Hey … just wanted to hear other people's thoughts about stove vs. fire. When I first started backpacking (in the '70s), I used only fires, then progressed to the white gas stoves, then to homemade alcohol stoves. Now I'm going back to fires again.
In the middle of the summer, when the wood is very dry, I often go only with a fire. If it's tended carefully, and then put out completely, I think it should be ok, provided you don't make one in an alpine meadow or something. But in Eastern mountains, if you use stealth campsites, scatter your ashes and cover the site with leaves, I think a small cook fire makes good sense.
The best thing about a stove is it's so convenient in the rain. Sometimes I carry a tiny homemade alcohol stove with enough fuel for maybe 2 meals or something. That's kind of "emergency backup."

