Nov 27, 2010 at 2:06 pm #1265964
I was going to pick up either the flight vest or jacket from moosejaw on Monday with the 5x reward points. They also have the flash jacket (hooded), but I already have a MB ul down. What do the experts think?Nov 27, 2010 at 2:58 pm #1668400
Both are good, but it depends on your use. I think the Flight jacket is most ideal for summer or early fall evenings in the mountains, or other times where you wouldn't be prepared for winter, but need something to cut the chill on a cloudy/windy day. The Flight vest is great for spring or fall in the Midwest to use in the early morning, or to lay over your body inside your sleeping bag at night. fyi- I have owned both and ended up selling them because I prefer a synthetic jacket for summer and fall when it might rain, they weren't all that warm for their weight (which was several ounces over WM's specs for both) and I wasn't too satisfied with the lower back coverage of either.Nov 27, 2010 at 3:02 pm #1668403
I was wondering about that. I was looking at the cocoon synthetic stuff, so maybe I'll fond something else at moosejaw.Nov 27, 2010 at 3:14 pm #1668407
What I did was find some 1.1 ripstop from Walmart, get some 5oz/sq yd Climashield XP from thru-hiker.com and made my own. You're not going to like me saying this, but I didn't find a single synthetic "pre-manufactured" jacket that I liked. It's all over-priced, most of what's out there is over-weight, and except for the BPL Cocoon stuff, most of the synthetic jackets out there use the thinnest Primaloft known to man. You can save a whole lot of money by making it yourself, even if you have to buy a new sewing machine. Even if you bought one of Thru-hiker's kits instead of hunting for 1.1 ripstop at Walmart, and then got a cheap $70 sewing machine, you'd only end up spending about $150 max. If you already have access to a sewing machine, the cost goes way down. Sorry, I'm sure the BPL jacket is great and I'm sure they know what they're doing with the price, but $230-240 is highway robbery compared to doing it yourself. I probably spent $40 total on mine.Nov 27, 2010 at 3:35 pm #1668411
eric chanBPL Member
i currently use a MB ex light with either a 60 g/m, 133 g/m, 170g/m outer syn jacket depending on the temps … i find that using both together allows for better temp and moisture control than a single jacket, or 2 down jackets … there is of course a weight penalty
a few notes
– for synth jackets buy whats on sale
– that said get primaloft one if you can … its warmer
– size the jacket to fit over yr MB UL
– 100g/m prima one will see you through the shoulder seasons alone and mild winter with yr MB UL
if youre going to hike in the jacket wear yr synth one, it can get damp and sweaty … and youll just laugh like santa … down stays in the pack except for cold stops and camp in which case it goes under the synthNov 27, 2010 at 4:13 pm #1668426
Mark HudsonBPL Member
@vesteroidLocale: Eastern Sierras
I have both of these and am very happy with them. I am no expert, but I find the jacket extremely warm and packs down very well.Nov 27, 2010 at 4:18 pm #1668431
Eric, any suggestions as to which ones? cocoon, nano puff, etc.?Nov 27, 2010 at 4:19 pm #1668433
Thanks, Mark. I have a WM megalite and love it. Thanks for the input!Nov 27, 2010 at 4:38 pm #1668443
eric chanBPL Member
landon … micropuff if you want a single all round synth garment … or the EB FA igniter … you should be able to find either for around $150 on sale if you wait/shop around
EB has the advantage of crazy sales at certain timesNov 30, 2010 at 8:45 am #1669340
Depends. The Flight jacket is ridiculously warm for the weight; for comparison, it's a hair lighter than a Patagonia Down Sweater, but probably has more than double the loft. If you want something warm for shoulder season or moderate winter camping, a great option.
The Flight vest easily takes me through 3-seasons & is a great layering piece in winter. I like vests b/c you can keep the core warm but get some automatic venting.
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.