May 9, 2007 at 9:50 am #1223168
I am interested to hear any input people might have in regards to their methods for mapping a new trip?
Do most of you like to use a USGS map, Mapping software like Nat'l Geo Topo, create your own, guidebook, GPS, etc?
Anyone have recommendations on especially good reads for orienteering?
What is you typical route finding method?
NathanielMay 9, 2007 at 9:34 pm #1388808
>Do most of you like to use a USGS map, Mapping software like Nat'l Geo Topo, create your own, guidebook, GPS, etc?
I gave up acquiring USGS topos when I bought NG Topo!, unless I'm traveling out of state–then I just patch up on-line topos. The Libre Map Project has free USGS 24K DRG topos (and more) for the entire US. I much prefer to print a custom map (with marked trails and/or annotations). I like having a guidebook if I don't know anything about the area–I learned long ago that the trails on the USGS topos may not be there. (NG National Parks Topo is pretty trustworthy on its own.) But I also like having guidebooks for local areas to find trails that I otherwise wouldn't know about. I'm working on a project to map and annotate all of the trails in Hiking Wyoming's Medicine Bow National Forest using a GPS, except now I have to start over because they published a second edition ;)
>What is you typical route finding method?
I mostly use a paper map and compass, but if weight isn't an issue (heresy!) or I'm off-trail and the cover is heavy enough to interfere with taking bearings then I like to have a GPS for backup. My GPS saved my butt in a blizzard when my maps blew away. Garmin's MapSource GPS topos aren't very high resolution, but they were sufficient for me to navigate through a pass I couldn't see.May 10, 2007 at 5:05 am #1388824
Thanks Doug. Do you have a state specific Nat'l Geo or is there a general one, I have looked around a bunch but haven't found an all encompassing one. Does ~$100 sound right?May 10, 2007 at 5:28 am #1388830
I thought about getting TOPO! but I am cheap and use freeware. USPhotoMaps (http://jdmcox.com) is used for setting waypoints, making routes, etc. The nice thing about USAPhotoMaps (aside from being free) is that you can also display USGS aerial photos.
To upload/download waypoints for my Geko 301 I use another freeware software called g7towin.exe.
Below is an example aerial that can be displayed/printed with USAPhotoMaps.
May 10, 2007 at 7:23 am #1388845
Thanks, I have never seen this before, excellent recommendation. It seems like a pretty complete solution.May 10, 2007 at 7:56 am #1388847
At first I found it a little cumbersome but now I really like it :)
If you end up using it PM me and I'll send you a Word document with my notes on how to use G7ToWin.exe with the Geko 301.May 10, 2007 at 8:30 am #1388850
Downloaded it, a little cumbersome, take some time to get used to it. Still haven't figured out how to grab a specific location yet. I don't own a Geko, been thinking about a GPS but don't want to spend the money yet. Thanks for the offer though!May 10, 2007 at 8:36 am #1388853
Under the "Goto" menu item you can search by populated place (state, city), USGS landmark (lake, mountain, etc), or lat/long.
Once you do that use either the keystroke "T" for topo map or "P" for photo and then "F" for fill.
Try getting a aerial topo for Billings, MT.
1. Goto/Populated Place
2. Scroll to find MT and double click
3. Double click "Billings"
4. Press "P" key for photo
5. Press "F" key to fill
Then to see a topo for the same area
1. Press "T" for topo
2. Press "F" for fillMay 10, 2007 at 8:55 am #1388857
Aha! Fantastic, I appreciate the tip. Do you know of a way to see how old the information is on the map, or when it was last updated?May 10, 2007 at 9:45 am #1388860
I use both Topo!, USAPM and Libre. The advantage to Topo! is that it uses a newer update of the topos with more info and better seaming of the map edges. The dates on the maps in USAPM and Libre are 1988 while Topo! are 1995. When comparing two similar quads you can clearly see the additional info and detail of the newer maps. Terraserver also uses the older 1988 maps.May 10, 2007 at 11:22 am #1388869
Doesn't TOPO! use the USGS maps too, therefore being the same date/data as USAPM without all the bells and whistles?May 10, 2007 at 11:43 am #1388872
@jgranite25Locale: Lake Tahoe
USGS maps may be way out of date, but I still heavily rely on the 7.5' quads. I also use Tom Harrison maps — shaded relief and updated trails with mileage — for research, but I rarely take them in the field because of the scale. I've found that I need the detail of the 7.5' in the field, esp. when hiking cross-country. I have a cheap GPS — the Gecko, I think — that I use for cross-country trips. It sucks up battery life, though, so I only turn it on for brief periods to check my altitude.
Before my computer died I used TOPO, an older version. But I believe it was based on USGS quads, so I don't think it provided more current info. I did like the ability to check elevation gain/loss via the path profile. I don't save waypoints from the field — on the rare occasion that I go back to a previous spot, I mark it on the map, since that's what I would be taking back out into the field.
As for books, one that's been around a while is "Be Expert with Map and Compass" by Bjorn Kjellstrom. He goes into orienteering a bit. There are local and national orienteering societies that offer courses and events.May 10, 2007 at 12:17 pm #1388881
Thanks for the book recommendation Janet. Do you have any experience with the USAPM program?May 10, 2007 at 12:22 pm #1388882
USAPM has a quick way to find the date of the photo/topo you are viewing. Use the Help/Get Date of Photo/Topo. A new Terraserver window will open that lists the date.May 10, 2007 at 1:04 pm #1388883
@jgranite25Locale: Lake Tahoe
No — actually I've rarely used aerials for planning my trips. I've found they don't offer enough resolution for where I go, but I'll admit I haven't looked in a while so perhaps it's worth checking out again. I use TerraServer frequently at work, but I'm looking at urban areas so the resolution's good.May 10, 2007 at 4:11 pm #1388901
You should run a tutorial on this program, very helpful tip. I have been struggling with the idea of buying a state TOPO! but those things are too expensive and I hike in many different states. . . I'd end up spending a small fortune.May 10, 2007 at 5:09 pm #1388904
Thanks Nathaniel. Since you hike many states TOPO! could make you poor quickly. I think that's why they added an exclamation point to the name.
Anyway, USAPM does what I need. Gives me an idea of the area (water, peaks, terrain), lets me set reference points for my GPS, and print maps. Toggling between the topo and aerial photos very helpful for me.May 10, 2007 at 10:14 pm #1388940
>Do you have a state specific Nat'l Geo or is there a general one, I have looked around a bunch but haven't found an all encompassing one. Does ~$100 sound right?
I use the state version of Topo!; ~$100 is the normal price for one state, although I've bought some on eBay for about $70. I added NG Back Roads Explorer, which has the level 4 maps (1:100K for continental US, 1:250K for AK) with road names. That way I can see everything at the high level, but I only get down to the quads in the states I own; good for driving. NG Topo National Parks (recently updated) stands on its own; it is the electronic equivalent of the TrailSmart paper maps, and the scale varies by park. It has top-notch annotation for the national parks, way beyond what you get on a USGS quad.
I agree Topo! is expensive, but when I started 'investing' in it there really weren't any good low-cost alternatives to cut&paste to construct seamless maps. It works great with my GPS, and I like being able to see the area on various scales without hassle. My map of the Na Ala Hele Honolulu Mauka trail system was created from GPS tracks, and when viewed in Topo! the trail segment distances pop up and there are live links to the Na Ala Hele trail descriptions on their web site. Topo! very easily allows me to sketch routes and get distances and elevation profiles, and load the route into my GPS (although I usually just follow it on a printed paper map).May 10, 2007 at 10:32 pm #1388941
@rcaffinLocale: Wollemi & Kosciusko NPs, Europe
> methods for mapping a new trip?
1:25 k topo map, compas, and a spare nights food in case.
Don't have a GPS; don't even WANT a GPS. Deep in the rainforest in the canyon country we probably wouldn't get a fix anyhow.May 10, 2007 at 11:30 pm #1388946
@tbeasleyLocale: Pigeon House Mt from the Castle
" Deep in the rainforest in the canyon country we probably wouldn't get a fix anyhow."
Your would be surprised how sensitive the Sirf 3 chip GPS is I have been in the dark depths of the Monolith Valley (Budawangs National Park New South Wales Australia) and it still gave readings. The same under thick foliage.
TonyMay 11, 2007 at 6:39 am #1388961
I seems that TOPO! is the most feature rich program, but the cost is huge (maybe I am jut poor) if you are hiking in many different areas. The road map one sounds interesting though.
I don't think I want a GPS either, I enjoy being away from technology when I am out in the backcountry. However, the USGS seems to only have maps from the 80's in the places I want to hike off trail. I had a bad experience when I was 15 hiking around the Three Sisters in Oregon with a map that was 20 years old, did my first 27 mile day. . .
Map and compass is my preference, but I haven't tried the software yet.
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.