Sep 30, 2013 at 8:42 pm #1308233
So, after talking about the layered silk with thin, lightweight cord on another thread recently, i've also hit on the idea to do this with some baselayers and mid layers.
The experiment. Buy some ultra cheap and lightweight, thin, hollow core polypropylene cord (significantly lighter than even dyneema/spectra [and MUCH cheaper]! though obviously much less strong) and take some of my baselayers and mid layers and add a lattice (criss crossed/vertical-horizontal) of cord across the surface either by fabric tape or sewing, or a combo.
Since i suspect it won't be particularly comfortable directly on the skin, i would put it on the outside of the baselayer and on the outside of the mid layer.
It will create a lot more still air space in-between the layers, increasing the warmth at very little weight. 3/16th cord maybe? Or thinner? What say you?
For shits and giggles (and research and PROGRESS), one or two of you who live in or backpack at much colder climates than myself, here's a proposition. You send me one of your cheaper baselayer and mid layer, i will polypro cord it up and send it back free of charge, and you test it your much colder climate than mine (VA, U.S.) and report back. There are number of people here who could (or should) vouch for my honesty and integrity since i've made and sent Kapok pillows to people here (or sent just the stuffing) and only asked for actual shipping price, or sent linen shirts to folks for shipping price. I will put a pic of myself up too.
I'm also going to try it myself, and combine with my Polypro fishnet baselayer, to see what happens. But i have a while to wait before any real cold hits :( (i actually like the cold, well to about 15f).
I have a couple projects to finish up before i can or should start this though. Will give it time to cool down some too.Sep 30, 2013 at 11:11 pm #2029801
Well in any case, i just bought 1000 feet of 1/8 inch polypropylene cord for about 26 dollars. I just might do my whole cold weather wardrobe (joking).
Let the experimentation commence…Oct 1, 2013 at 7:00 am #2029843
Yeah, I'll help. Massachusetts/VT/NH/ME. I would like to see pictures of what it looks like when done first, though, if you don't mind.
Cheers!Oct 1, 2013 at 7:21 am #2029855
Hah, fashion has no place in backpacking or innovating gear! ;p
In any case, the cord i ordered is bright neon yellow…. consider it extra safety measure. ;)
But yeah, i will do one of my garments first and put a pic up.Oct 4, 2013 at 8:58 pm #2030942
Ok Max, are you ready…i said, are YOU READY!???? Enough theatrics, bam!
Ok, so this was a prototype. You will note that i first tried sewing it…yeah, silly me. So then i tried the fusible bonding stuff, which required me to put some kind of fabric over the cord. Since this was just a prototype and i was impatient to get er done, i used whatever fabric i had plenty of left overs of. Which happened to be a somewhat heavy, 65% Polyester-35% Linen blend. Note that at first, i used too much fabric and fusible stuff and it became increasingly more narrow as i refined my approach.
I weighed the amount of Polypropylene cord i used in the shirt, and it came out to .7 oz. Next shirt i make, i will use a lightweight silk to be the top fabric. Max, this too could be yours, for the low, low, low price of well, nothing except shipping to me. I have my system down, so i won't flubb up your baselayer as i flubbed mine up a bit (but please send me a cheaper or less favorite one just in case). I think i have some light weight silk laying around somewhere. It's white/off white colored, so a white baselayer would make sense.Oct 4, 2013 at 9:01 pm #2030943
Me g'quing it up. I know, you're jealous, and i can't blame you.Oct 5, 2013 at 3:08 am #2030978
mik matraBPL Member
@mikmikLocale: Brisbane AUSTRALIA
that this is a fantastic idea!! But it seems that you may need a LOT more cordage to actually separate the 2 garments you are wearing especially if they are thin garments as they will touch (especially around bends of contour of the body). Nice to see some great innovation!!Oct 5, 2013 at 7:25 am #2030995
James KleinBPL Member
I can vouch for Justin's honesty – he's legit.
Justin have you seen this thread:
I think you could use some 1/8" foam from gossamergear in a grid a pattern similar to your cordage above and come in around 1 oz (the foam is ~3oz/sqyd).Oct 5, 2013 at 5:06 pm #2031093
Yeah, as soon as i put it on, i realized that i realistically would need more cord on it, but i'm not sure i would say a lot per se. I think 3 more on the front should do it for the front, and then some down the sides. I don't actually want it on the back because i figure especially with a pack on, the back gets too hot as it is.
Thank you for the good feedback and positive vibes, much appreciated.Oct 5, 2013 at 5:14 pm #2031095
Yeah, i did see Daryl's thread on the foam. So would you think i should cut strips of it off and glue or fuse it on a shirt, or do sort of like a vest like Daryl's but with spaces for ventilation?
A separate vest might make more sense as far as that goes, because i don't think foam would handle being washed and dried as clothing very well.
Perhaps a separate foam vest with lot's of ventilation, in combo with a base or mid layer with more cord, might be more ideal? I honestly don't think that shirt would require a lot more cord to work as planned. Definitely needs some more, but like i told Mik, i don't want extra insulation on the back, though i realize that the front and sides does need some more cord.
Thank you for the feedback.Oct 5, 2013 at 5:39 pm #2031100
Brett PeughBPL Member
I am totally missing what is going on here. Please explain.Oct 5, 2013 at 6:08 pm #2031109
Hi Brett, the idea is sort of akin to, and was inspired by the concept of Fishnet baselayers. The idea behind those is really well explained in a BPL article that was written a little while back about Fishnet baselayers. A lesser summary follows below.
Anyways, it's less the fabric and material which insulates and creates warmth for us, but rather the "air it traps". If you can create a layer of more still air, like with what happens with a Fishnet baselayer, with subsequent layers over the top of same, this insulates just as well as well knitted or weaved, many fiber containing garment. Ultimately, a wind resistant outer seems very necessary to such systems, but most of use something like that anyways.
So what i'm trying to do with the corded shirt, is to put some constant air space in between one layer and another, creating more insulation at less weight than a full fabric would usually entail (except for down because it's so light and efficient at creating still air space and "trapping air"). I don't have enough cord on the shirt though, to fully implement this (as others have pointed out).
The obvious advantage over down and even a lot of fully knitted or woven fabrics, is moisture is no problem. Also one can very quickly vent the heat and moisture should it become necessary to do so. Just open up one's windshirt outer, and ah, let the heat and moisture escape. Also don't have to worry about drying times as much, especially using something like Polypro cord since it's so hydrophobic. Since the PP cord is encased in fabric, it should be less stinky too.
Hope this helps. This thread should probably be on MYOG section…Oct 6, 2013 at 8:34 am #2031204
One issue using foam is packability/compression. The corded shirt packs up surprisingly well.Oct 6, 2013 at 12:25 pm #2031267
@hipassLocale: Los Angeles
Tron prototype costume?
Did your wife find out about this project yet and if so what was your explanation?Is she buying it also?Oct 6, 2013 at 4:46 pm #2031326
Haha Dave… No, she's been away at a Burning Man regional in Ohio, but she shall find out tonight. Yeah, maybe i'll say it's my costume…
(she doesn't mind my projects too much, unless they happen to cost $$, fortunately for me this is a relatively cheap one, but i'm not sure why i ordered 1000 ft of the cord).Oct 6, 2013 at 4:58 pm #2031330
Mark VerberBPL Member
@verberLocale: San Francisco Bay Area
I appreciate the DIY idea using the corded shirt, but I would suggest that the grid version of powerdry that patagonia started to use in the Cap 4 hoody in 2012 is fishnet done right. There are air voids in the grid pattern, and the fabric wicks moisture away from body and spreads it over a wider area which isn't touching skin. Extremely air permeable, so controlling ventilation with a windshirt or some sort of shell lets it be worn in an amazingly wide range of conditions. In my case I have been comfortable when active between 25-65 with the variables being whether I was using a wind shirt, hood used, sleeve down or pushed up.
–MarkOct 6, 2013 at 5:51 pm #2031346
Thanks, it looks interesting and pretty nice–haven't seen it in person but would like to. Unfortunately for us poorer folk, it's got that Patagucci price tag though–119 retail, which seems pretty high for a fleece, albeit, a specialized one.
If i use the right materials–especially if i make a shirt from scratch, i can get the weight of the corded shirt design pretty darn low. Actually, my new Polypro 3.4 oz shirt would work great for this, combined with some lightweight nylon to bond the pp cord (i will have to be careful with the iron though, PP would be easy to melt).
I could get the weight down to about 5 oz or less i imagine. Wouldn't use it as a baselayer as it would stink too much.
But if i combine it with a true fishnet baselayer top (which i have one of), and a windshirt, i don't think it can be beat in terms of a combo of weight, warmth, moisture management, and adaptability. At a very low price to boot.Oct 6, 2013 at 9:47 pm #2031412
Mark VerberBPL Member
@verberLocale: San Francisco Bay Area
> it's got that Patagucci price tag though–119 retail, which seems pretty high for a fleece,
ouch. yeah, I forgot what it's retail price tag is. I actually think it's worth that because it is such a great piece, but this is when having a patagonia outlet nearby combined with memorial day / labor day sales is a boon because it can sometimes be found for sub $50. Still not cheap, but more reasonable.
Good luck with your experiment. It's always good t fine DIY solutions which work and are affordable!
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.