Slightly sloppy 11 oz MYOG pack

Tyler that pack isn't sloppy! I think it looks good, and as long as its functional, who cares what it looks like!

Seriously, for not having instructions or a pattern, it looks really nice.

Most people place a seam where they attach the shoulder straps. This provides a much stronger connection.

As for roll tops, yes a thin plastic strip is often used for at least one side. Usually people just improvise. A wide packing strap from large crates should be flexible but rigid enough for the job.

I agree with John as well. Working off no real pattern it looks pretty decent. And it's a first pack…it could have ended up useless which yours doesn't seem to be.

My first pack I made was pretty useless and has since been cannibalized for other projects. Your pack looks like it will give you some great trips out of it.

1) The trick my girlfriend taught me that works wonders, especially on silnylon but not so much on canvas, is a glue stick. I just apply a decent bit of glue on each piece then stick them together. The glue will keep the pieces from slipping around much, you won't have to put any extra holes in already pretty delicate fabric, and once you are done, the glue just rubs off. For oxford though, pinning works fine. Also, you may want to give yourself a larger seam allowance. What did you use?

2) My first patterned pack was the G4, and for this pack, the pattern has you put an extra piece of canvas across the width of the backpanel, covering the straps. It works pretty well and I have used it on packs other than that one, but I plan to try just having a seam there on my next pack and seeing if that gives it a more clean look.

3) I've used the tops of ziploc bags before for a rolltop closure on a small running pack. On some packs though, I just don't use anything at all, and I think it works fine.

Tyler,
Nice looking backpack design for your first backpack and your sewing looks pretty good also.
Also most of us work on this mantra "Patterns! WE don't need no stinkin patterns!"
Most of us make our own patterns and do our research just like what you did from websites and other forums like backpacking light and sport goods stores looking at commercial made backpacks. It called reverse engineering as we use to call in the radio control glider forums I use to participate in and bulid my own designs and cut my own wings and fuselages.
How i make a pack:
I draw out how I want my pack to look like using my imagination of what features I want in a pack and the measurements in my art book . Then I buy poster board to make a full size side profile of the pack pattern, then the shoulder straps and hip belt profile pattern. Then I put pattern I made on the fabric I use a light blue Koh-I-Noor woodless colored art pencil to trace the pattern on the inside of the fabric for the pack. I use scissors to cut out my fabric leaving a 1/2" margin. Then when I am sewing the front ,Side and back of the pack together, I have a line to sew on. So you don't need a fancy rotary cutter just sharp scissor and your imagination .
Terry

Thanks for the positive encouragement and shared experience!

Liking these tips, gluestick sounds like great technique that I'll try out next time. Sil is just too dern slippery for my fingers.

I also like the idea of creating a nice sturdy template and drawing lines right on the fabric. I was worried about putting the sharpie to the fabric but I realize now that a creating a nice clean line, to help for a good straight stitch to cover it is worth the risk of some sharpie peeking out.

You can sew sil-nylon OK. Just use lots of pins.

–B.G.–