innernet because the cut of inner nets, at least the three that I mentioned earlier, does not allow it. The front wall of an inner net will always be behind the setup pole, since the pole sets up outside of the net tent. This means that even if you offset the setup pole, you will be prevented from scooching forward by the front wall of the net tent.

So even though on paper the peak height of an innernet may be 46″, when sitting cross legged the front wall of the innernet prevents you from sitting under its peak. As a result when sitting upright your head will end up pushing up against the back wall of the tent.  This does not make for comfortable meditation.

So if meditating is a priority for you make sure that the peak height of any shelter you’re considering is “usable” peak height. Be careful of anything that has a net wall that runs straight up and down from the shelter’s peak. If you’re investing in the lightest possible shelter and considering Zpacks or something similar, absolutely go with the tent with built in netting rather than the tarp plus optional inner net.

For me, after trying a Hexamid tarp paired with an SMD Serenity NetTent, a Hexamid Solo Plus tarp paired with a Hexanet, and an MLD Duomid paired with a BPWD Pyranet 1, I have settled on a Zpacks Hexamid Solo Plus TENT with extended beak which weighs about 18.5 oz (including guylines, stuff sack, setup pole, and 8 stakes) and has a usable peak height of 50″.

And I couldn’t be happier. Yes, I have sacrificed a bit of versatility (I can’t leave the netting at home when it’s not bug season). But all the space…I almost feel guilty!  I can’t think of a shelter on the planet that has a better weight:space ratio (I am in no way affiliated with Zpacks).

Hope this helps someone, someday. I know that during my shelter research I punched in "meditation shelter" looking for this kind of insight and came up with nothing.

Rex Sanders BPL Member
PostedMar 20, 2014 at 9:44 pm

Ronny,

Good insights. I went down a similar path looking for my last shelter, except I'm 6'2" and wanted to read in the evenings and meditate in the mornings. That pointy peak problem led me to a TarpTent Moment, with a hooped crossover pole that gives me just barely enough room to sit up straight. Not ultralight, but it meets my needs.

Problems like this (specs versus usable space), make buying shelters sight unseen over the Internet a scary process. Even with generous return policies, returns are time consuming, you lose on shipping costs, and your money is tied up waiting for refunds.

I'll take another look at the Zpacks Hexamid Solo Plus.

Thanks.

— Rex

PostedMar 20, 2014 at 10:05 pm

You are right, to maximize space having the netting sewn on the tarp is the way to go. Some people like net tents because it works and it's more versatile. Congrats on the hexamid tent, it's an amazing design and very light, plus you are "encapsulated" in a little bug free environment.

PostedMar 20, 2014 at 10:53 pm

"Problems like this (specs versus usable space), make buying shelters sight unseen over the Internet a scary process"
True and that is why I encourage folk to think about usable space not 2 d dimensions and to make a mock up of the shelter before they buy.
Not all that easy with some but dead simple with some hoop tents,pyramids and other trekking pole supported shelters , like this :
moment Ur
Pyramid shelter

for reference, the one I am under (I am 5'8") some 6'plus folk insist it is more than big enough for them . (laying down on that mat I would touch the ends and no ,sleeping at an angle,moving the pole offside, does not work either…)
And that is why how other people fit in is less important than how you do.

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedMar 20, 2014 at 11:00 pm

The cat. How much for the cat?

You could get a trail camera set up in your own yard and photograph the animal roaming around at night.

–B.G.–

PostedMar 21, 2014 at 1:03 am

After 18.5 years Pip is now resting …
Now , new place, I have ring tail possums running around at night.
cute but they eat their own poop (not so cute)

Ron Bell / MLD BPL Member
PostedMar 21, 2014 at 8:05 am

Ronny-

That second pic of Franco's is quite misleading.

All users of a smaller pyramid style shelters from any manufacturer use a single pole offset toward the door. This opens up the useable space a great amount. Ex: In a SoloMid XL it leaves about 3.5' from pole to rear shelter edge- HUGE SPACE- That's how an InnerNet fits – with the pole on the outside the net offset to the front.

The other popular option on a small mid- Like the SoloMid- is to use two poles in an inverted V setup. This opens up almost all of the interior space and is almost like an external support system.

TarpTent makes great products and I think that if Franco would clearly note that he is an employee of TarpTent in his posts or user name/icon that would clear it all up for everyone.

PostedMar 21, 2014 at 3:28 pm

I did not mention the particular shelter I was replicating because that is just one out of many mock ups that I have done.
Often I see a comment about size and can't help myself doing a mock up just to see how I would fit in it .
This is why I wrote "And that is why how other people fit in is less important than how you do.", specifically I would NOT USE a pyramid shelter with a pole at an angle because the chances of me or wind or snow load knocking the pole down is a lot greater than if set up perpendicular.
Keep in mind that again I am talking about how I feel about it, not how others do.
For some reason I had the impression that the OP was also talking about how he fits not how some other forum member does.
So Ron, before you call someone else's post misleading, read the fine print.
Anyway just for you , here is another one :
lost in Space
note the I am the odd guy that sleeps on top of a mat.

PostedMar 21, 2014 at 4:55 pm

How would it look with a 3" pad? : )

I like the simplicity if Mids but the unusable space is frustrating unless you get a tall one. But by that time, the weight savings starts to disappear. I am surprised more people don't use the Tarptent Stratosphere fly only option. Seems like it discards all of the negatives that exist with a mid that may have a similar footprint.

PostedMar 21, 2014 at 8:51 pm

Ronny,

My favorite pole shape for a one person shelter is an inverted U for some of the same reasons you mention. Two hiking poles with (in this case) a 2 foot long ridge pole connecting the hiking poles works well for me.

xx

xx

xx

Marko Botsaris BPL Member
PostedMar 21, 2014 at 10:13 pm

Franco – love the photo with the cat! I hear if you use a pyramid shape the cat will not spoil. (sry, maybe too obscure a reference). But for some reason I love the picture. Just put it in an art gallery and stand back and listen to what people say.

Not sure what type of shelter except one you can sit up in, but I've got you covered for an UL zafu. If you buy one of those cheap boxes of wine, the bladder inside has a cap than can be closed. They are extremely light (a few oz) and strong enough to sit on. Adjust amount of air to your tastes – wine to be removed beforehand, and if absolutely necessary, drunk.

PostedMar 23, 2014 at 12:12 am

Ron – is the solo innernet a pyramid in shape (i.e. is it a mini version of the duo innernet) or does it have a vertical front wall (which would not allow scooching forward regardless of dual pole use or offsetting of single pole [although the duomid is probably big enough that you could set up the solo inner backwards so that it were a better fit for a body in lotus. Hmmm])?

If it is a mini pyramid then I may have misspoke in my original claim that it would not work for the intended use of sitting upright without hitting head on ceiling.

Everyone else – thanks for the laughs. Zafu from wine cooler is brilliant. If I needed it that would be my one piece of gear that makes me smile.

Marko Botsaris BPL Member
PostedMar 23, 2014 at 12:25 am

I once actually bought an inflatable zafu. It was pricy and turned out to be a regular (and cheap) zafu cover with a beach ball shoved into it. Caveat emptor. :-)

PostedMar 23, 2014 at 5:24 pm

Just learned that MLD solo innernet is a symmetrical pyramid, not a half pyramid. It could work for sitting up cross legged without hitting knees on front. Not sure, haven't tried it. Maybe someone who has used it could weigh in.

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
Loading...