Dec 2, 2011 at 5:26 am #1282624
So my wife and I applied for a permit to backpack the Escalante Route from Lipan Point to Grandview Point in late April. We are both really excited as this will be our first trip to the canyon, although not our first big backpacking adventure.
1. For those of you who have hiked/camped this route, did you have free standing tents or use tarps (tents that required stakes)? We have an Rei Quarter Dome (free standing) and an MLD Duomid. I would love to bring the Duo as it is so much lighter, but im concerned that most of the camp areas along this route will either be rock or sand. (i could tie it down to rocks, but i dont know if they will be available, if we'll see strong winds, etc).
2. Water filtration: I have a gravity filter (made with a sawyer inline) and was curious what methods you used to prefilter the water. Would a bandana suffice as a prefilter? (i understand that i will need to backwash in the field frequently to prevent clogs)
I appreciate any info/insights you can provide.
~AidanDec 2, 2011 at 7:11 am #1807893
David ChenaultBPL Member
@davecLocale: The West Slope
I've done only the western 2/3s of your hike, but reckon I can comment anyway.
Prefiltering won't be necessary when getting water from side canyons and springs. It will when filtering from the Colorado. The Bandana should work fine, with frequent back flushing. I always used drops myself.
You're right that stakes are often not much use in the canyon. You'll most likely to camping on either sand or hardpack. Rocks tend to be very abundant. I always used a tarp in the Grand Canyon, and finding things to use as deadmen was never hard. A few sand stakes might be good insurance against a night when you don't want to hunt rocks.
Have a fun trip, the hike up from the river to Grandview is one of my favorite stretches.Dec 11, 2011 at 6:25 pm #1811049
Most of the beaches can hold stakes, deep in the side canyons, not. Not sure how many days you plan but as long as you plan for beach camps take the lighter tent.
Water…plan on there being no water between Tanner Beach and Red Canyon beach. You may luck out but April can be pretty dry. Also plan on the Colorado being muddy due to the Little Colorado draining snow melt from the White Mountains. I bring a glacial silt filter for my spring hikes when I need to count on the Colorado.
At Red Canyon, about a mile up canyon you should be able to find a spring at or just above where the New Hance trail drops to the Red Canyon bottom (it is on the map). And then more water at Page Spring about 1 mile below Horseshoe Mesa.Dec 12, 2011 at 11:05 am #1811232
Thanks for the insight. We applied for 4 nights although not sure if it will take us the full 4 nights or 3.
I might consider getting some aqua mira for this trip and eliminate the filter all together.Dec 12, 2011 at 8:38 pm #1811483
I've done tanner/hance in 3 days/2 nights. One more for a Grandview exit.
Sites: Cardenas, Red Canyon beach, Horseshoe Mesa.
For your April hike, water I'd plan:
* Colorado River at Tanner beach
* Colorado River at Papago
* Spring in Red Canyon
* Page Spring on the hike up to Horseshoe Mesa
Any other water in side canyons consider a blessing. So take industrial strength filtration to handle the Colorado. Aqua Mira or Katadyn tabs will work for side canyon sources as long as it isn't raining. If raining these will mud up pretty fast.Dec 13, 2011 at 5:19 am #1811548
What do you recommend as far as "industrial strength filtration"? Will the gravity filter (sawyer inline not be sufficient at filtering from the Colorado? Is there something specific I will need to use?
Got my permit in the mail yesterday!! Woo!
~AidanDec 13, 2011 at 9:48 pm #1811884
i use a sweetwater glacial silt prefilter when I take water from the colorado while the little colorado is running. this prefilter can be backwashed, also dissembled and rinsed.
my experience is that a muddy colorado will overwhelmed just about any filter. MSR miniworks, katadyn, and sawyer. the sweetwater prefilter works better than anything else I've tried.Dec 14, 2011 at 11:55 am #1812140
>> my experience is that a muddy colorado will overwhelmed just about any filter.
You can also look into using alum.
http://wildernessvagabond.com/gcescalante2011/Alum%20treatment.pdfDec 24, 2011 at 4:03 am #1815525
@davelisakLocale: Grand Canyon hiker
Ditto to the remarks that have been posted. I've used both tarp and tent. A freestanding tent would be a great luxury, because the Canyon is generally inhospitable to stakes. Fortunately, rocks are plentiful, even on beaches, and with practice you learn to pitch either tarp or tent with relative ease. I bring titanium stakes, slip them through a loop in the guyline, and then put a heavy rock on top of the stake. I have weathered 40 mph winds with this method.
Water: Between your kickoff at Lipan and Page Springs (just shy of Horseshoe), your only real source is the Colorado. It can be relatively clear, if you're lucky. But don't rely on that. In 2001 I hiked this route and the Colorado was so silty that we could pump only 16 oz of water before we had to dismantle the filters and clean them. Fortunately, we were using MSR Miniworks and they held up beautifully to the hard work. But it took us hours of filtering every evening. Lesson: If you are going to filter the water, be sure that the device is field strippable and that you are familiar with the procedure. Then maybe you'll get lucky with the water.
Have a great time!
DavidMar 17, 2013 at 12:58 pm #1966704
Mike In SocalBPL Member
..reviving this old thread..
I'm hiking the Escalante route at the beginning of April and I am deciding on which water filtration to use. Since I am assuming the Colorado will be silty, I am leaning towards using my Katadyn Vario (although it is my heaviest filter) because it has a ceramic pre filter. I've used this in muddy water before and had to field-clean it several times during the process. I'm careful about maintaining the filter by checking and lubricating the O-rings regularly. I plan on filling a 10L collapsible water container and then filtering from that.
Are there any better combinations that also have a charcoal filter? What would be a good backup? Steripen? Micropur?
ThanksMar 17, 2013 at 7:07 pm #1966820
My son and I will be on the Escalante the first week of April as well!
You can check the color of the Colorado from the eastern viewpoints (Lipan, Moran, etc.) before heading down. If it's running clear, it will look green from the rim. If it's brown, it'll be cloudy. We're going to be below the rim for 8 days and will probably just take the MSR Miniworks. I take chemicals for backup.
I almost always let Colorado river water settle before filtering. I take a couple of 96oz Nalgene "Canteens" which are the collapsible/soft plastic containers with the wide Nalgene mouth. For settling, I prefer tall containers that stand up on their own. Make sure that the opening is big enough for the prefilter to fit. I prefer a closed container as opposed to a bucket so I can settle water overnight for the next morning; the mice like to 'swim' in open containers…Mar 21, 2013 at 1:03 pm #1968256
Mike In SocalBPL Member
Thanks for the advice on the canteens – I like that idea. I have a couple that I will be bringing on my trip. Maybe I'll see you somewhere between Tanner Canyon and Hance Rapids. We should have some kind of BPL flags or bandanas to hang off our packs – LOL.
MikeMar 22, 2013 at 7:23 pm #1968703
Say hi if you see us. We're easy to identify — short asian mom and 14yo son. :)
I hear the spring melt is on and that the LCR is starting to run high and brown up in Cameron. It'll probably make a mess of the Colorado below the confluence. I was hoping it would hold off another week so we could get a glimpse of that travertine blue. Oh well.
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.