Bob Marshall Wilderness Open – Eccentric But Not Insane
A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!
Home › Forums › Campfire › Member Trip Reports › Bob Marshall Wilderness Open – Eccentric But Not Insane
- This topic is empty.
Jun 1, 2012 at 7:03 pm #1290593
The Bob Marshall Wilderness Open is an event contrived and hosted by BPL’s own Dave Chenault. This hasty traverse of Rocky Mountains / Bob Marshall Wilderness Complex is intended in the spirit of the Alaskan Wilderness Classic – push yourself and your skillset to cross big wilderness as effectively as you can.
For me this held an allure as I really had no idea what my own abilities and limitations were. Was I capable of a 40 mile day? Two in a row? I suspected I might be, but I’d never hiked more than 25 miles in a day before. I entered this event hoping to learn more about wilderness travel and my own abilities while enjoying the grandeur of the Rockies.
The BMWO comes at a time of year (late May) when the conditions are highly variable and challenging. There’s definitely going to be travel on snow and weather is likely to be both cold and wet. Initially this was a concern for me – I wanted to see how far and fast I could hike, but I wanted to do it in nice weather on dry trails. I watched the NOHRSC snow depth projections hoping the snow would melt and I could put together a summer SUL gearlist.
As the event neared, I knew there was going to be snow travel and any illusions of balmy weather also faded. At the same time, I started to understand and embrace why the BMWO is held when and where it is. May is one of the most challenging times of the year in the Bob and thus this event would be a far better teacher than one held in August. This was a chance to test and hone a much bigger set of skills: snow travel, route finding, avy danger, high river crossings and extended cold and wet weather management. I was very nervous but finally eager for the challenge.
Food: Stoveless – energy bars, chocolate bars, dried meats, granola, pop tarts
Sleep/Shelter: Tarp, 14oz 35F down quilt, inflatable pad
Travel: Yupi Ski Shoes for snow, no packraft
My route for this event was focused on minimizing the number of miles. I hoped to incorporate a few off-trail sections and a swim across the Flathead river to reduce the total milage to around 80. Most others had planned routes in the 90-118 mile range to cover this 59 mile (as the crow files) traverse.
Red is planned route, Blue is where actual route differed from the plan
Participants John, Cyrus, Dave and Greg (mostly with backs to the camera) chat with Forest Service guys and significant others pre-trip.
Day One: Start to Mid-Rock Creek – 9am to 12:30am – Est. 39 miles
The morning of the event (and the night before) the weather was intimidating: Light snow/rain and temperatures around freezing.
Dusting of snow on the South Fork Teton Bridge
In total, there would be 7 participants this year after the challenging weather forecast deterred a few more. John, Cyrus, Dave and myself were joined by Greg (a previous Alaskan Mountain Wilderness Classic competitor) and two of Dave’s acquaintances from Kalispell, MT. Greg had planned a creative route that skirted the first (Sawtooth) range to the south to avoid the high elevation snow, while the rest of us were heading straight into the Rockies on the S. Fork Teton road towards to the Headquarters Pass trailhead. From there Dave would packraft south to a more appealing pass, while the rest of us planned to press forward over the Chinese Wall at Larch Hill Pass.
After a short delay at 9am to chat with a nice local enforcement ranger who had swung by to collect names, we were off around 9:15am. Dave and I settled into a nice pace together and covered the 8 miles to the Headquarters Pass Trailhead in a few hours.
Heading towards the Sawtooth Range
East Side of Headquarters Pass
As soon as we reached the trail, a few inches of fresh snow greeted us. Climbing higher meant the new snow got deeper and the hard crust from the winters snowpack became apparent underneath. As we approached the alpine, the fresh snow had been shaped by the wind into slabs of varying depths. In some areas it was foot deep on top of the crust, while in other areas there was challenging sidehilling on bare crust – I removed my Yupi’s for this. There was some avalanche concern in this area as the firm winter snowpack provided a perfect sliding surface for the new snow.
Dave Chenault side hilling on crust near Headquarters Pass
Dave C. heads for the pass
We reached the pass in the early afternoon and struggled with high winds and deep drifts for a few minutes before descending to more friendly conditions around treeline. Dave and I then descended the 8 miles to Sun River where we parted at 4:30pm.
Over the Pass and back in the trees
The Sun River valley was an amazing change from Headquarters Pass. The warm temperatures, clusters of elk and green fields felt strangely out of place after the harsh winter conditions a few hours earlier. At this point I headed on towards the Rock Creek trail and Larch Hill Pass while Dave packrafted the Sun River.
I headed past the impressive Ranger complex in the Sun River basin and walked towards the Rock Creek trail and Larch Hill Pass. I knew I had 5 hours until dusk and about 15 miles to the pass plus several more to get back down to the White River.
Unfortunately in my haste I made a large and frustrating error. At the trail junction near Rock Creek I didn’t break stride to fully read the trail sign, but rather I mis-read the sign and mistakenly headed up the wrong trail to Red Shale Creek – the drainage north of Rock Creek. I think I mis-read the first trail listed on the sign and thought "That’s the one” so I took off without reading the rest or confirming on the map.
Marching up the wrong (Red Shale) creek
The Red Shale Creek trail was a good one with no ambiguity or junctions, so I never had reason to stop and consult the map for hours. At one point I pulled out my compass and observed the drainage heading in a NW direction instead of W, but I dismissed this by telling myself the Rock Creek drainage likely has a curve or wiggle in it. I should have pulled out my map to actually check. Such is the danger of being so sure you’re on the right trail that you never stop to check.
Three hours later I had gained 2000’ and covered ~6 miles. At this point the snow cover was obscuring the trail and I finally pulled out my map to locate myself and take a direction bearing. I could see the Chinese Wall but there was no indication of a pass. Everything seemed strange and I wondered why I hadn’t seen the Rock Creek cabin, so I pulled out my GPS and obtained my UTM co-ordinates – I wasn’t even on the map.
In disbelief at my error, I rushed back down the trail hoping to still make some distance up Rock Creek today. I half-jogged the 2000’ descent in 1hr 40 and arrived back at the junction at 10:30pm – 5 hours after I was already there. I then headed up Rock Creek for 2 hours until 12:30 and camping just below the snowline.
Light snow falls on the trail to Larch Hill Pass
Day Two: Mid-Rock Creek to White River Junction – 4:30am to 8:30pm – Est. 24 miles
The next morning I woke up and discovered I had a made another large mistake. In my haste and frustration at hiking the wrong trail, I had descended the trail too aggressively and aggravated the IT band in my right leg (which sometimes bothers me when I jog). My right knee was so sore that I couldn’t bend it. I took a few Advil but it was obvious my stride wasn’t going to be good today. I ended up having to swing my stiff right leg out and around instead of bending my knee to lift it. A stiff leg wouldn’t have been so bad on flat trail, but today’s hike was almost entirely on snow so I was somewhat dragging it.
I continued up Rock Creek toward Larch Hill Pass – albeit at a pace around 1.5mph., half of yesterdays. Casey and Jeff had passed me during my scenic detour, so I had their tracks up the remaining ~9 miles of Larch Hill.
Snowy ascent up Larch Hill while following Jeff and Casey's tracks
In the upper forks of Rock Creek I had hoped to take a more direct off-trail route to the pass, but the snowpack was still patchy at this elevation so off-trail travel with the ski-shoes wasn’t feasible. I continued to follow Casey and Jeff’s tracks for several hours up and over the pass. At Larch Hill Pass it was snowing hard and the fresh snow was deep. Still, I was only a few hours behind Casey and Jeff so their tracks were obvious.
Getting pretty snowy around 7600'
Plugging along near Larch Hill
The actual Larch Hill Pass isn’t nearly as obvious as I was expecting it to be. The trail undulates and wiggles for several miles before wandering over the pass, so it’s easy to miss the actual pass. When Casey and Jeff had gone over the pass they had mistakenly entered the wrong drainage to the N of the pass instead of to the W, which I then followed their tracks into. A few hundred feet below the pass I was out of the bad weather so I stopped to check my navigation and discovered the problem. The map showed this drainage would meet up, but it would cost me a few miles. I opted to carry on instead of re-ascending.
I followed that drainage down through the snow for an hour or two and finally met up with the trail along the White River. It was mid-day and my leg continued to hurt badly which held my pace to 1.5mph. I hobbled along past the awesome Needle Falls on the White River, seeing quite a few elk and deer in the area. I arrived at the Junction with the S. Fork at 8:30pm and after crossing this fork decided that 8 hours of sleep might be what my knee needed to perform better.
Looking down the North Fork of the White River near Needle Falls
My clothing was almost entirely soaked from the persistent precipitation today, but my sleep socks and down vest were dry so I changed into those and fell asleep in my down quilt in minutes. It was snowing lightly and I thought I might be too cold to sleep in my 35F quilt, but the next thing I knew my 4:45am alarm was going off. 8 hours of uninterrupted sleep likely played a big part in the success of the day to come.
Camped out at the S. Fork of the White River
Day Three: S. Fork White River to Finish – 5:00am – 3:30am – 43.9 miles
The third day started off like the second – a stiff knee and hobbling along at 1.5mph. The pace was frustrating but the scenery was great. The wet forests, grassy meadows and powerful White River were all awesome. I knew I was going to be hobbling beside excellent packrafting water for next dozen miles and I badly wished I’d brought my packraft. Instead of a painful 8 hour hobble, it could have been a fun 2 hour float.
Lush and wet along the White River
I covered the 6 miles of trail to near the S. Fork of the Flathead in 4 hrs (5-9am) and then a bit more off trail to reach its banks (9:30am). The Flathead is an amazing waterway. Some of the meadow areas along its banks are hard to believe with their grassy floors and loosely spaced trees. Naturally perfect spots for camping. The deer and elk seemed to like them too.
Meadows near the S. Fork Flathead
I arrived at the South Fork of the Flathead planning to swim it. The closest bridge was 12 miles round trip out of the way, which was not appealing with my knee issue. Dave had told me the river was about 6x as wide as the S. Fork of the Teton which looked right to me. Dave had said swimming this would be ‘eccentric but not insane’ which I now agreed with. I was quite nervous jumping in, but my brain knew I could do it.
About where I swam the S. Fork Flathead
I choose a spot that was pretty deep right from the start, but led to an area on the far side that was shallow. I wanted to have a swim where once I was most of the way across I would be able to stand up, so didn’t have the challenge of trying to exit from deep water. I considered using my pack as a kickboard with the dry bags inflated inside, but in the end I wanted the full ability to front crawl so I wore the pack normally after securing most of my gear in dry bags. I tried to wade out a little ways into the waist deep water, but the river was too powerful for that. It quickly pulled me in and I was swimming. I used a front crawl stroke at a 45 degree upstream ferry position. Swimming felt ineffective compared to the power of the river pushing me downstream, but after a few seconds I could tell I was making progress.
The actual swim was pretty short – maybe 10-20 seconds. I moved about 2x as far downstream as I did across. Supposedly a nearby water temperature gauge indicated the Flathead was 38.5F. That sounds cold and I’m sure it was, but I was a lot more concerned about the power of the river so this wasn’t at the forefront of my mind.
I had been wearing rain gear plus leg tights for the swim, so I wrung out the tights and then added my baselayer top, synthetic jacket and other warm items. Just as my teeth started to chatter I warmed up and was quite happy about the swim (10am). Post-dip I felt quite refreshed and perhaps a bit less grubby from the trail miles.
Stoked to be back in warm clothes.
Wet but beautiful trail along W. bank of the Flathead
I proceeded North along the Flathead, having scrapped my initial plan to hike Holbrook Creek Valley to Feline Creek. I wasn't confident the snow pack would be consistent enough to allow efficient off trail travel with the ski-shoes in the Feline Creek basin.
I was soon caught by Jeff who informed me him and Casey had opted for the bridge (Big Prairie) and my swim had slotted me between them. They were due at work the next morning and unsure about the snowpack in the final Swan Range, so they were opting to hike North along the Flathead for 20 miles to a trailhead. The thought of an early exit was alluring, but 20 miles wasn’t that much less than the ~32 miles I had over the Swan range, so around 2pm I parted ways with Jeff at Big Salmon creek and headed west for Pendant Pass.
Hiking with Jeff along the Flathead
Final Look at the S. Fork Flathead
The trail along Big Salmon Lake was quite challenging with literally hundreds of trees down on the trail. It appeared that many trees killed by a forest fire had then been pushed down onto the trail by the winter snowpack. It was like this for miles. Thankfully at the same time the IT band inflammation in my knee miraculously relented and I was able to use the knee with only moderate discomfort.
Timber down along Big Salmon Lake
The final pass (Pendant Pass) was 20.7 miles away (from the Flathead) and it was 2pm. I realized that if I could maintain nearly 3 mph through these logs and the upcoming snowy sections then I would be able to clear the pass by sunset (9:45pm) and finish sometime in the night. I pushed hard through the blowdown and kept at it when the patchy snow began around 5000’. This section of trail was awesome….great creeks, lots of wildlife and at a really interesting time of year for animal tracks and vegetation.
Amazing trail along Big Salmon Creek
Loving the hike
There was some pretty wet sections of trail
The patchy snow went on for miles from 5000' – 6200'
Around 6000’ I put on the Yupi ski-shoes and at 10:00pm in the final minutes of daylight I made it to the pass, having averaged 2.6 mph for the past 8 hrs. I did the last few miles without my bear spray, as I lost it while crawling over a log.
Big Salmon Falls
Following Bear Tracks to the Pass – They sure walk in a straight line
Looking NW from near Pendant Pass at Dusk
The descent down to Upper Holland Lake was a bit trickier with soft, south facing snowpack often allowing me to sink thigh deep. I waded down to the lake and then traversed around it looking for the trail. Thankfully some faint animal tracks gave away its location and I followed those as best I could. I began the 5.8 mile descent to Lower Holland Lake.
Arriving at the lower lake was great with its warm temperatures and signs of civilization. There was still 6 miles to go though to the Hungry Bear. These miles would end up being some of the hardest of the trip mentally, as I felt like I was finished and I was very tired and sore, yet there was still a good while to go and slowing down could add an hour or two. If someone offered me a ride during these moments I might have accepted, but there simply wasn’t cars out at 3 am. The last 3 miles along Hwy 83 seemed to last forever, and even when I could see the faint orange light of the Hungry Bear sign it still took 15 minutes to get there. Finally at 3:35am – 66.5 hrs after starting – I had completed my traverse of the Bob. My trip here ended up being ~106 miles instead of the ~80 I had planned.
Overall, the BMWO was an amazing experience and I'm itching to go back next spring and give it an even better shot. I left a lot of room to improve this year. I reckon the sore IT band cost me 8 hours due to slow hiking and another 4 hours due to getting extra sleep hoping to heal it. Being more reasonable on the descents may eliminate this. Navigation errors also cost me 5 hours (Red Shale Creek) and 1-2 hours (Larch Hill Pass). Sub 50 hours seems easily possible on this route and sub-40 might be achievable – perhaps with a raft. The course may be different next time around though.
I hope to see many of you guys out there next Memorial weekend ^_^.
For a gearlist used in this event see my profile:
The aftermath of my BMWO diet
Jun 1, 2012 at 7:21 pm #1883147Greg MihalikSpectator
Thank you Dan!
An excellent TR.
Congrats on the planning, prepping, and execution.
Well Done.Jun 1, 2012 at 7:27 pm #1883148Jerry AdamsBPL Member
@retiredjerryLocale: Oregon and Washington
Great report, well written, you guys are amazing to do that
Why are you smiling in every picture : )Jun 1, 2012 at 7:38 pm #1883150Justin BakerBPL Member
@justin_bakerLocale: Santa Rosa, CA
Wow, that looks like some rough conditions! Probably some of the most challenging you could ever encounter. Did you use any cramps getting over those passes?
If you don't mind me asking, what is the brand/name of those tights you were wearing in the pic after you got out of the river? They look like something specific I saw a while back.Jun 1, 2012 at 7:46 pm #1883152
The tights are GoLite Cross Timber Zonal Tights. They're super cheap ($29?) on their website right now. This was my first time ever wearing tights and it worked well in combination with rain pants for windy conditions. They acted as sort of a thin wetsuit during the swim and generally I was really happy with them. Definately part of my arsenal now for shoulder season conditions.
I didn't use any crampons. There was a few spots where it would have been nice, but if repeating I would stick with my decision to not use crampons or an ice axe – personal preference/risk tolerance varies though. Some guys did this trip without snow shoes (Casey and Jeff) while most other had snowshoes – usually with crampons. The ski-shoes were nice in a few spots, but they sucked at sidehilling (lack of ankle support) and they were too sketchy descending (many crashes – scared of tree wells). I lost my water bottle on the first pass crashing on the Yupi ski-shoes, so I just drank directly from streams the rest of the way.
I wouldn't carry the ski shoes again in these conditions, but if the snow pack was more prevailent so lower elevation/gentler slopes had consistant coverage then they could be good. Hard to pick the best choice – I'll mull it over when next years conditions are more more apparent. I would much rather brought my packraft instead this year.Jun 1, 2012 at 7:59 pm #1883156Justin BakerBPL Member
@justin_bakerLocale: Santa Rosa, CA
Ski shoes…. do you mean the big plastic boots? Did you need them for your snowshoes? Sorry, I am a noob in the snow.
That sucks that you lost your bottle, it has happened to me once before when walking through brush and branches during a very hot day. I have considered trying to find some way to secure it to the pack, maybe clip it with some cord so it can't get away.Jun 1, 2012 at 8:49 pm #1883167
The Yupi 'Ski Shoes' are sorta hard to explain. Do a Google Image search for a look.
Basically they are like fat snow blades with a permanently attached climbing skin to the base for grip uphill and glide downhill. The bindings ratchet to your feet like snowboard bindings but they are permanently in walk mode like telemark skis. They work well for following an established skin track (if you're touring with skiers but are a snowboarder) and they work well for gentle ascents in spring conditions. They work poorly when sidehilling due to the lack of ankle support and they are tough to handle downhill because of their short length and free heel.Jun 1, 2012 at 8:56 pm #1883168David ChenaultBPL Member
@davecLocale: Queen City, MT
Outstanding trip and report. Keeping the psyche up during adversity is the most important thing on trips like that, and you did an exceptional job.
I hope to hike and raft with you soon Dan.
John emailed me his write-up, and I posted it here: http://bedrockandparadox.com/2012/06/01/eccentric-but-not-insane-dan-and-john-weigh-in/Jun 1, 2012 at 9:21 pm #1883169Trevor ConreyBPL Member
Great read Dan! Congrats on finishing and sticking it out through all the adversity. What an adventure and a huge learning experience.
Thanks again for the great write-up.Jun 1, 2012 at 9:50 pm #1883173Richard NisleyBPL Member
@richard295Locale: San Francisco Bay Area
Congratulations on your achievement and thank for sharing with an excellent trip report.
Just curious, if you rafted where possible would have there been a requirement for an aggressive back ferry (smile)… just kidding.Jun 1, 2012 at 10:30 pm #1883177Sam HaraldsonBPL Member
@sharaldsLocale: Gallatin Range
Good on ya' for participating, Dan. I really wish my circumstances of the past months had been different and I could've participated. Wonderful living vicariously through the trip reports I'm reading.Jun 2, 2012 at 4:22 am #1883207Ike JutkowitzBPL Member
@ikeLocale: Central Michigan
Awesome report, Dan.
Great job on completing the trip in unique style.Jun 2, 2012 at 6:09 am #1883218Mike MBPL Member
congrats Dan! that's a great adventure in the truest sense
I had the wonderful opportunity to work in the BM for several years in my youth, it is a very wild place to be sure :)
MikeJun 2, 2012 at 6:23 am #1883219Brendan SwihartBPL Member
@brendansLocale: Fruita CO
Fantastic, Dan.Jun 2, 2012 at 10:07 am #1883285Keith FMember
@hamericaLocale: Northern Virginia
Swimming in 38 degree water is pretty insane. Dan you are hard core!Jun 2, 2012 at 12:14 pm #1883308Gary DunckelBPL Member
You are my new hero, Dan. That was an amazing accomplishment, considering the conditions, loss of water bottle, knee issues. Long ago, I spent a summer based at the confluence of the Sun, Gates Creek, and Headquarters Creek, doing USFS trail work. It sure looks different in those May Conditions. Thanks for the fine photos, and the great write-up. And Dave, I enjoyed your report as well. You guys are a breed apart from us mere mortals.
Edit…spellingJun 2, 2012 at 8:37 pm #1883418
Thanks for a kind words guys….it was a great adventure. Working in the Bob would be an awesome way to spend the season.Jun 2, 2012 at 9:04 pm #1883424Nico .BPL Member
@nickbLocale: Los Padres National Forest
That sounds like an awesome adventure. Lots of great learning experiences make for better future trips and fun, exciting stories afterwards.
Swimming the river at those temps is hard core. Good on ya'!Jun 3, 2012 at 11:58 am #1883568spelt with a tBPL Member
@speltLocale: Rangeley, ME
Fantastic report on an awesome trip. Makes me want to drop everything and train just so I can try it next year.Jun 4, 2012 at 11:18 am #1883892John St. LaurentSpectator
@johnstlLocale: Pacific NW
Yours was the trip that I had been hoping for Dan, but wasn't in the cards for me this year. Well, except for the swimming part, which was never part of my plan!
I'll be seeing you next year.Jun 5, 2012 at 10:01 pm #1884468Tad EnglundBPL Member
@bestbuilderLocale: Pacific Northwest
Excellent report Dan, and thanks for your honesty about the adjustments to your planned route. Your ability to access your location, adjust the route in spite of a mix-up, maintaining the end goal is to be commended.
Do you ever worry about your knee and having a full blow-out making for a early bail-out? Does it hamper your pace often?Jun 6, 2012 at 7:23 am #1884529Brent MahanMember
@thenerbLocale: Southern New Hampshire
Great TR. Exciting to read with good pictures. Sounds like an amazing trip and one you'll remember for a long time.
Thanks for sharing!
What an awesome experienceJun 6, 2012 at 12:29 pm #1884615
"Do you ever worry about your knee and having a full blow-out making for a early bail-out? Does it hamper your pace often?"
I've never had knee trouble before when hiking, but I do get some IT band inflammation on long runs (ie. 10 miles). I'm pretty confident that the IT band inflammation I got on this hike was almost entirely from the speedy 6 mile descent I made after taking the wrong turn. I'm not sure if it was my pace (really fast, long strides with lots of knee bending) or the pounding my knee(s) took as I dropped 2000' and 6 miles in 1:40, but either way it's something that I think I can avoid in the future by showing a bit more restraint on the descents and relying on the trekking poles more. Some stretching of the IT band beforehand would also help and I've learned a few of those.
So as I hoped, this event was a great opportunity to get to know my body better. I learned I can hike 40+ miles in a day, that I need to pay attention to my knees and that 18-20 hrs per day is quite repeatable for events like this, while the 23 hours I hiked on the last day was too much if I needed to hike again the day after. I had a lot of swelling and soreness the day after finishing, so I would have been heavily hampered by that if I still in the woods. Now I can recognize problems with my body a bit sooner and hike accordingly.
With all that said, having some sort of a Spot device would be nice in case a real injury or something else came up. When you're planning on a 3 day hike at this pace and you've instructed your wife to call SAR at 4.5 days, then you don't have a lot of extra time to nurse injuries. Had the knee not cleared up, I would have had to push hard to make it out in 4.Jun 7, 2012 at 6:36 pm #1885065
Greg posted his awesome adventure report here:
https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B4EhuD5RFBfYeFVldXlaTmpKaEU/edit?pli=1Jun 8, 2012 at 11:10 pm #1885445Warren GreerSpectator
Very well written and an engrossing read. All I can say is I would have had to hike on to the bridge, cause I am not getting in 38* water. As you know, I surf quite a bit. And when the temps drop below about 58* it is cold or at least I am. And that's with a 3/2 wetsuit and booties on and a lid if the outside temps are lower. Water in the mid 50's will give you an ice cream headache if your head goes under. Can only imagine how you felt (though you did such a great job describing it). You guys are real mountain men in those conditions. And some mileage coverers at that. Your pictures were also great as well. Makes me want to get up in the morning and get out.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!
Our Community Posts are Moderated
Backpacking Light community posts are moderated and here to foster helpful and positive discussions about lightweight backpacking. Please be mindful of our values and boundaries and review our Community Guidelines prior to posting.
Gear Research & Discovery Tools
- Browse our curated Gear Shop
- See the latest Gear Deals and Sales
- Our Recommendations
- Search for Gear on Sale with the Gear Finder
- Used Gear Swap
- Member Gear Reviews and BPL Gear Review Articles
- Browse by Gear Type or Brand.