Topic

Another PCT Gear Review

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
Hiker 816 BPL Member
PostedDec 8, 2010 at 10:38 am

I set out to hike the PCT this last summer. The plan was for my wife to join me for the second half. Turns out she doesn’t really like thru-hiking all that much. Thus, my hike ended prematurely after hiking about half the distance. But that’s another story.

Anyway, I’ve finally gotten a little time to reflect, and figured I would provide a review of some of the gear and methods I used on the hike.

I made my own backpack. It incorporated a U-shaped aluminum rod for a frame, which attached directly to the hipbelt on the bottom. I made it with Dyneema X gridstop from thru-hiker.com, and some of the heavier Dimension Polyant X-pac fabric. Generally, the pack worked really well. The frame did wear through the X-pac fabric in a few spots, though. The holes were small and didn’t seem to affect the performance. We just moved and the pack in currently in storage, but once I get it I will take some photos and post something more about it.

I started the hike using symblissity bot spot water bottle holders on the shoulder straps of my pack. They worked ok, but they interfered with my vision of my feet slightly, were a bit cumbersome, and allowed my water to get warmer more quickly than I’d like. I switched to a hydration bladder after the first couple weeks. This was heavier, but worked to keep me happily hydrated.

I used gossamer gear trekking poles. Very soon after I passed the 1,000 mile mark, one of the poles broke when I was contorting myself to get at some mosquitoes that were feasting on my leg, and ended up tripping over one of the poles. At the next resupply, I used some epoxy and a small piece of PVC tubing to repair the pole. Literally one hiking day later, I slipped on some loose gravel and managed to break the same pole again (below my repair job) while falling. I met a lot of people on the trail who were using the poles, and every single one of them had broken one of their poles after around a thousand miles. So, you’d expect me not to recommend these poles, right? Wrong! They worked so incredibly well that I think their fragility is worth overlooking. The swing weight is so light, they dampen vibration so well, they adjust, and then hold their adjustment so well, and they are so stiff, that I have to say they are just the perfect set of trekking poles. Grant hooked me up with a replacement at a reasonable price, and I continued using them. In fact, I bought a second pair for my wife. And 1000 miles isn’t that bad. While a thru-hiker will experience breakage, it takes a lot of weekend trips to hit that mileage.

I wore coolibar fingerless sungloves. These were fantastic. I originally got them simply because, since I use trekking poles, my hands get more direct sun exposure than any other part of my body (since clothing covers everything else). They worked well for that, but I found them to be even more useful for two other reasons. First, they prevented the blistering and cracking that trekking pole straps can cause after being out in dry hot weather for a long time. Second, they absorb sweat really well, which made them perfect for wiping sweat from my brow. My other clothing didn’t work nearly as well for this. The first set of coolibar gloves I used lasted about 1100 miles before needing to be replaced, which I consider great given the abrasion against my pole straps. The second pair developed holes at the seams within a week. I think the second pair was just a lemon.

I wore an Outdoor Research Sun Runner Cap. This hat is ugly, and I tried to remove it before anyone took a photo of me. Nonetheless, I’ve tried a lot of hats, and this is by far the most comfortable. It wicks sweat well, protects from UV rays better than any other hat I’ve found, and is light. It can also protect from cold wind reasonably well if tightened down, and keeps mosquitoes from biting my head and neck.

For the desert section, I wore a long sleeve Nike Dry-Fit UV top . It’s not on the Nike website any more, so I don’t know whether they are still making it. It was the perfect shirt for the hot weather – blocked UV light, wicked sweat like nothing else, and was very comfortable. Unfortunately, mosquitoes could bite through it with ease, so I switched to . . .

A Railriders Adventure Top. It’s relatively cool with the mesh sides, provides good UV protection, is incredibly durable, mosquito resistant, is light, and doesn’t smell too bad even after a lot of use with no washing. The only downside is that it doesn’t wick sweat that well, so it wasn’t quite as comfortable as the Nike shirt in hot environments.

I wore Asics 2 in 1 running shorts. These were amazing. The inner liner is sort of a boxer brief style and is very thin and fairly snug fitting. Before I found these shorts, I had chafing issues on my upper thighs. Once I put these on, I never had any chafing again. They also have no zippers, so there is nothing to rub strangely under a hipbelt.

I sleep much better when I am (relatively) clean at night. Instead of having a dedicated set of sleeping clothes, I had two pairs of shorts and two shirts. I washed the dirty set out each day, and then hung them on my pack to dry. At night, I would use a small washcloth to wipe the sweat and salt off, then put my “clean” clothes on. In the morning I was already wearing my hiking clothes for the day, and I was ready to go. Although the cleaning routine took some extra time, and having a second pair of shorts and a shirt added weight, it was worth it for me.

When it was cold, I wore BPL Thorofare Pants. They were light, breathed fairly well, and were fairly comfortable. They are ok in terms of durability. I got a hole in them when I snagged them on my ice axe, but the hole never got any bigger.

I wore an old Montbell Thermawrap Jacket for warmth. This is a nice, light, simple, comfortable jacket that does what it is supposed to do. I like that it doesn’t have any bells or whistles.

For the coldest parts of the trail, I also carried a Western Mountaineering Flight Vest. I only wore it while setting up and taking down camp, and to augment my 30 degree down quit (more on that below). It was luxuriously light, comfortable, warm, and packable. It was a perfect addition to my sleep system when it was needed. It got left at home for the warm sections, though.

I started with DriDucks raingear. This worked well enough . . . until I stooped over to pick something up at a trail angel’s place and the backside split in a monumentally loud explosion. Luckily no one was behind me to witness this, particularly since I had nothing else on underneath since I was in the process of washing my clothes.

After that I switched to Golite Reed pants (no longer available AFAIK), and an Integral Designs Thru-Hiker jacket. Both worked extremely well, though the jacket is a little heavier than I would like.

I wore Drymax Trail Running Socks. I’ve tried a lot of different kinds of socks, and these are the best by a good margin. In addition to the fact that they seem to handle moisture better than most other socks, they are available in more sizes than other brand’s socks. I generally wear a size 9 shoe, and in every other brand I was in the extreme of the size range for the sock (like I would fall in the 9-12 shoe size sock). That always made for a sock that was too sloppy (large) or too tight. But with Drymax, I’m right in the middle of the range, and they fit great.

For shoes, I wore the La Sportiva Wildcat most of the time. This shoe fits me perfectly, is light, provides sufficient support and cushioning for me, and breathes and dries extremely well. It has a very wide forefoot, but a normal midfoot and heel.

I also wore the Brooks Cascadia 4 (they are now up to the 5). This shoe also worked really well. It didn’t fit me quite as well as the La Sportiva, but it did have a slightly longer and pointer toe, which allowed my Kahtoola Microspikes to stay put much better.

Speaking of which, the Microspikes generally worked well, but were not as versatile as I had hoped. They were very useful early in the morning. But as soon as the snow softened up, which wasn’t much past 10am, they were useless.

I wore the Symblissity LevaGaiters the whole trip. As far as I’m concerned, these are the best gaiters on the market. No cords underneath to wear out and need replacement, no need to glue velcro on the back of the shoe. They stay put, breathe well, and keep stuff out of the shoe.

For sleeping gear, I used an old BPL Arc-X quilt. It isn’t offered any more, but the Nunatak Arc Ghost appears to be pretty similar. I’ve been using this quilt for a few years now, and it works fine. It isn’t warm enough for a PCT thru-hike by itself, but seems to work fine when augmented with insulating clothing. If I were to buy another quilt, I think I’d go with one from Katabatic Gear. The Arc-X can be a pain to keep centered properly when I’m tossing and turning.

I slept on a Thermarest NeoAir in a short size, which I put on top of a 1/8” Gossamer Gear Thinlite pad (which I also used as a sit pad). The NeoAir is the most comfortable sleeping pad I’ve ever slept on, by several orders of magnitude. I never (not even once) felt anything on the ground underneath me. I didn’t have any problems with its durability or noise, either.

In the colder sections, I slept wearing a Jacks R’ Better Down Hood. This was well made and very puffy. I sewed an extra strip of velcro along the bottom so I could cinch it around my neck and keep it from moving around at night. Still, it sometimes shifted or fell off my head. In order to solve that problem, and get better coverage, I would probably go with a Katabatic Gear hood next time.

I used a Steripen Adventurer Opti for water purification. I used to have the regular Adventurer, but I had lots of problems with it, mostly related to (I think) the water being too devoid of minerals to allow the electric sensors to register that the unit was in water. No such problems with the Opti. It worked flawlessly the whole time. I never removed the batteries for storage, yet I easily got 2 weeks worth of use, even when I was using it most heavily. The only downside to it is that it didn’t remove or kill the tiny mosquito larvae I could sometimes see in the water. I don’t think the larvae can harm me (right?), but they are really unappetizing.

I used an Excalibur Food Dehydrator to dry lots of food. I spent the month and a half before I started hiking dehydrating stuff 24/7. Literally. It worked extremely well. I packaged my food in Stand Up Plastic Bags from Sorbent Systems (I used DMP35Z bags). Dealing with the company was like pulling teeth, likely because I was not an industrial customer ordering millions of bags. The bags I got are food safe, but are not approved to be submerged in boiling water. The company rep told me that several other people used these bags for rehydrating backpacking food, though, so I gave it a try. Maybe I’ll develop cancer a decade from now as a result, but the bags worked well for me. My favorite meal was dehydrated quinoa, dehydrated homemade refried beans, freeze dried cheese, dehydrated strips of corn tortillas, and a packet of taco bell hot sauce & olive oil. I could have eaten it every single night. The reason I decided to do the freezerbag cooking style is that my wife, who was supposed to join me for the second half of the hike, has a lot of food sensitivities. I didn’t want to restrain myself to her diet, so that would have meant cooking two separate meals each night. It seemed like going the freezerbag cooking route was the best way to do this. Had I known my wife wasn’t going to hike that long, I could have avoided the waste factor of using and throwing away so many plastic bags. The convenience of not having to clean my pot was pretty nice, though.

I also drank energy shakes from Infinit Nutrition and Hammer Nutrition. I had at least one shake per day, and they were great. They provided a decent amount of energy, tasted pretty good, and served to rehydrate. I preferred the taste of the options available from Infinit over that from Hammer, but to each their own. With Hammer, you can get the unflavored energy powder and add it to your own flavored drink mix, but I haven’t tried that yet.

That just about sums up everything. I hope someone finds it helpful.

–Chris (aka Hiker 816)

PostedDec 8, 2010 at 5:19 pm

Thanks for the great review. I always find these types of reviews where the reviewer discusses multiple pieces of gear as related to a specific hike valuable. Gives a bit of perspective in terms of how a set of gear worked together. I am also always interested to see what adjustments were made over time.

Thanks again Chris

PostedDec 8, 2010 at 6:27 pm

Those are great reviews, thanks.

Why didn't I ever think of wearing gloves in the Summer for comfort and sun protection? Great idea, seems obvious now.

Do you think there is a benefit to those gloves over, say, biking gloves?

Hiker 816 BPL Member
PostedDec 8, 2010 at 9:45 pm

"Do you think there is a benefit to those gloves over, say, biking gloves?"

It probably depends on what kind of biking gloves you're talking about, but the coolibar gloves are really thin and light — much lighter than any cycling gloves I've seen. I think the cycling gloves would probably be hotter, and the padding on the palm might get in the way. But I think the sun protection would be just as good so long as you didn't use cycling gloves with an large open weave mesh on the back.

I'm glad the review was helpful for some of you! Happy trails . . .

Jeff Jeff BPL Member
PostedDec 18, 2010 at 1:37 pm

Those coolibar gloves are great. I used them on my last few PCT hikes. Probably have 1000 miles and still work great. I was able to avoid greasy sunscreen on my hands.

Hiking Malto BPL Member
PostedDec 18, 2010 at 1:44 pm

What mileage did you get on your wildcats and what was the failure?

Ethan A. BPL Member
PostedDec 18, 2010 at 7:43 pm

Hi Chris, what size Wildcats did you wear and what size and width are your feet? Are they true to size or do you find they run smaller or larger by half a size or a size?

Also, when you take out the footbed, is the sole underneath it relatively flat?

Hiker 816 BPL Member
PostedDec 18, 2010 at 8:58 pm

I get a little paranoid about injury on a long hike, so I haven't actually taken any of my shoes to failure. I generally hike with one pair until I notice that they aren't as comfortable as they were when I started with them (usually from cushioning collapsing), then I replace them. That said, I probably replaced the Wildcats every 400 miles or so. I know that seems excessive. Like I said, I'm paranoid. At that point, the outside edge and heel of the sole would definitely show wear, but wouldn't be worn through. I didn't have any wear issues with the uppers, though I bet if you nailed it against a sharp piece of granite you could cut the upper.

I generally wear a 8.5-9.5 in around-town shoes, and a 10 in hiking shoes to accommodate thicker socks and swelling. I usually go with a 2E to a 4E width, or medium to wide, depending on the shoe. I wore a 43 in the Wildcats. According to La Sportiva's size chart, that should mean they are true to size or even maybe a tiny bit large. As far as I can tell, the footbed is totally flat underneath the insole.

Just so you know, the open weave of the shoe lets in a lot of dirt. Also, I did some long distance running with them and found that I needed to crank down the laces a bit to get my heel to lock in as snugly as I wanted. The tongue isn't quite thick enough to keep this comfortable at the top of the shoe, so I added a bit of extra foam there to fix that. I didn't have this problem when hiking since I kept the shoe tied a bit more loosely.

Hope it helps!

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedDec 18, 2010 at 9:27 pm

Great write up! Concise but informative with no nonsense — just the way a review should be. Thanks for posting!

I bought a Neoair pad this year — good to know about its durability! :)

Hiker 816 BPL Member
PostedDec 19, 2010 at 9:32 am

Thanks for the accolades, everyone. I'm glad it was helpful.

Just so I don't mislead anyone, I should add that I was pretty careful with the NeoAir. I used a GG thinlite pad underneath it, and used a tyvek groundcloth when sleeping. I packed the NeoAir in my sleeping bag stuff sack in the morning, and it stayed there until I made camp for the night. I heard of some people inflating their NeoAirs to use for floatation when doing stream crossings. I doubt those pads survived the whole way without a puncture. But with care, I am pretty sure the pad will last many miles.

On another matter, I just realized that I forgot to review the Symblissity LevaGaiters that I used, so I just edited my original post to include a short paragraph about them.

Happy Trails!

PostedDec 19, 2010 at 11:34 am

Thank you, good writeup.
I need to try the LevaGaiters. My Dirty Girls are good, but the velcro on my shoes keeps peeling off, even with glue.

Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
Loading...