Topic

Beefing up a Zia grill

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
Gary Dunckel BPL Member
PostedSep 20, 2013 at 11:14 am

Of the >250 Zia grills that I've sold over the past 4 years, I received feedback from 3 people who mentioned that their grills sagged horribly when used over a very hot fire. It wasn't clear how much weight they loaded onto their grills, or exactly where they placed their grills. In many uses of my own grills, I've not experienced this during my normal use, but I always position my grill in a small alcove off to the side of my main campfire. During my early field testing, I intentionally placed a very heavy load, about 5 pounds, on a grill, and there indeed was a bit of sagging over a 2-hour testing period. However, one thing is clear–the properties of titanium do change a little when the temperature of the metal exceeds around 1600*F, which can cause the grill to sag. This is completely reversible, and when the grill cools back down it becomes quite normal again.

So in the interest of improving things in the field for those who want a grill of greater strength while remaining very lightweight, I came up with an idea. By reinforcing the grill with extra titanium rods of greater heat resistance, I have increased the load capacity significantly.

The first photo shows a regular grill, with four titanium split rings attached to the little "triangles" between the first and second cross braces in the four corners. In the foreground are 2 prototype 12" Stix, and a regular 9" Stix for comparison.

Basic grill with split rings and Stix

I placed 2 steel propane canisters on the grill. The 3# 12 oz. weight was obviously too much for the grill, and significant sagging occurred. And of course this would worsen if the grill was positioned over a very hot fire. The grills work OK for loads up to maybe 2 pound loads, and placed over a less intense heat source, like a bed of hot coals.

Loaded grill without support Stix

In this photo, two of the 12" Stix have been inserted into the split rings on each side and positioned under the grill to support the sides.

Stix supports inserted

Finally, I loaded up the grill with a heavy 11# 11 oz. Note that there is only a nominal amount of sag of the grill in the cold state. Again, intense heat will cause some sagging, but the grill was never intended to support loads this large.

Loaded grill with Stix

So why is all this presented in Gear Deals, you ask? Well, I had several pair of the longer Stix made for use in studying if this concept might work, and I need some beta testers to help add to my knowledge base. First off, I don't want anyone to respond unless they will give this a good run of tests and report back to me. Secondly, I would rather this be done by members that have been around BPL for some time, whose profile I am familiar with, and who aren't just here to buy and sell gear. I'll choose who I think will be good beta testers.

So here's what I will do, for three people: If you purchase a grill and set of 6 Stix at my normal BPL price of $75, I will attach the 4 split rings to the grill, and also include 2 of the longer Stix support rods. By the way, the longer Stix are quite useful for other things too. For example, in YNP I was unable to reach the only feasible tree limb stub to hang my gravity filtration bag, and the Stix extended my reach to make it easy. And being 12" long, they would be perfect to measure the wall thickness of a quinzee. Or to use as a fire poker.

The reason I'm doing this is that I want to learn if there's a reason to order a bunch more of these longer Stix. For those interested in giving this a try, please post here on this thread, and then fire off a PM to me. We can then work out the details, exchange e-mail addresses confidentially, etc.

Thanks for indulging me, folks. Now it's time to post this, then come back and correct my spelling mistakes… (edited, because there was at least one…)

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedSep 20, 2013 at 11:22 am

In your photos, those cinder blocks look pretty heavy. I don't know if I want to carry that much.

–B.G.–

Gary Dunckel BPL Member
PostedSep 20, 2013 at 1:06 pm

C'mon, Bob, hanging a few bricks from your pack is macho, chicks will dig you, and the squirrels will respect you in the morning. But to avoid that, just camp in construction areas, or places that have recently been bombed–usually you'll find lots of good bricks to set your grill on.

(Edit–for my usual spelling errors)

Gary Dunckel BPL Member
PostedFeb 2, 2014 at 1:09 pm

Update. There wasn't any interest when I asked for beta testers of this concept. The reason I needed some help is that the September flooding in the Boulder, CO area shut down all 5 of my access roads to the Indian Peaks, and I couldn't get up there to do my own testing. Then I realized I could do a major test right here at home. I placed 2 fire bricks in my cast iron chiminea, built serious fires with very hot burning pinon pine, and I tested the grill under those conditions. I placed a 1.8# load of water in a disposable pot made from big can of chili. The results are as follows:

The regular grill without the reinforcement sagged within a couple of minutes. This was a complete failure. Then I removed the pot and grill from the fire to let them cool back down, while I added more pinon to keep the fire roaring.

I then I inserted the two titanium support Stix into the split rings along the sides of the grill, set it on the bricks and over the fire, and placed a cold pot of ice water on the grill. This time it took about 8-10 minutes before the grill began to sag. It drooped very slowly at first, but then I realized that it wasn't going to work very well. I stopped that test at the 12 minute mark, and the 2.5 cups of water had nearly reached a boil. The .125" diameter titanium rods certainly added some strength to the grill, but not as much as I had hoped.

The next test was to use .125" diameter stainless steel rods to support the sides of the grill. That worked perfectly, and there was no significant sagging of the grill at all, even after a period of 20+ minutes over such a hot fire. I repeated the stainless steel test several times in succession, each time changing out the water for more very cold ice water (I wasn't interested in learning the time to boil, I just wanted to test the grill performance under a constant weight load). After 4 tests total, there was no sagging of the grill, and my research was finished. Stainless steel is the way to go, even though it adds a little extra weight to the setup.

So I consigned my rod-bending friend to make some Stix out of stainless steel. He had to fit it into his schedule, and it took a few months for him to get done. But I now have a moderate supply of 13" Stix in stainless steel, as well as a number of 13" titanium Stix. I never have needed any additional support for my grill when I camp, but I never expose it to intense heat either. I expect that the titanium support Stix will add just enough additional support to allow a slightly heavier load to be placed upon the grill over a small-to-moderate fire. But for serious strength, the stainless steel is what is needed.

Two days ago, I tested the new stainless steel Stix with one of my prototype grills on my kitchen gas stove. Again using the fire bricks to support the grill, I turned the burner on high and let it rip. Same results as in the chininea–the unsupported grill failed miserably when exposed to such a high heat. The titanium Stix supports did a lot better, but they too sagged a little after 10 minutes. The stainless steel never once sagged. I even raised the weight load on the grill. The SS Stix easily supported a 4# weight load for >30 minutes without sagging.

Here's what the assembled grill/Stix looks like (in the snow–sorry):

Grill and SS Stix, in snow

Then, a close-up showing a titanium split ring that the Stix slips into on the underside of the grill:

Split ring for Stix

I am offering to sell these grills, with the split rings and stainless steel Stix, exclusively to members of the BPL community. I have a limited number of the Stix, so these probably won't be around very long. Depending on demand, I may or may not have more of the SS Stix made when these are sold. The shipped price of one of these is $60. If anyone is interested in the titanium 13" Stix, you might consider ordering a set of 6 regular Stix for the usual price of $30, and I can swap out 2 for the longer ones (so, 4 regular and 2 long Stix for $30).

By the way, here are the weights for each product:

Grill with split rings—-.9 oz. (26 gm.)
2 stainless steel Stix—1.7 oz. (48 gm.)–This becomes a pretty strong grill for
just 2.6 oz.
2 titanium Stix (13")—-1.0 oz. (28 gm.)
Regular Stix (10"), each-.35 oz. (10 gm.)

By the way, I won't be able to sell the split rings and SS Stix separately at this point. Placing the split rings isn't an easy task, and I feel that I should do that. But if you already have your grill, you could mail it to me. For a small charge (say, $10 + return shipping), I would be happy to place the rings on your grill and include the 2 SS Stix. But I won't be able to do this for a few months, as I see how fast these assembled grill/Stix combinations sell.

You can reach me by PM, or preferably, by sending an e-mail to me at drzooz(at)aol(dot)com

Now that the groundhog has seen his shadow, we can move on to the Super Bowl. Although I'm pulling for the Broncos, it doesn't really matter who wins. The losers still get to live in a beautiful place after the game is over.

Gary Dunckel BPL Member
PostedFeb 3, 2014 at 11:00 am

OK, I lied about it not mattering who won the Super Bowl. My Denver Donkeys were humiliated, and it took me back to the '80s when Elway was repeatedly blasted by the NFC. I'm grumpy today.

So to make me a bit happier, I've decided to sell the beefed-up Zia grill setup with the stainless steel Stix supports for $50 during the month of February. So that's like buying a grill at the usual price, but you get the cute little titanium split rings and a pair of burly stainless steel support Stix for free. What's not to like about that? In March, when I've forgotten about the Super Bowl and the days get longer and warmer, I'll bump the price back up to $60.

(Please note that I might have to access a $500 surcharge for any Seahawks fan.)

Gary Dunckel BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2014 at 10:23 am

I was contacted by a person with a question. He wanted to know if the stainless steel support Stix were fixed in place on the sides of the grill. The answer is no. The Stix slide into and out of the titanium split rings. So, depending on what you intend to do with the grill, you can take the grill only, or you can take the SS Stix along to add good strength to the grill when loading it up heavily or for use over a very hot fire. The Stix also work great as backup tent stakes, and all the other multiple uses for them. At 2.6 oz., these beefed-up grills will handle high campfire heat, and they're likely the lightest full service grill option available anywhere.

Link . BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2014 at 10:50 am

Gary, I know I told you not to worry about the Superbowl but at least it was really close :0 So I guess with the $500 surcharge I will wait little while to see if you forget about the game…. but I am not holding my breath .

Gary Dunckel BPL Member
PostedFeb 25, 2014 at 9:17 am

So February is coming to a close shortly, and this is your friendly reminder that the beefed-up grills are on sale through March 1st.

Also, I'm over that Super Bowl loss, and there will no longer be the $500 surcharge for you Seahawks fans. So you're good to go, Link, except that you already have a grill. As for you others, you might want to move on this before it's too late.

Gary Dunckel BPL Member
PostedFeb 28, 2014 at 8:42 am

Last reminder, folks. Today and tomorrow the beefed-up grill will be shipped to you for $50. So for the price of a regular grill, you get 2 free 13" long stainless steel support rods and 4 titanium split rings (which can be removed if you like). The stainless steel Stix make great back scratchers, as well as somewhat heavy backup tent stakes. Also, if you like, I would be happy to swap out the SS Stix for long titanium ones. These are lighter of course, and they do offer a significant amount of support, but not nearly as much as the stainless steel ones. Keep in mind that everything can be disassembled, giving you a regular grill at the usual price. Two more days to decide…

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
Loading...