"I imagine the most epic and dire situations would start out with the loss of my pack due to avalanche, precipice, river, theft, or some situation I could not foresee.. If I haven't lost my pack and all its luxuries I would not call that situation 'survival'- I'd call it 'camping'."
I completely agree. While many of the above "kitchen sink" survival kits would definitely up your comfort level (and probably your odds) during a survival situation, I think the size/complexity of the kit would lend it self to be left behind while you wash up or taken off while asleep.
I think the ultimate goal of a survival situation is to stay alive until rescue/escape, not build a small wilderness outpost.
Obviously, knowledge, skill, and will are the most important survival tools. Knowing how to build shelter and fire and find water will keep most people alive for long enough without any gear. That said, a few tools kept on the person, AT ALL TIMES, will lesson the burden. A knife, fire starter, water container/cook pot, emerg. poncho/garbage bag/emerg. blanket combined with the skills above will make the goings much smoother. Throw in a compact compass and signaling devices (whistle and/or mirror (knife blade can work)) and thats all you should need for a true SHTF, keep your ass alive situation.
I keep on my person at all times a knife and photon. When I enter the woods, I add a whistle, a key chain compass and a firesteel to a lanyard with the photon. These items never leave me, even while asleep. A water bottle, a Ti Cup, a warm hat and a emerg. blanket in a small pack stay with me most of the time…Depending on the weather/area, I may add a few things to the pack.
I imagine being woken up in the night by a starving furry monster with big teeth and by the time I have come to my senses and catch my breath, I realize, in a cold november night, I'm far from camp with nothing but what I was sleeping in…disoriented and scared…Did I grab the kitchen sink?



