Advice for a light 2 person, 3 season tent.

The Big Agnes Fly Creek UL2 sounds like it would fit the bill pretty well. You can find them for 279 on sale right now, and at about 2 pounds, they're a great option.

Edit: Or there's one on Gear Swap for 190– http://www.backpackinglight.com/cgi-bin/backpackinglight/forums/thread_display.html?forum_thread_id=60428
That's a great deal.

Hi Ben,

Thanks for the quick reply. I have always had Big Agnes products on my wish list but I see notes I've made to myself that the rule for BA tents is they are supposedly very cramped and you have to get the next size up to be comfortable. For example, the Fly Creek UL3 is what you'd need for two people to sleep comfortably. This is echoed on the REI reviews for the product. What do you think?

I can't actually speak to the size of the Fly Creek, but I think it just depends on how the walls pitch in. 86*52 is a pretty standard 2P tent size, but the usable space could be less. The walls look pretty steep so it may be cramped. If you've got an REI or something near by, I'd set it up and see how you fit in it. Others here might be able to comment on it as well.
Another good option is a Mountain Hardware Skyledge 2.1. That thing is absolutely rock solid, but heavier. I use a Big Agnes Copper Spur UL2, but that's mostly because I'm 6'4". I need the size, so I take the weight penalty.

Hi David,
I was also in the same situation: Needed two person, 3 season tent, light, inexpensive, not too cramped. I've ended up buying Stoic Arx 2 XL from SteepAndCheap.com – the price was half of the retail and it is a great tent all around. I wouldn't pay full price for it, but if you can score a deal like i did – you will enjoy it a lot.

I've used it on a trip to Mammoth Lakes when temps dropped below zero and there was snow around us. We had no issues and it performed well. It is not as light as BA UL2, but the price, size and features made up for the difference in weight.

http://www.backcountry.com/stoic-arx-2-tent-3-season

http://www.hypersensory.com/content/review-2-lightweight-tents-msr-hubba-1-person-and-stoic-arx-2xl-2-person

If not Stoic – then go to REI and take a look at the tents they have in store – sometimes they have good lightweight options available.

I have two of the Fly Creek UL2 tents and am considering selling one of them. I quite like them. They are plenty long enough for me at 5'10". As a solo tent it is awesome. My daughter and I slept in it in pretty cold weather and did just fine. To change clothing, though, I had to have my daughter move all the way over to the side so I had enough headroom to maneuver in the center. As long as you're comfortable being a bit cozy with each other it is a good tent.

Interestingly, my three kids shared a Tarptent Rainshadow 2 and had room enough for all their gear inside. It only weighs 1 oz more than the UL2 w/o footprint. This tent has more headroom and more space.

David,
I think you're right about sizing up. My girlfriend and I used it and it was crammed, like so much so that it's not our present tent. It depends on the length of your trip (how much gear you have), but it's pretty much a tent you slide into when you're ready to sleep and are excited to escape in the morning.

I have a Big Agnes Fly Creek UL3, it will sleep 2 people. There is no way you could sleep 3 people without serious spooning. It weights 4 lbs, 0.8 oz with everything, including optional ground cloth. That's 2 lbs per person if you split the load.

I love the BPL community. Thank you so much for the great advice and feedback everyone. I think right now I am crossing the Big Agnes Fly Creek UL2 off the list. I am OK being a bit cramped but it really just sounds like they are pushing it too much.

Yuri – I have a Stoic sleeping pad and sleeping bag. Maybe I should make it a triple. I will check out your suggestions.

I am ok with a tight-ish fit for two but not that much. I am being greedy in wanting a lightweight tent that can fit two but will still be light enough that it makes sense carrying it even on solo trips.

Has anyone tried the L.L. Bean Microlight FS2?

By the way – i'm 6'3" and my dad is about 5'11", so two of us fit fine in the tent. We even put some gear inside (mostly clothes, flashlights, etc). Two vestibules stored our packs, boots – that extra space was absolutely essential. I would have to put my boots/pack inside the sleeping are or outside of the tent completely.

I also have Stoic Somnus sleeping bag and their air-pad. While stoic may not have the same following as some other brands – i find quality and utility to be on par with more famous and expensive manufacturers.

I know you said you didn't want any "funky setups", but you might want to consider the Six Moon Designs Lunar Duo. It's an extremely roomy two-person tent, and while it's designed to be set up with trekking poles, you can buy regular poles from Six Moon Designs to use with it instead. Right now the original model is on sale (look in the Bargain Bin), and the new Outfitter model (which is heavier by about a pound) can be had for a very reasonable $160 (not including poles).

If I go with the Lunar Duo and use the SMD poles, how much extra weight does it add? Is the new packed weight size still considered light? And the poles collapse or do I have to carry around 3 foot sections like a tripod or trekking pole?

Also, I see the Explorer listed as $310 and the bargain bin version at $260. Did you make a typo or is there something I am not seeing?

Thanks.

I don't know if it matters to you, but I don't think the Duo is freestanding.

Oh, it does matter to me :( Thanks Ben

The poles are segmented and held together by shock cord, like regular tent poles. There are two versions, the carbon fiber poles, which are lighter but much more expensive (3.6 ounces for a pair, total cost $60), and the aluminum versions, which are heavier but cheaper (6 ounces for a pair, total cost $28).

There are currently three models of the Lunar Duo available. The $310 version of the Lunar Duo is the new 2012 silnylon model, which features a few minor improvements over the older silnylon version which is now on sale in the Bargain Bin for $260. The inexpensive Outfitter model is a polyurethane coated fabric rather than silnylon, which is why it's both heavier and cheaper.

And, as Ben mentioned, the Lunar Duo isn't a freestanding tent. Most people don't find that to be a must-have feature, but of course that depends on what sort of surfaces you pitch your tent on. Bear in mind there are ways of making a non-freestanding tent pitchable on most hard surfaces; it just takes some know-how (and a bit of work). And in general, you still want to stake freestanding tents for safety's sake. But if you really need a freestanding tent, then the Lunar Duo won't work for you.

I just realized, embarassingly, I don't really know what free-standing means. Well, I do know what it means but what are the practical pros/cons for it? Does a non-freestanding tent require BOTH soft ground to stake and a tree for support?

As mentioned above, the Lunar Duo is NOT freestanding – that is, it requires stakes or some sort of anchor to the surface to be set up properly.

It's a great tent and very roomy even for two – the double doors and vestibules are really nice for that. You will not be able to set it up in a parking lot – I had a friend who was sleeping with his son in the outfield of the local minor league stadium and he couldn't use this tent either because stakes were not permitted. I've set it up successfully on a platform (there are some of those along the AT – this one was) but it required a little extra work and some extra rope in my case.

I didn't know SMD was offering the Lunar Duo in different flavors (like the SkyScape). Brilliant move!

David
Take a look at the Tarptent DR.
I have recommended that to solo users that want a double just in case.
At 41 oz with pole and stakes (6) it is light enough and packs small enough (20″x4″) to compete with solo shelters.
If you want, with trekking poles you can have a freestanding set up but it is easy enough to erect on platforms (for example) just using the tie out points.
This is my short video on the DR :
TT Double Rainbow
Note the dry set up,dry entry and rain porch , nice when you are stuck inside on a bad day

Franco
Tarptent Downunder

With a freestanding tent, the pole structure gives the tent its basic shape. A nonfreestanding tent generally has fewer poles, and thus depends on the stakes to pull the tent into its proper shape. Accordingly a non-freestanding tent needs an alternative way of anchoring the tie-out points when you pitch on a surface where you can't drive in a stake, since staking the tie-out points is needed to get the tent to hold its basic shape. Fastening the tie-out point to trees (or any other fixed structures) is one alternative. Another alternative is to push a stick through the tie-out point, pull that corner of the tent taut, then stack a pile of rocks on top of the stick to hold the stick in that position. Or you can use a snow anchor (http://www.rei.com/product/725165/rei-snow-and-sand-tent-anchors) instead of a regular stake, and put something sufficiently heavy inside the anchor to hold it in place.

If you regularly pitch on very hard ground, such as slickrock or asphalt parking lots, a freestanding tent is more convenient (although you'll still want to find some way to weight down the corners to keep a wind gust from blowing your tent away!). If you don't, and are willing to get creative on those occasions when you do find yourself on such a surface, then a non-freestanding tent works well.

You might also want to look at the TarpTent Scarp 2, which is freestanding if you get the optional crossing pole setup.

I have the REI quarter Dome, the T@ size fits your spec really well. If you liked the half dome, you will like this even more, as it weighs a pound less (4 lb approx.) On REI Outlet, the 2011 version is being sold off at $220, which is a bargain. I actually have the T3, which is wider and roomier for two rather than snug as the T2 is IMO. Worth the extra lb (?) Backed by an amazing warranty – bring it back for any reason and they refund. I got mine at the REI garage sale as it had been returned as damaged – one pole section was cracked, no tears anywhere. cost $10.83 and needed a single replacement pole section at $16. Definitely the best bargain I have ever found.
The T3 is also on sale in the Outlet

Paul thanks for the heads up on the amazing sales at REI. I love REI stuff and would love to get one of their tents but the packed weight for the T2 and T3 are 5 and 6 lbs roughly. That seems awfully heavy to me. Am I being too picky asking for a 2 person tent for roughly 4 lbs?

Franco,

Have always been a fan of Tarptent but don't have any experience with them. I watched your video. Are the tents considered free standing? I can't tell (sorry if it's obvious). Also, is the floor completely separate from the top? It seems like a lot of wind and dirt could blow in.

If you're willing to go for 4 pounds, I'd look at the Copper Spur UL2. It's been on sale a lot of places lately. It's a phenomenal tent, and my choice at 6'4".

4 lbs is no problem but I thought Big Agnes tents run small so I'd really need a Copper Spur UL3 right? That runs $500 which is more than I want to spend.