I use a tent, sometimes double wall, sometimes fly-only. The only factor affecting my sleep system is temperature.
I'm considering making a silnylon jacket and pants to use as vapor barrier clothing instead of using the emergency bivy for this. This would allow me to wear clothing as extra insulation, but would add 5-10 oz and also remove the minimal heat reflection of the emergency bivy.
Sort-of winter (0 to 30 F)
Tested in backyard down to 9F
Exped Downmat 7 (full-length)
19" x 19" 1/4" CCF sit pad under hip area (might as well use it for something)
Marmot Angel Fire bag (15F down, women's bag which is wife's 25F summer bag)
Heatsheets Emergency bivy as vapor barrier liner (VBL) (sometimes)
medium to light baselayer (whatever I'm wearing during the day)
acrylic balaclava (covers mouth and nose too)
down jacket as a foot bag, inside sleeping bag/outside VBL
Winter (-10 to 0 F)
Tested on 1 trip without VBL down to 15F
Exped Downmat 7 (full-length)
19" x 19" 1/4" CCF sit pad under hip area (might as well use it for something)
Thermarest Ridgerest 3/4 length (maybe… extra insurance due to risk of inflatable)
Marmot Never Summer bag (0F down, 4lbs!)
Heatsheets Emergency bivy as vapor barrier liner
medium to light baselayer (whatever I'm wearing during the day)
acrylic balaclava (covers mouth and nose too)
down jacket as a foot bag, inside sleepingbag/outside VBL
WINTER! (-30 to -10 F)
Experimental, not tested
Exped Downmat 7 (full-length)
19" x 19" 1/4" CCF sit pad under hip area (might as well use it for something)
Thermarest Ridgerest 3/4 length (definitely!)
Marmot Never Summer bag (0F down, 4lbs!)
MontBell #3 (30F down, 21 oz) used as quilt over 0F bag
Heatsheets Emergency bivy as vapor barrier liner
medium to light baselayer (whatever I'm wearing during the day)
acrylic balaclava (covers mouth and nose too)
down jacket as a foot bag, inside sleeping bag/outside VBL