This is my first post and I certainly don't compare with any of the brilliant and experience folks on this board.
Trying to design some Boy Scout projects I have used a 50 year old strong like bull sewing machine to use a size 18 needle , a zig zzg stitch w/o thread and the material folded over into between 16-20 thickness. (Makes tons of holes in a heck of a hurry.) I have tried this on $2.00 mylar sheet that require packing tape support or it won't make it thru the night, Sol themal orange bivy which also required strategically place packing tape, tyvek thema what ever which feels just great after a pass thru the washing machice, and finally Sol extreme Bivy which has the soft inside. I use these inside my bags when only wearing silks or liteweight polypros.
My conclusion is that as long as I watch my heat level just like you need to do in a bag, I do not sweat. I feel there is some temperature benefit, but have not quantified. I actually bought a heat lamp and two thermometers to test this out but that will wait until next weekend. Either the Tyvek radiant or the SOL stronger bivy which have needle holes top and bottom about every 1/8th of an inches is very comfortable and just plain nice to sleep with. ( I also loved my poncho liner in the servive and the mummy bag my wife made out of a "woobie" that also is a joy to sleep on but weighs over a pound.)
My upcoming "shade tree" temperature test may provide some insight but better men than I probably know how to perform a reliable test. I would be happy to send samples of the needle punched Radiant tyvek if anyone is interested. Regards, Paul French