Topic

Black bear becomes first Alaskan to test new ‘stand-your-ground’ law as hikers call 911

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
James holden BPL Member
PostedSep 13, 2013 at 2:10 pm

more at link …

http://www.alaskadispatch.com/article/20130729/black-bear-becomes-first-alaskan-test-new-stand-your-ground-law-hikers-call-911

You could sense it might go bad as soon as you heard they had packed rain ponchos instead of a tent for a two-to-three-day camping trip. Juan Duran — a soldier from Houston, Texas, now stationed on Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson — might have made it over Crow Pass solo, but his wife Cindy and younger sister Dafne — the other members of the party — had never camped before.

The Crow Pass Trail is approximately 26 miles long with a 3,500-foot gain in elevation approaching from the Eagle River side. No one insisted on bringing a tent or mosquito netting, even though this has been one of the worst years for mosquitoes in a long time. None of them expected to run into a bear. The bears are what finally triggered the 911 call.

…..

There seems to be two schools of thought when unprepared people encounter a black bear. One hypothesis is that all bears should run away from a human. The other hypothesis holds that all bears want to kill you. The reality is somewhere in between, although seeing the bear run over the mountain is far more likely than experiencing any kind of aggressive behavior. These hikers seemed to initially believe Hypothesis 1 would carry the day. When all the bears didn’t run, the hikers downshifted to Hypothesis 2.

…..

The hikers made many mistakes, any one of which might have triggered an avalanche of troubles that could have resulted in a real emergency. But the final mistake they made was calling 911. They were not in any imminent danger, and they would have realized that if they had taken the time to be more prepared. By calling the universal emergency telephone number they “cried wolf,” expecting officials to bail them out of a situation that happens a dozen or more times a day in the Anchorage area: the simple, although admittedly astonishing act of encountering a black bear on its own terms.

;)

Dena Kelley BPL Member
PostedSep 14, 2013 at 2:22 pm

I live 20 minutes from the trailhead in question, and sort of consider it my "back yard", hiking there many times each year. I am amazed anyone would attempt to do it as an overnighter with ponchos. I'm going to blame the guy for exhibiting REALLY poor judgment- he may have made it, but to take two newbies that way was just asinine. They also did the trip backwards- nearly everyone starts in Girdwood and ends in Eagle River because if you do it that way there's one steep mountain to start and then it's roughly downhill the rest of the way. His route was all uphill- subtly to start but growing ever steeper. The ladies most likely would have enjoyed it a lot more if they'd just got the elevation gain out of the way when they were fresh.

This WAS the worst mosquito year I've ever seen in my 40 years here, although the hot weather we had in June/July seems to have killed them off because August was about the most bug-free I've ever seen it. Bears are a regular sight on the Crow Pass trail – as they are in most areas in Alaska- but normally aren't a problem. There have been a few Grizzly attacks there, Eagle River starts at Eagle Glacier and is a salmon spawning river so you need to be more vigilant when the salmon are running. They did close part of the trail this year due to a bear killing a moose and caching it right on the trail.

Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
Loading...