Rainier: Tentless at Camp Muir or Sherman

If you get stuck at muir for a day or two a bivy will suck. I've taken a bivy to muir to use as an option if there was no room in the bunkhouse. Luckily, i didn't need to use it. These days i find a bd lighthouse a better option when conpared to a bivy.

Richard,
Thank you for your response. With the early alpine start that is common in climbing Mt. Rainier, I'm hesitant to carry much shelter weight when I'm only going to be sleeping from 8-11pm. A short nap…

Mike -What's the weight of the shangrila devided by 2 compared to your bivy gear. What's the time/energy factor of having to dig in worth. Why waiting until 8:00 to go to sleep. What's your plan if weather or physical condition has you spending a full day at muir before your summit attempt. Unless you are coming from altitude, a day acclimatizing at 10k' is not a bad idea. Ask your question at cascadeclimbers.com in the newbies or rainier section and see what people say.

carrying an extra 2-3 lbs of tent for 3-5 hours …
v.s.
not carrying extra 2-3 lbs and lots of extra work at Muir …

no brainer for me.
I would be taking the tent.
but I like to be prepared for things.

ShangriLa ? not familiar with it but sounds like a fair weather item.
I have been at Muir when it was so windy our tent was practically ripped away from us … and that was in July. You just never know.

but I've only been there twice, so I'm not a Rainier expert.

In wind I sleep better in a bivy than a tent because I'm not worried. You only need about 8" of windbreak if that, just to keep the wind pressure from compressing the bag.

Snow is no problem while sleeping.

Wind driven rain, holing up for a storm, etc. a bivy would really suck.

Richard,
Our plan is to do a two day trip up of Rainier. Either the Disappointment Cleaver route (with camp at Muir) or the Emmon's Glacier route (with a night at Camp Sherman). Good suggestion to check out cascadeclimbers.com The Shangri-La 5 set-up is similar to many other "cooking/kitchen" tents that are floor-less pyramid shelters. I've used it multiple times in the snow with a descent amount of winds. The tent performs pretty good, but not excellent in high winds and snow conditions. The weight between my bivy set-up and the tent is fairly similar, maybe 5 ounces per person more in the tent set-up. The major difference is the additional hour or so in digging the trench for the doghouse set-up.
The difference in weight between the 9-10 lb expedition tent and the pyramid tent (20oz per person) or bivy (16 or so ounces) is significant. If it's really windy i won't sleep well in the pyramid tent. If it's really stormy and we're stuck in camp, I won't do well in bivy set-up.

@ Jim-have you been up on Rainier before? Or other tallish mtn's in either a bivy or snow shelter?

My experience with bivys is all in the Sierra or bike touring. Probably about 50 nights total mostly summer. In winter I've had some rather significant wind. One trip about a foot of snow.

I sleep great in a bivy. It's everything else where a bivy sucks.

I haven't tried this myself, but some 3-climber teams take something like a Black Diamond Firstlight tent, one person sleeps inside, two sleep outside, then if conditions get bad, the outsiders cram inside. I know the following climb is not very relevant, but Steve House and Vince Anderson have a picture of a Firstlight perched on a narrow snow ledge during their award-winning climb of the Rupal Face of Nanga Parbat.