Jun 14, 2013 at 8:08 am #1304207
What is the conventional wisdom regarding floorless shelters (i.e., no bathtub floor) and down sleeping bags? I'm thinking about shelters along the lines of the SMD Wild Oasis, MLD Solomid, and the like. Is lying directly on your groundsheet (on your inflatable pad) a good idea? My concern would be with water running into the shelter and compromising your insulation. When would a bivy be needed to protect your bag?Jun 14, 2013 at 8:17 am #1996580
I move around too much at night to stay on my pad. I guess if I strapped the bag to the pad it might stay together.
So I say if your shelter keeps rain off your groundsheet, and you keep the bag on the groundsheet, no need for a bivy.Jun 14, 2013 at 8:24 am #1996581
@bster13Locale: Norwalk, CT
I use polycro groundsheet, sleeping pad and a tarp with my down bag with no troubles. I'd do the same inside any other floorless shelter. Maybe consider a hammock (my new 3 season shelter) if u toss and turn a lot. I've never slept better.Jun 14, 2013 at 8:25 am #1996582
"My concern would be with water running into the shelter and compromising your insulation"
If you have water running into your shelter you picked a bad site to set up. To me if you have a fully enclosed shelter you should not need a bivy… Isn't that the point of haveing one? Using a bivy in a tarp is for the spray that you get from not being fully enclosed.Jun 14, 2013 at 8:42 am #1996587
@owareLocale: Steptoe Butte
I don't always bring a bivy, even tho I make them. Like they said, site selection is a big part of tarp camping.
Where a bivy is necessary with a floorless shelter.
Ledges, cliff bases etc where you have no choice in site selection as to prevent water running under the tarp.
High Desert, alpine, tundra etc. where high winds can suck the heat from your sleeping bag or quilt.
Tundra, Swamps etc where bugs can overwhelm a headnet.
Where it is nice.
Desert, Dunes on river trips, to keep blowing sand out of your sleep system.
Dirty campsites to help protect an expensive down bag.
Using a quilt, to keep the edges out of the dirt and prevent drafts.
Storing extra clothes, safe but handy if the night turns cold.Jun 14, 2013 at 9:42 am #1996612
To counter some opinions it must be said that on occasion in the Southeast forests we get deluge rainstorms which soak the ground and produce both "ground sheeting" and "lake effect"—you're sitting in a pool of water. I liken it to what happened to Jared Hendren in this BPL link—(though he wasn't in the Southeast)—
He said— "Next it started to rain, really hard, like inches per hour hard. Water started coming under the tarp everywhere, pretty soon all of the ground under the tarp was saturated, and puddles started forming."
Old hands will say "better site selection" but sometimes if the rain is heavy enough no site will stay dry as a deluge produces a half inch of sheeting water moving downhill. Often this water will come over a ground cloth and form pools under a bivy or a sleeping bag and gear. Examples of ground water below—
I call this "lake effect".
This is "sheeting" where I was camped on a never-used site on a slight hill in dead leaves (Big Frog wilderness).
So, some tarps have bathtub floor inserts (with bug netting) and perhaps a good bivy will keep water off your bag if the bivy is sitting in a pool of water—but maybe not.Jun 14, 2013 at 10:06 am #1996617
@rosyfinchLocale: the mountains
There are a ton of campsites in the High Sierra that are shallow lakes when a thunderstorm passes through. Sometimes it seems that most campsites are this way… or that the best ones with the best views. Being so enamored with the beauty of a particular camp, sometimes you don't realize the drainage (or lack thereof) until after you have made camp.
Anyway, a bivy with a waterproof floor and sealed seams gives you some options and some protections in the above.
And, of course, there is always the possibility of your tarp blowing down and flapping in the rain…
billJun 14, 2013 at 10:09 am #1996618
@danepackerLocale: Mojave Desert
A bivy sack is really necessary when sleeping in snow caves, trenches or quinzhees.
It keeps your bag dry. I'd recommend an eVent top for winter and most other bivy bag uses.Jun 14, 2013 at 10:13 am #1996621
In addition to what Tipi said, there are areas where I'm required to stay at a designated camp site (N. Cascades, Wonderland, etc) and have limited site selection options.
Williswall media (member here as well) has a great video showing a campsite on the Wonderland which had an inch of standing water. Back when I was still backpacking with a traditional tent, I once woke to find myself in a lake. Poor site selection was certainly to blame but I was very grateful that my tent had a waterproof bathtub floor.
This issue is what prompted me to purchase a Zpacks bathtub floor instead of just a polycryo groundsheet for my upcoming Wonderland Trail hike.
The only bivy that I've had any meaningful experience with is the USGI goretex bivy. I've slept through rainstorms without getting wet. I'm sure that some materials breathe better than others but I'm of the belief that venting is just as important as the material. I will still use it for alpine camping but will eventually upgrade to a MLD Event Soul bivy to save myself 1.6 lbs of unnecessary weight.
Edit what Bill and Eric said! Need to type faster.Jun 14, 2013 at 10:34 am #1996629
"Williswall media (member here as well) has a great video showing a campsite on the Wonderland which had an inch of standing water. Back when I was still backpacking with a traditional tent, I once woke to find myself in a lake. Poor site selection was certainly to blame but I was very grateful that my tent had a waterproof bathtub floor."
I've been in a tent with a bath tub floor and poor site selection and have the water come in anyway. Plus I dont think that most Ul bivys are made to protect the user from getting wet while sleeping in an inch of water?
Some times when bad weather hits and your hiking your in for a long night(or three) no way around it. I would not carry a bivy with a fully enclosed shelter just to plan for this. Unless thats your thing, goin backpacking when the weather is just complete garbage.Jun 14, 2013 at 10:40 am #1996631
On bivies protecting you from ground water. Go use your bivy for a few dozen nights then hold it up to light. After my PCT hike I had dozens of small holes, easy to seal but these would defeat the very reason of using a bivy to combat ground water.Jun 14, 2013 at 10:41 am #1996632
Also if that is all your worried about why not just get or make an individual bathtub floor… it would be much lighter than a full bivy.
Or just carry a piece of poly cro as a ground mat, punch some holes in it with a hole puncher and if the weather gets that bad, use guy line and bring it up around your sleeping bag to keep the river that you set up your tent in out.
There are plenty of solutions to that problem that dont involve lugging around an event bivy with your Ul tent.Jun 14, 2013 at 1:36 pm #1996691
"Also if that is all your worried about why not just get or make an individual bathtub floor… it would be much lighter than a full bivy."
"re are plenty of solutions to that problem that dont involve lugging around an event bivy with your Ul tent."
I can't tell if you are asking me or the OP. If this is directed at me, I use a bivy as a standalone shelter in the conditions mentioned earlier. If I'm using a tarp, I just use a ground sheet until I receive my bath tub floor later today or early next week.
Fortunately I've only found myself in a lake once (described above) and I wasn't in a bivy then. I've slept through torrential rain storms in my USGI bivy without getting wet with the exception of minor condensation). Didn't use a ground cloth in the military and the USGI issued Thermarest didn't fit inside it all that well so the system from ground up was
2. Bivy (2.5 lbs)
3. Sometimes a poncho hooch mission dependent. (1.5 lbs plus bungee cords weight?)
While bomber, this system is way too heavy for BPL purposes.Jun 14, 2013 at 1:54 pm #1996692
"I can't tell if you are asking me or the OP"
Sorry its not really directed specifically at anyone. Its more for anyone that feels a full bivy is necessary in a fully enclosed shelter.Jun 14, 2013 at 2:06 pm #1996695
"not really directed specifically at anyone"
Gotcha! The one issue I'm tring to dial in for my Hexamid Twin Tarp (sans net) is mosquito control. Not sure if I'm going to try a Borah bug bivy or not. Will probably order a S2S Nano Mosquito Net Duo (~4oz) and see if I can make it work before I commit to a bivy.
I figure between the Hexamid Twin, Twin floor, and S2S Mosquito Net, I'll have a great modular system where I can cowboy camp in comfort but still have a tarp to dive under when the weather turns crappy. Just a theory at the moment though.
EDIT fwiw I exchanged emails with Borah and aked them if the bug bivy had a bathtub floor. He indicated that it technically does not but that when you sleep in it, the silnylon floor is pulled up in a way where it acts like one.Jun 14, 2013 at 2:22 pm #1996699
"Will probably order a S2S Nano Mosquito Net Duo (~4oz) and see if I can make it work before I commit to a bivy."
Richard Rankin is using one with his new HMG mid and he seems to like it quite a bit. If you PM'd him I'm sure he'd be happy to give you more real world info.Jun 14, 2013 at 2:25 pm #1996700
so off topic– but now you guys got me buying one of those s2s bug nets for my tarp!2.9 ounces is pretty light!Jun 14, 2013 at 2:47 pm #1996710
@dwambaughLocale: Pacific Northwest
IMHO, when you are using a minimalist tarp with poncho-like dimensions, stormy weather expected and bug protection with a tarp, and day hiking CYA. Winter snow shelter camping is a common use too.
Sometimes you don't get to pick a site. Some areas have restricted sites, or the site available has compressed soil that allows water to run through it or collect in puddles, right where you are pitched. Sometimes you run out of time and have to make do.
I agree that a bivy shouldn't be needed with a full shelter. I do like to use a footprint under to help with water issues and protect the tent floor. Tyvek or polycryo film are fine.Jun 16, 2013 at 4:53 pm #1997258
When you guys say "full shelter," are you referring to an enclosed tent with bathtub floor or a floorless shelter such as a MLD Solomid?
I would never attempt to use a bivy inside a floored shelter. However, I'm more interested to know whether those who use a Solomid type shelter feel the need for a bivy in addition to a groundsheet to protect their down bag.Jun 16, 2013 at 5:05 pm #1997261
8' x 5' tarp or similar size then a bivy.
8' x 10' tarp or similar no bivy.
Hexamid solo or Trailstar no bivy.Jun 16, 2013 at 5:10 pm #1997264
@dwambaughLocale: Pacific Northwest
+1 on what Nick said. Maybe in an 8×10 with two and nasty weather. If the tarp/tent edge can be piched close to the ground and it is wind stable, you're in pretty good shape without a bivy. No way in a full tent unless I wanted the warmth.
I use a Gatewood Cape, which can be pitched high or low and the low pitch is fine for full protection. I use a fairly large ground sheet and roll the edges under in the high side to duct water under if it looks like the site is going to be troublesome with water drainage.Jun 16, 2013 at 5:30 pm #1997268
Would you use a bivy with the Hexamid solo tarp? Wasn't sure if you were referring to the tarp or net version of the shelter. The nice thing about the Hexamid, I suppose, is the cuben fiber bathtub floor, which alleviates problems with groundwater.Jun 16, 2013 at 5:44 pm #1997272
My Hexamid doesn't have the net. I use the cuben poncho/ground sheet rarely as a groundsheet, don't want to develop pin holes if possible. Normally a waterproof foam pad serves as my sleeping pad and groundsheet. If I expect problems with drainage I will use the poncho/groundsheet. With temps down to around freezing I am usually using a cuben quilt.
Edit: I have never used the Hexamid with a bivy. Also I don't set it up unless rain is in the forecast.Jun 16, 2013 at 5:50 pm #1997278
My shelters are the MLD duo grace tarp, the cricket tarp and soon I will have a patrol shelter. I always use a superlight bivy. It helps keep me warmer and helps protect from drafts. It keeps my bag very clean so I don't have to wash it much. It helps with bugs, mosquitoes, flies etc. and I don't have to bring a ground sheet. If I were in a fully enclosed Mid I would probably use it anyway just because of the familiarity and comfort of the bivy unless I was camping with a woman. But having said all of that my main reason I love the bivy is that I am a huge fan of cowboy camping and it is really worth it to me to have the option to not put up my shelter every night and have great star gazing and nature scenery while I am falling asleep. This way my quilt is protected from dew in the morning and from nighttime winds.Jun 16, 2013 at 6:09 pm #1997287
This is the beauty (or downfall) of gear. What works for one person may not be the solution for another. The solution is to get out a lot and figure out what works for each of us.
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.