Help with shoe selection

I just got a pair of Vasque Pendulum shoes, and my first impressions are great!

They're light (advertised at 11 oz., I think); have a 6 mm. drop (19mm. in the heel, 13 in the forefoot); and water (even really, really cold White Mountains in March water!) flows through quickly.

The drop hasn't been an issue for me, and doesn't seem to have an adverse effect either walking or running (I usually run either barefoot or in vff but like the idea of a little more protection in the woods).

The tread seems good, so far. I've worn them on a couple day hikes and been running in the woods on mixed surfaces– slushy snow; frozen granular; ice; and of course the 3 R's. So far so good, except that htey do slip around pretty good on an icy slope.

Don't know yet how well they'll wear, and i still kind of cling to the old gore-tex paradigm (love my Vasque Scree 2's!); but I think they'll be my go-to shoes for as long as they last and I'm optimistic.

I have Merrill Moab Ventilator shoes B/C I hike in the desert southwest a lot and need the sole protection from jagged rocks.

Yeah, they may be a tad heavier but it's all in the sole protection.

If NBs fit you the other models would be worth examining. I wasn't fond of the MT100s rubber or tread.

The La Sportiva X Country is minimal trail shoe with a mid-narrow fit and rubber that is sticky, but not quite approach shoe sticky. The tread pattern is also fantastic in mud and loose gravel. You can still find them on sale. I haven't had a chance to put hands on the replacement (Anakonda), which is hopefully not too different.

My Inov-8's just last and last. very durable and well-made. However, I don't have hikers- just everyday shoes. Still, a big +1 to the company.

I just picked up a pair of Salomon Speedcross 3's and they have rubber studs on the bottom for traction. Preliminary testing says traction is superb. However, I don't know how well they drain.

I like the traction of the La Sportiva C-Lite 2.0, very similar tread to the La Sportiva X. Although, a drawback to both is they have a built in shoelace gator that makes it difficult to affix traditional gators (without modification). They also seem to hold really wet mud more than some other treads, which I would assume would get slippery, but strangely haven't experienced that even with mud caked on them. Overall, I really like the shoe, but the tread does wear down quick… but something I'm willing to live with to gain the cleat like grip they offer.

If they suit your foot then Inov 295's would be worth a look IMHO. They are pretty wide fitting and grip well. A new version is about to be released, so you should be able to get a deal on the older ones.