Topic

MYOG Tent plans and details

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 20 total)
PostedSep 23, 2013 at 3:58 pm

I have had some requests to provide details on a tent I designed as a solution to a problem detailed in this thread "Lightweight tent for the Scottish Highlands"
(http://www.backpackinglight.com/cgi-bin/backpackinglight/forums/thread_display.html?forum_thread_id=78532&startat=60)

s8s12s10planinchesplanmetric

It is a double walled tent weighing 960 grams (34 oz.) which so far has performed well in strong winds. To try and minimise weight, I designed it so that the space (and fabric) is where it is needed and nowhere else. There is a lot of width at arm level, sit-up headroom and then very narrow and low with just enough foot space at the other end.

The tent has 2 doors on the right hand side. They can open individually, depending on wind direction, or the whole side of the tent can be opened up. I originally intended to put a door on either side of the tent, but I wouldn't have had rain protected entrances that way. Also, with the weather we get in Scotland, sometimes it is best just to stay in the tent and having the extra internal space makes it a lot more comfortable.

The flysheet is 30D silnylon at 50 grams/m2,from Extrem Textil in Germany. They have a lot of tent accessories too and are a good source if you are based in Europe.

The original alloy poles I got from China, which are fine but weigh about 60 grams/metre. I have since changed these to Easton Nanolite, at about 45 grams/metre. Quest Outfitters stock these.

The inner tent is made from nylon panels, with a large mesh panel in the door. I got the nylon from Extrem Textil also, it weighs 38 grams/m2. It is not ripstop though, and it was also very difficult to sew. They have now replaced it with a ripstop nylon of the same weight, which I haven't tried yet.

The floor is PU coated nylon, weighing 56 grams/m2 (2 oz.), available from just about any fabric supplier in the UK. I used the heavier PU coated for the bathtub floor rather than silnylon as the ground is almost always wet here and I have had seepage through a silnylon floor before. I think the extra 30 or 40 grams of weight is well worth it especially as it can be difficult to dry stuff out here.

I used a No. 5 zip for the flysheet door with double sliders, to open from top or bottom. The inner tent has a No. 3 curved zip with double sliders, which after much experimentation, I have concluded that 400mm radius is the tightest it will go without kinking. People more skilled at sewing than I might be able to do better than this though. The No.3 zip weighs half that of the No. 5 and I was tempted to use this for the flysheet doors also, but decided to err on the safe side.

I used 1mm dyneema guylines with mini clam cleats, but I think I will change it to 2mm, the 1mm stuff is a bit difficult to get a grip off.

I could probably have got the weight down to below 900 grams (32 oz) but I didn't want to take any chances with several big hikes in the pipeline.

Weight breakdown:

Flysheet 390 grams (14 oz)
Inner tent 321 grams (11 oz)
Alloy poles 131 grams (5 oz)
Pegs 8@ 6 gms 48 grams (2 oz)
Guylines, cleats etc 25 grams (1 oz)
Stuff sack 15 grams (0.5 oz)
Seam sealing 30 grams (1 oz)

I have recently started using it without the inner tent as the midges are not so bad now, this gives me a shelter weight of 640 grams (22 oz) and a much smaller pack size.

Jerry Adams BPL Member
PostedSep 23, 2013 at 4:11 pm

nice! well made, Panels are taut.

now if you would just put a blank line between each picture it would read better

Stuart R BPL Member
PostedSep 24, 2013 at 12:08 pm

Interesting design and very well made! It’s really good to see inovative alternatives to mainstream offerings. I don’t use poles myself so my solution for the same conditions is here. It has not been out in extreme wind but did keep us dry in a major thunderstorm in the Pyrenees this year.

PostedSep 24, 2013 at 2:40 pm

That's a pretty nifty hybrid Trekking Pole/ Tent pole design!

PostedSep 24, 2013 at 8:18 pm

Marc,
Most impressive, and may set minimalists to drooling.
How you got the weight down so much for a double wall with a vestibule and plenty of room for Fido is amazing, especially without using lighter fabric around 15 denier for the canopy.

If Eureka were to make one of those, they'd use a big, fat tube for the spreader bar, and put a hole though the middle of it the size of a ferrule projecting from the Easton pole, do something like Lightheart does to glom the ends of the bar onto the Trekking poles, and thus make the tent 'freestanding.' With little thought given to weight, of course.

Since many more folks carry at least one trekking pole, perhaps you can conjure up something with just one trekking pole, and one flexible pole. Not 'freestanding', but lighter still. Or maybe one trekking pole and two flexible ones for more interior room and stability.

Thank you again for reposting your tent on MYOG with the additional details.

PostedSep 25, 2013 at 12:49 am

Thanks Stuart.

It was from reading your thread and seeing the professional job you did that originally inspired me to have an attempt myself.

PostedSep 25, 2013 at 1:08 am

Thanks Sam.

This is my favourite tent to use now, and I think it's just because of the interior space, having the width to bring the backpack into the tent and spread all the stuff out without rummaging about trying to find things (and letting the midges in).

Not sure about a 1 trekking pole design, I think the MLD Trailstar would be a very hard act to follow, but it has got me thinking.

I recently spent a week in a tunnel tent, and after reading Roger Caffin's articles about tunnel's advantages and seeing his excellent tents I have to agree that the space to weight ratio is really good. So I think my next project will be a freestanding tunnel tent.

PostedSep 25, 2013 at 5:04 am

No, neither have I. I was hoping one of the manufacturer's would make one, I can think of many situations where it would be the ideal tent. I would certainly buy one.

Anyway, I have a design, not sure if it will work, but there is only one way to find out. If only I could get my wife's stuff out of the garage…

PostedSep 26, 2013 at 6:39 am

"a freestanding tunnel tent
never seen one of those…"

How about the old MSR Fling?

f

PostedSep 26, 2013 at 8:22 am

"a freestanding tunnel tent
never seen one of those…"

Never noticed that one before. Shows it's possible though. A strange looking beast, almost like just over half of a Tarptent Moment. Single wall though. I wonder how well it would fare in a hoolie, and just how much that top pole is contributing to it.

PostedSep 26, 2013 at 2:22 pm

Yes I do know the Fling, but by definition once you add a ridge pole it isn't a tunnel tent anymore.
The same way as a bike with three wheels becomes a trike.
The Exped Polaris is a bit like that.
(no , not a trike, a freestanding "sort of tunnel" tent)
See also Moss Outland/Olympic Vintage

PostedSep 26, 2013 at 2:57 pm

Yes, I suppose you are right. It's a very similar pole structure to the Golite Imogene, which I wouldn't think of as a tunnel tent.

It's certainly not what I had in mind. I don't want to carry an extra 3rd pole to make it freestanding.

PostedSep 26, 2013 at 3:39 pm

Mark,
Before the Fling GoLite had the Den (sans 3rd pole)
The problem with that design is that if you set it tail in the wind and the wind changes direction, you cannot leave the door open.
Obviously this is more so when it rains.

PostedSep 27, 2013 at 2:20 am

Franco

I see what you mean.

Now that is definitely not a tent for the highlands!

PostedSep 27, 2013 at 8:32 am

This shape of a tent, with side door(s), is my favorite.

I'm part Scottish. Maybe that is a factor?

PostedSep 27, 2013 at 9:43 am

Daryl Daryl

That is a nice looking tent! Did you post details about it? I had a quick look though your previous postings but there are 174 pages of them.

I take it that being up in the Pacific Northwest, you get quite a bit of rain also. You have the wide panels at either end, so you can open up the sides and get the views and a good airflow without getting wet? Is my thinking correct?

I have just completed a very similar looking design, so maybe it is a Scottish thing. It works fine here most of the time, until the rain starts coming in horizontally at 60 mph, then those sides get closed up pretty sharpish.

PostedSep 28, 2013 at 8:31 am

Marc,

“Is my thinking correct?”

Yes.

Here’s a link. I had trouble finding it too.

here

I experienced some of your wet weather when my wife and I walked the Highland Way a couple of years ago. Yes, it was very similar to weather here in the Pacific Northwest.

PostedSep 28, 2013 at 11:30 am

Daryl

Thanks for the link.

That it is a superb tent. Nice solutions and a clever design!

I'm afraid my tent has an uncanny resemblance to yours, perhaps it is a result of the similar climates. I didn't get anywhere near as light as yours though or the range of height adjustment.

Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 20 total)
Loading...