Topic

Any reason to buy a cuben fiber ULA Circuit over a HMG Windrider 3400?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 20 total)
PostedDec 1, 2013 at 5:32 pm

Has anyone had experience with both?

The sense I get is that the Circuit may be a bit more comfortable. But the Windrider is supposedly actually waterproof while the cuben Circuit is not, not to mention being around 7 ounces heavier and $65 more expensive.

Thoughts?

I am trying to buy a pack I can use on the AT next year. I am looking at less than 12 pounds base weight (possibly less) not including pack weight.

PostedDec 1, 2013 at 5:57 pm

"the Windrider is actually waterproof while the cuben Circuit is not, not to mention being around 7 ounces heavier and $65 more expensive."

ULA has a great reputation, but the cost for a Cuben upgrade was a deal breaker for me. They also were using a lighter Cuben.

I've found the HMG 4400 pretty comfortable and it carries weight well. The 3400 should be plenty big. You might look at Zpacks as well.

J-L BPL Member
PostedDec 1, 2013 at 6:15 pm

I used to have a non-cuben ULA Circuit but have switched to a HMG 4400 SW. I find the HMG pack is more comfortable and carries heavy loads better. The suspension/frame/hipbelt are simple but work very well. The pack keeps out most rain but has let in some water during very deep river crossings. I still use a packliner for extra protection. The nicest thing about the fabrics used is that it gains very little weight when wet.

Try on a standard Circuit and a Windrider to see which one fits you best before deciding. The return shipping costs will be money well spent.

PostedDec 1, 2013 at 6:22 pm

Awesomely, I live in Portland OR, and Next Adventure carries ULA packs in stock. So I can try on the Circuit without paying for shipping.

Incidentally I am in Seattle today and stopped by the Feathered Friends store earlier which carries HMG packs which was what got me thinking about this in the first place.

Speaking of which, the FF employee seemed to think that the HMG packs would be even more durable than the standard ULA packs.

PostedDec 1, 2013 at 6:35 pm

I have looked at the Z-packs packs before. They are too minimal. I like having the belt pouches. I know you can add them, for an absurd price, but they look crappy. Z-packs are really out of the running.

Luke Schmidt BPL Member
PostedDec 1, 2013 at 7:02 pm

Personally I think a Circuit is way to big for an AT hike.

For reasons of my own I ordered a slightly customized Porter 3400 but if I was hiking the AT I'd pick the Windrunner 2400 for several reasons.

-I like the size, I doubt you'll need more space on the AT (I know I wouldn't). Dan at HMG told me the 2400 size is the most popular with AT hikers.

-I like the pocket set up. I like side mounted water bottles for easy access on the move. Hipbelt pockets are great for water treatment and cameras. The front mesh pocket would be nice for drying wet gear

-I like the way the hipbelt and frame are set up.

-The fabric is water proof and the seams are taped. Very nice if you hike in all day rain (I'd still us a pack liner for my critical gear).

PostedDec 2, 2013 at 11:50 am

Now I am considering the cuben OHM 2.0 too. It sounds as if it may be even lighter still than the Windrider, and only $40 more, in addition to being more customizable with removable features.

Steve Meier BPL Member
PostedDec 2, 2013 at 3:41 pm

I had a ULA CDT made in cuben and was surprised how heavy the cuben was. Actually wish it was lighter but feels well made and it is my go-to bag now. I buy ULA's for the S-shaped shoulder straps, which are awesome for broad shoulders. Too bad these packs weren't in REI so you could easily try them on. Someone mentioned the large size of the Circuit, which I have and why I went with the CDT. The Circuit is huge and the CDT is quite large as well. I had them to replace the cinch top with the fold and buckle, which gave me a larger expansion top for those times I need more space.CDT in cubenCDT 2

M B BPL Member
PostedDec 2, 2013 at 5:54 pm

Both great packs.
I have had 4 ULA packs, including 3 circuits.

Size isnt an issue to me. If you dont stuff your sleeping bag/quilt, a Circuit will never be too big. I have never used compression cord or side straps to compress any pack, I remove it to save wt. I dont undertand why any pack has compression stuff, unless you wanted to carry bowling balls.

Even with a 6.5 lb base, when you stick 7 days food in there, its getting pretty darn full, moreso with winter gear. If your a 3 day hiker in the summer only, then yeah, its too big. I have seen many many many circuits and catalysts on the AT.

When comparing wts, compare apples-apples and the difference wont be that large.

I havent used a windrider. The circuits water bottle pockets and mesh pocket are larger and appear much more useful. That is a big part of my packing style. I can actually do without hipbelt pockets and I may get a belt made without them.

The CDT and Ohm make extended use of ~1.1 nylon. Replacing that with 2.9 oz cuben hybrid doesnt exactly shave weight.

Ryan Smith BPL Member
PostedApr 26, 2014 at 7:51 pm

Matthew,

Did you end up going with the Windrider or the Circuit w/ cuben hybrid? What is your opinion now? I am facing this same decision and it's a tough one. I want an all black pack which means HMG will use 150d cuben hybrid(that's all they stock in black) which makes the weight & price pretty much a wash with the Circuit. The added durability of the 150d hybrid is nice, but I don't really need it. So, it comes down to fit, features, etc. I'm leaning towards the Circuit right now, but I've changed my mind about 10x. lol

Ryan

PostedApr 27, 2014 at 12:30 am

…that Matt thought better of his earlier assessment and again considered Zpacks' offerings…

Edited for grammatical reasons only.

PostedApr 27, 2014 at 9:25 am

If you go to Matt's profile and read back on some of his old posts he ended up getting the HMG pack, but he made an interesting comment that he is considering purchasing an ULA pack made of the original material. I found that to be interesting and would like to know his thoughts on why…

PostedApr 27, 2014 at 9:42 am

I have used both and prefer the HMG, but most of this comes down to what fits you best.

Ryan Smith BPL Member
PostedApr 27, 2014 at 10:23 am

Yeah, fit is the main factor at this point and of course the most challenging to test. Everything else seems pretty similar. Trying them on would take about an hours drive, but may be the best plan given that these packs are both custom and cost ~$350.

Ryan

PostedNov 30, 2014 at 3:47 pm

Hey, just getting around to these old threads after finishing my hike.

I went with the HMG Windrider 2400. I was very pleased with it. It definitely has some wear but its got a lot of miles left on it, IMO.

I found it to be very comfortable. I really like how easy it is to reach waterbottles in the side pockets by reaching back without taking the pack off. I also like not having to use a pack cover, and the side hip belt pockets are nice, if a bit small.

I took very good care of my pack (no tossing it, dragging it across rock, or sitting on it) and its is good condition still. Shows signs of a thru, but its mostly structurally intact. The only real issue is that it has some delaminating occurring on the inside where it rolls up, but the owner at least claims the new packs have fixed that issue (and he did correctly guess I had an older model pack).

As far as why I went with this pack – price was a large factor. I bought a 2013 model for about 70% of the list price during a closeout sale. The Zpacks packs are way to expensive IMO as are the cuben ULAs. I do own a regular fabric ULA and truthfully I do feel that that material would outlast the cuben material, but its heavier and not waterproof.

…and that's about it.

Ryan Smith BPL Member
PostedNov 30, 2014 at 3:54 pm

I ended up going with the ULA in cuben hybrid and have been pleased with it. Chose the Circuit because 1) I've dealt with ULA in the past and they have always been great and 2) the ULA has a better set of features IMO. Both could easily carry the 30-35lbs I had planned.

I will say this – the cuben hybrid is no match for granite.

Ryan

PostedNov 30, 2014 at 4:46 pm

Like Dave, I too have had the pleasure of using both packs. I was actually looking for a used Ohm to go down a size on my Circuit when a good deal on the HMG became available. I'm glad it did too since the HMG rides better [for me] than the Circuit hip belt did. I have mentioned this before in the forums – the ULA hip belt on my Circuit would start aggravating my left upper hip flexors after two days of carry. The HMG has never presented the same aggravation – again, for me and YMMV.

That being said, I agree with a lot of the build components of the ULA, so much that I moved the hand straps to my HMG pack using a couple of small biners. Either pack will do you well and I am glad to see ULA now offering a cuben option.

PostedNov 30, 2014 at 5:32 pm

On a side note, you can get a black 150d hybrid cuben now on the HMG packs. It adds a couple of ounces, but the fabric is considerably thicker and stiffer, and presumably more durable.

PostedDec 2, 2014 at 5:04 am

Found that the Circuit just fits me better. The posters that are advising you to go with the one that fits the best are correct. It isn't worth saving a couple of ounces to have something that doesn't carry well on YOU.

Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 20 total)
Loading...