Feb 2, 2014 at 10:39 am #1312774
Michael SBPL Member
@cascadebackpackerLocale: Pacific NW
Looking for some advice from the experienced packrafters…
If you had to have just one paddle, would you choose a 4 piece or 2 piece paddle?
Certainly, the 2 piece paddle is lighter and has less parts/interfaces to improve reliability but the 4 piece is obviously more "packable". For a length of around 200cm, is the 4 piece absolutely necessary?
I see many photos where folks are just carrying 2 piece paddles (or a 4 piece that is only broken down into 2 pieces) strapped to the outside of their packs. Unless I'm bushwacking, I think I'd prefer to keep the paddles on the outside of my pack to avoid abrading the interior of my pack and contents.
Now if I plan on traveling to a packrafting destination by aircraft, then the 4 piece is clearly a winner.
The lighter weight of the 2 piece for carrying and paddling sure is tempting. Wondering what others prefer and why or do a lot of people have both and just use each one for different applications?Feb 2, 2014 at 12:14 pm #2068994
Richard NisleyBPL Member
@richard295Locale: San Francisco Bay Area
If long distance bushwhacking or commercial travel is part of my trip, I always take one of my two 4-piece paddles because they are the easiest to pack and protect. They also offer the weight saving benefit of not requiring trekking poles. I pack just the blades and then use the paddle shaft as a walking staff (chair foot protector on the bottom). I take my 4-piece Werner Powerhouse (209 cm, 41.6 oz.) primarily for difficult whitewater trips. Otherwise I take my much lighter 4-piece Sawyer Packrafting paddle (205-230 cm, 32.2 oz.). This paddle's shaft length variability also makes it ideal for a large mid shelter center pole. If the nylon stretches do to moisture, I just lengthen the center pole to once-again achieve a taught pitch without having to get out of the shelter. The adjustable length also provides the variability of a high pitch for warm weather and low pitch for cold weather.
I otherwise take one of my 2-piece paddles because they are cheaper for the same material, lighter than the equivalent 4-piece, and stronger. For trips with little bushwhacking and a lot of flat water paddling, I use my carbon fiber 2-piece Epic paddle (215-225 cm, 25.8 oz.).
I had paddled hard-shell touring kayaks, folding touring kayaks, and hard-shell whitewater kayaks for many years prior to purchasing my first packraft in 2004. This year I am planning on a multiple-week pack rafting trip in central Alaska. It is a sacrilege for an UL packrafter to admit this, but I am taking my HEAVIEST PADDLE, 4-piece Werner Powerhouse, for this trip. There is no alternative exit strategy if I break a paddle on this all bushwhacking / III+ WW trip. Everything else in my pack is UL and the total weight for 10 days is 35.5 lbs. In addition to food/water/camping equipment, this includes standard WW safety gear (helmet, foam PFD, dry suit, throw rope, etc.) plus an, 8-weight fly rod and related fishing gear.Feb 2, 2014 at 12:49 pm #2069002
David ChenaultBPL Member
@davecLocale: The West Slope
4 piece for sure.
When you need to pack your paddle in the pack, it'd really suck to not be able to.May 2, 2014 at 2:55 pm #2098702
Derrick WhiteBPL Member
@mikuLocale: Newfoundland & Labrador, Canada
Love to see your gear list.
DerrickMay 4, 2014 at 6:55 am #2099007
spelt with a tBPL Member
@speltLocale: SW/C PA
I have a two-piece. It's kind of a pain in the butt.
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.