Topic

MontBell Pocketable Daypack 20. Ion replacment?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
Dale Wambaugh BPL Member
PostedDec 18, 2013 at 8:35 pm

I've been looking for a dead simple day pack more for urban and travel use than hiking. I picked up a MontBell Pocketable Daypack 20 today and I think it will do the trick. It is a simple zippered panel-loading pack with a large 10.5"x10.5" zippered front pocket and a 7"x7" hanging pocket inside that forms a self-stowing stuff sack, 3-D mesh padded shoulder straps and a hang loop. That's it! And it weighs 8.2 ounces on my scale.

MontBell Pocketable Daypack 20

Manufacturer's specs:
Weight 8.5 oz. [my sample is 8.2oz]
Fablic 210-denier nylon
Compressed size 7.1" x 8.3"
Other One size fits most
[Size] 19.7" x 11.0" x 5.9"
[Capacity] : 1220 cu.in. / 20 L
http://www.montbell.us/products/disp.php?p_id=1123649

So many small packs are cut like a cylinder and ride too high on my pack, like a rabid raccoon has jumped on. This is even more clumsy in urban environments where you can wipe the nose of someone standing behind you with your pack. I did this on a Roman subway at rush hour and got a good lesson in Italian cussing. This pack is nearly 20" tall at the back panel and 11" wide and I measured 6.125" deep at the bottom. It rides well for the size.

I like the shoulder straps. They are 2.75" wide at the top and take a natural curve to the outside as they taper. They are long enough to actually fit an adult male (I wear a large top) and have ample webbing for a wide range of adjustment. They wrap smoothly around my shoulder tops and the ladder adjuster ends up 4" below my armpit (I usually wear a long torso pack). There is no sternum strap or waist belt and I don't feel the need for either. It will carry comfortably on one shoulder as well.

This may be a good candidate for a GoLite Ion replacement. It would be easy enough to remove the hanging pocket inside and it begs to have a bungee cord array and mesh side pockets added, although I think I'll use it as made.

Montbell does offer similar packs in 16, 15 and 11 liter versions, although the weight doesn't drop below 6oz for even the 11 liter model.

MontBell Daypack 20

JCH BPL Member
PostedDec 19, 2013 at 6:42 am

Not really of any help here :) but maybe someone at GG will see this and bring back the Big Bag.
http://sectionhiker.com/gossamer-gear-bearister-food-hanging-system/

I was lucky enough to snag one of these a while back and not only is it < 3 oz. but without doubt the most comfortable shoulder straps I've ever encountered on a day pack. Basically a Sil bag with shoulder straps. The unique haul loop integrated into reinforcing seams is ingenious.

I rue the day that anything happens to this and I need to find a replacement.

JCH BPL Member
PostedDec 19, 2013 at 7:17 am

Looks like Angelo may be right, the shoulder straps look to be identical. I really like the reinforcement on the Big Bag though…after a great deal of use, mine looks like new. No seam stresses anywhere. Hopefully the Riksak is of similar quality.

Dale Wambaugh BPL Member
PostedDec 21, 2013 at 11:12 am

The REI Flash 18 is a good example of the "rabid raccoon" riding on your back.

I had a Flash 22 and used it as my main day hiking bag for the early summer and returned it. The straps weren't very comfortable and it would dump the sternum strap sliding mounts too often. I found half the sternum strap sitting in my lap on breaks on several occasions. The back of the slide is slotted to make the strap removable and it works too well.

I've since moved up to a Stoke 29 for my day hiking rig and wanted a small light pack for urban and travel use.

On the trail, my pack is my office and like waist belt pockets and easy organization. I don't want be digging around for sunscreen or other small items and I like easy access to my map and a sit pad. I prefer water bottles to bladders, so side pockets are handy. But all those straps and contraptions are in the way on a bus or plane.

For urban/travel use, I want just enough for rain shell or fleece, camera, phone, map or guide book, light umbrelka and a small zipper bag with the smaller items. That outside pocket on the Montbell is big enough for a small water bottle or platypus.

I compared the Montbell to the Ion due to the simplicity and weight. The Ion was also a panel loader and only 9oz. I could never figure our why Golite dropped the design. I would add water bottle pockets of course :)

I wish that Cilogear would make a 25 liter Worksack. The 20 is just a little small.

Dale Wambaugh BPL Member
PostedDec 22, 2013 at 12:34 pm

"As said sadly not available in US. But you guys have lots of other awesome cottage
pack makers. Why bother?"

You always want what you can't have :)

I'm happy with the MontBell, which is much lest expensive than any of the other options and certainly under the radar for urban/travel use.

I just never understood why GoLite stopped making the Ion. Considering they have the patterns and materials list and the cult following, it seems it would be an easy thing to fire up production on another batch.

Velimir Kemec BPL Member
PostedDec 22, 2013 at 1:35 pm

Hi

"You always want what you can't have :)" = that's why I have two Ions:)…
And for the price of single Eureka Moyo you get almost four Montbell packs above..interesting?

Cheers

Dale Wambaugh BPL Member
PostedDec 22, 2013 at 2:36 pm

"And for the price of single Eureka Moyo you get almost four Montbell packs above..interesting?"

Yup. Last trip to REI I saw the Flash 18 on sale for $24 or so and a new yet more complex and an ounce heavier version on the shelf for $34.50.

I've been through of these small packs over the years and none really floats my boat. Wider and flatter works better for me than the more cylindircal designs. The Ion is guilty there too. Something like a smaller Jam minus all the padding and hardware would be good.

If you want a small pack that hangs well, I think the old REI rucksack with a couple big pockets is the way to go.

Vintage REI rucksack

It has a teardrop shape in use, leaving your shoulders free and airy. The bulk of it sits in the small of your back with a low center of gravity. One of our cottage makers should make a design like this in Cuben with mesh pockets. Perfect for basic day hiking essentials/water/camera/clothes. Just make sure the straps are something that an adult male can use comfortably.

The Moyo is getting out there on volume— 27 liters, not to mention €69.95. Not bad at 290g/10.2oz.

I have a Stoke 29 that is kind of the next step up at 1.5lbs, with a full waist belt with pockets, 29L capacity and lots of other bells and whistles. I prefer that for a day pack to get the volume and more comfortable suspension. I was at the REI Gear Garage when they threw a perfect one in the bin for $21 :) KA CHING!

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
Loading...