My experience is with a Tarptent Squall 2. I use it for a roomy solo tent, and if my wife is present, its fine as a 2 man tent. I have rarely had condensation in it, and I've used it in snow, rain, wind, cold, and heat. The one time it was awful was in a dust storm. With all that mesh, lots of dust came into the tent.
I add shock absorbers to the tent lines, in the form of snubbers made for fishermen. These are sections of rubber tubing with metal loops on the ends. This helps the tent stay tight all night, and absorbs some shock from wind gusts.
I don't take the footprint, and have not had any problems.
I also like the idea of a much larger cheap tent for car camping, where weight and bulk is not a problem, and being able to stand up to dress is helpful.

